Sonu Nigam on Karunya - Page 4

Originally posted by: bapigua

Even if osama bin laden was from assam he would be their home town hero. they will choose any body over a good singer to see their home boy win no matter how bad he is. public voting does not mean justice. if a celebrity commits a crime some people might sympathize with him or her any way and would not want to see him or her punished. thats why justice department is not handled by public voting. imagine if white people were allowed to decide martin luther kings fate in 1960 they surely would put him to prison or death even though it would not be justice. public voting is only for making money for big corporations. they are playing with poor people's emotions and making them even poorer.

Bapigua,

Man you make me laugh sometimes. not this time. Dont insult Assam's intelligence.

Originally posted by: MusicIsDivine

I agree, Hemu voice does something to you (at least to me) - it touches your (my) heart - it is not just his talent and training - there is something magical about his voice. I like Karunya's singing too but Hemu is all jaaadu...😳

Totally agree. Hemu's voice quality is super. When I listen to both of their songs in the Telugu movie Vamsham, I feel that hemachandra sounds more like 19 than Karunya who has a really nice voice too, its original.

But I cant imagine Karunya singing for any of the current Bollywood actors who look gruffy and manly. I mean picture Karunya singing Right Here Right Now for Abhishek, it would sound funny !!

Hemu has that advantage, his voice is more suited to a lot of conventional actors in both Bollywood and Tollywood. Another advantage he has over Karunya is karunya can go crazy with pitches but then again, his voice sounds good only for Romantic tracks (Note I said SOUNDS good, not commenting on his singing). His speciality however is to make even a Sukhwinder number sound nice n sweet vs the power in it. Thats what I felt when I heard Kavah Kavah. I've heard that song in clubs and its a good dance track. He made it sound like a normal song which is great. Hemu on the other hang does the opposite, makes boring songs sound extra ordinary.

Its very hard to say who is better or not. I really wish they all do a concert togehter, II and SRGMP finalists !!

Just a small info, today Marc 1st is Karunya's 20th B'day !! Is that why people r discussin him so much ?!

Actually i was stunned when Sonu called him the top singer he has seen in competitions. After all if he was being sincere, he is putting him above Mohd. Vakil, Parthiv, Rahul vaidya, etc. That is why I started this topic.
I didnt know it was his birthday today. Happy Birthday to him

I like Karunya but Hema's singing has touched my heart more.

Originally posted by: raghav64

Actually i was stunned when Sonu called him the top singer he has seen in competitions. After all if he was being sincere, he is putting him above Mohd. Vakil, Parthiv, Rahul vaidya, etc. That is why I started this topic.
I didnt know it was his birthday today. Happy Birthday to him

I don't think he REALLY meant he was THE best. I think he was trying to educate the voters a little. I guess he wants the show to have a little more credibility, and a REAL singer to win (Amey or Karunya).

Originally posted by: ab_srgmp

I don't think he REALLY meant he was THE best. I think he was trying to educate the voters a little. I guess he wants the show to have a little more credibility, and a REAL singer to win (Amey or Karunya).

I think that is what he said though. I agree with you about why he said that. However he is careful with his words unlike other judges/mentors so I give his word some weight.

Originally posted by: raghav64

I think that is what he said though. I agree with you about why he said that. However he is careful with his words unlike other judges/mentors so I give his word some weight.

Could be. I just started watching 4 weeks back. Then I am surprised at his comments for another contestant. Will PM you this contestants name.

Originally posted by: ab_srgmp

I don't think he REALLY meant he was THE best. I think he was trying to educate the voters a little. I guess he wants the show to have a little more credibility, and a REAL singer to win (Amey or Karunya).

Agree!! I think he was just trying to emphasise that Karunya is one of the best singers on the show, and urging people not to let him slide into the bottom 3 every time.

It is difficult to beleive that after the kind of talent he has witnessed in his years of hosting Sa R Ga Ma, he would identify Karunya as the best singer after hearing him sing just 8-10 times.

He does make singing look so easy though. It is effortless. Eeven Hema was like that.

Karunya is no doubt good,even better than Amey.But no comparison with Hrishikesh,sharib,they are greatest.