Real Challenge to Top 5 - Page 2

Mind-blowing 👏. Agree with you - this taboo of versatility is a hoax.

Originally posted by: preeti_l

OK....here is my list:

1. Vinit: Jalte hai jiske liye (Talat Mehmood)I do not think he has sung this type of song b4....wud love to hear him sing it.

2. Debojit: Jiya dhadak dhadak jaaye (to test whether he can sing the variation in the antara)

3. Hema: Laaga chunri mein daag....no doubt he wud be able to do justice to it. it wud be a pleasure to hear him sing this one.

4. Himani: Tanha tanha yahan pe jeena (Rangeela)

5. Nihira: Jiya jale jaan jale (Dil Se)

I believe every singer has his/her own category of songs that they excel at, and it is not necessary for them to prove that they can sing every type of song. So I would not want to give them something against what is their forte just to prove that they are versatile. Just my opinion 😊 The main factor in my choices above is that I would love to hear them sing these songs 😊

Preeti, I like your thoughts. OK let me give 2 lists now, one that I think will be a little difficult for the challengers and their genre, and one I think that they will do perfect justice to and will do absolutely wonderful:

Challenge
----------

Nihira - As already mentioned, would like to see her handle 'Aitaraaz yaar ka' (Aitaraaz)
Himani - 'Chhalka chhalka re' (Saathiya)
Hemachandra - Very difficult to challenge Hemu's voice, but may be 'Rang de basanti' (Rang de basanti)
Debojit - 'Laagi tumse man ki lagan' (Paap)
Vinit - 'Yeh jo des hai tera' (Swades)


Will do very well in
---------------------

Nihira - 'Piya tose naina laage re' (Guide), Also 'Pal pal hai bhari' (Swades)
Himani - 'Seekho na naino ki bhasha piya' (Shubha Mudgal's Ab ke sawan album), Also 'Lambi judai' (Hero)
Hemachandra - 'Naghme hai, shikwe hai' (Yaadein), Also 'Tadap tadap ke' (Hum dil de chuke sanam)
Debojit - 'Surmai shaam is tarah aaye' (Lekin)
Vinit - 'Mere mehboob tujhe' (Mere Mehboob)

Originally posted by: soulsoup

Mind-blowing 👏. Agree with you - this taboo of versatility is a hoax.

Thanks, soulsoup!!

Originally posted by: jayc1234

Preeti, I like your thoughts. OK let me give 2 lists now, one that I think will be a little difficult for the challengers and their genre, and one I think that they will do perfect justice to and will do absolutely wonderful:

Challenge
----------

Nihira - As already mentioned, would like to see her handle 'Aitaraaz yaar ka' (Aitaraaz)
Himani - 'Chhalka chhalka re' (Saathiya)
Hemachandra - Very difficult to challenge Hemu's voice, but may be 'Rang de basanti' (Rang de basanti)
Debojit - 'Laagi tumse man ki lagan' (Paap)
Vinit - 'Yeh jo des hai tera' (Swades)


Will do very well in
---------------------

Nihira - 'Piya tose naina laage re' (Guide), Also 'Pal pal hai bhari' (Swades)
Himani - 'Seekho na naino ki bhasha piya' (Shubha Mudgal's Ab ke sawan album), Also 'Lambi judai' (Hero)
Hemachandra - 'Naghme hai, shikwe hai' (Yaadein), Also 'Tadap tadap ke' (Hum dil de chuke sanam)
Debojit - 'Surmai shaam is tarah aaye' (Lekin)
Vinit - 'Mere mehboob tujhe' (Mere Mehboob)

Good choices, jayc1234!!

I too would love to hear all from ur List 2, if they do so, it would be MINDBLOWING!!!👏 👏 😉

its a good topic..
i would love to see

Himani singing "Zara zara from RHMDM"

Hema(i am sure he can sing ny song, beautifully)singing "madhuvan mein radhika"

nihira singing " mehboob mere from fiza"

debojit singing " saathiya title song"

vinit singing as some1 already mentioned " jalte hein jiske liye from sujata"

Nihira-Pani pani re(Maachis)

Himani--O mere sona re

Debu-Mehbooba Oh Mehbooba(Sholay)

Vinit--Dil keh raha hai(Kyun ki)

Hemu-Albela sajan ayo re

Originally posted by: bangboy

Nihira-Pani pani re(Maachis)

Himani--O mere sona re

Debu-Mehbooba Oh Mehbooba(Sholay)

Vinit--Dil keh raha hai(Kyun ki)

Hemu-Albela sajan ayo re

👏

How can I forget the Maachis songs - guys who will be the best for "chor ayee hum oh galiya" ?

hemchandra's voice suits for songs "chod aaye hum woh galiya" n "chapa chapa" from maachis