Senior Members Plz Analyze Amey Date

hi guys,

can the senior members of this forum analyze Amey Date, Karunya and Antara as they had beautifully analyzed contestants of SRGMP. I apologize on posting this topic here but on the idian idol forum i know ppl dont have much knowladge about this nor do I as a matter of fact but it would be very nice to have posts which could tell us the quality of these singers I personally find these posts very interesting and helpfull.

thx a lot in advance.

cheers.....

Amey - potential to be in finals. Good and learned singer. (singer - ****)

Karunya - potential to be in finals. Good and learned singer. (singer - *****)

Antara - potential to be in finals. Has developed herself magically.. gaon ki gori has become supermodel!(singer - ***)

Its sad that Amey,Karunya are in Indian Idol instead of SRGMP.If they had been in SRGMP,They wuld have given a good competition to Hemu,Vinit and Debu..

Antara has improved a lot ,Good singer but I would put Himani,Nihira and Ujjaini on top of Antara

Waiting 4 analysis by FarfromhOME,dWARAKANATHJI

Ya I agree with Bangboy, Amey and Karunya would have given good infact very good competition to Hema, Vinit and Debu.

But then again, I dont want them to get affected by politics like what happened to Vinit.

Amey has a brilliant brilliant voice. His Laaga Chunari pe is simply outstanding. His only flaw is, I can't imagine him singing for any of the current crop of actors. I can be wrong, but that is what I feel.

Karunya is Hema's cousin and very talented. His classical knowledge is impeccable and other than Amey, the only one whom Sonu seems to really like. However, he might end up suffering from the same thing like Hema. He was put into danger inspite of some brilliant performances

Meenal Jain is on whom I have my money. I think she is a complete package. New voice, good luks and a complete package. Hope she wins!

Antara is an excellent performer. I wish Anu Malik will give her a chance! Her voice is what anu malik would really like!

Just my small views