Nigahenmilaneko-Twinkle or Meenal

I have watched Meenal performance and Have heard Twinkle's song(Thanks to Dizzy Banana for Uploading)

My unbiased choice is Twinkle

I watched Meenal's performance on 'Nigahe milane ko' today. I must say Twinkle did a better job with this song.

I am sorry but meenal rocked

I don't know why, but I hate Meenal's voice. Its too husky. Her last weeks performance was just unbearable.

Originally posted by: jmn7

I think adwarakanath loses his head when writing about Twinkle.He can only do that.Twinkle is older than him.All the other singers were wet in that video.Some of them were good.

Ash is older than Abhi(shek) too.

"Na umr ki seema ho,

na janmo ka ho bandhan,

Jab pyar kare koyi

To dekhe keval maan (slightly different for Abhilash though 😉)

Where did you all see the video , I did not see it yet.

Originally posted by: jmn7

Abhishek Bachan is born in 1973.He is 33 years old now.He is elder than aishwarya Rai.It is for publicity sake that he is projected as 30 years old.

What???????????????????????????????????

Amitabh Bachchan and Jaya Bhaduri got married in 1973. So, whats your point. 😡

Don't spread false information about the Bachchan family.

I think there were a couple of songs in common between Meenal and Twinkle and my unbiased opinion says that Twinkle was far better than Meenal. Twinkle can bring the feel to the song but Meenal fails to do so every time.

Originally posted by: apparaohoare

Ash is older than Abhi(shek) too.

"Na umr ki seema ho,

na janmo ka ho bandhan,

Jab pyar kare koyi

To dekhe keval maan (slightly different for Abhilash though 😉)

Where did you all see the video , I did not see it yet.

Yeah, what video is this? What? Ash is with Abhisek now. I am behind in my Bollywood news. What happened to Vivek? I read somewhere that Ash is '73 born, Abhisek is '74 born. Vivek was also younger than her. Karishma is '75 born.

I dont remember Twinkle's version and I haven't watched Meenal's rendition of this song.
I do, however, remember Sneha Pant singing this song in the old SRGM and would like to throw her name into the hat. Were these two better than Sneha?