Created

Last reply

Replies

36

Views

2.7k

Users

7

Likes

25

Frequent Posters

digitalone 33 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#31

Originally posted by: Its_Sash



Thayyem is a Classical??? 😆
Yehi sunne ke liye kya maine woh sab link di thi...??? 😆😆😆
http://www.indianetzone.com/1/theyyam_kaliyattam.htm
Last try😆....if you can find any time do click on the link and just read the title. 😆😆


I rest my case..... goodnight DT 😆😆




Ok so its folk only..............................

Enjoy
Digitalone 33
Its_Sash thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#32
-Sneha thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#33
First things first, we NEVER bashed her! If you would remember it, I myself was SO impressed with the whole concept, NOT the dance, but the concept, until I logged on into the forum and saw videos of how it was a copied act. Now, you'll tell me it was not entirely copied. Does not make a difference to me. Remo has done it earlier to, using international performances, it still makes them "copied" to me unless you give credit to the original choreographer. Neither Remo nor Geeta ever did that!

Now my reasons:

1. The whole concept was the same. Changing the story does NOT make it difference. The whole essence and beauty of the original performance felt exactly like the copied one.

2. The costumes were nearly the same. She couldn't find any other costumes? That's utterly ridiculous. Krishna's costumes were exactly the same, and so was the Kalia thing entirely the same.

3. The song was the same, so were the background tunes. In some parts, I actually found the choreography to be somewhat similar too. So, that shows she does not have the creativity to try new stuff despite same costumes and song right?

4. The prop and lighting were EXACTLY the same. It does NOT matter whether it was only in the end, at the beginning, or throughout. What matters is that it was undoubtedly a ditto copy of the original act in those terms, that is, in terms of prop and lighting.

5. It was a duo act instead of a group act. SOOOO? Does that change the fact that it was the same thing? NO! No! no... !!


After all this, if you find the whole "act" not to be the same, good for you truly. All I can say is that I was initially very impressed, only to be hugely disappointed by the whole thing about "copying" and then not giving credit. You want to take a concept, good enough, but man, at least put something of yours to make it special. Otherwise, she could just have shown a video of the previous act!


sunandshine thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#34

Originally posted by: Ishan.

<font color="#990000" face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif">Thansk for the video Sash , the song is the same , the costume is the same but there is no mention of the fight between Krishna and Kaliya , all of them are krishna and dancing on the song ! In Geeta's choreography , there was a fight shown between Kaliya and Krishna and how Krishna wins at the end !
</font>



From that dance, Kaaliya seemed to have gotten the better of Krishna..did you see how Kaliya gav a hard time to Krishna??😆
sunandshine thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#35

Originally posted by: sneha0601

First things first, we NEVER bashed her! If you would remember it, I myself was SO impressed with the whole concept, NOT the dance, but the concept, until I logged on into the forum and saw videos of how it was a copied act. Now, you'll tell me it was not entirely copied. Does not make a difference to me. Remo has done it earlier to, using international performances, it still makes them "copied" to me unless you give credit to the original choreographer. Neither Remo nor Geeta ever did that!

Now my reasons:

1. The whole concept was the same. Changing the story does NOT make it difference. The whole essence and beauty of the original performance felt exactly like the copied one.

2. The costumes were nearly the same. She couldn't find any other costumes? That's utterly ridiculous. Krishna's costumes were exactly the same, and so was the Kalia thing entirely the same.

3. The song was the same, so were the background tunes. In some parts, I actually found the choreography to be somewhat similar too. So, that shows she does not have the creativity to try new stuff despite same costumes and song right?

4. The prop and lighting were EXACTLY the same. It does NOT matter whether it was only in the end, at the beginning, or throughout. What matters is that it was undoubtedly a ditto copy of the original act in those terms, that is, in terms of prop and lighting.

5. It was a duo act instead of a group act. SOOOO? Does that change the fact that it was the same thing? NO! No! no... !!


After all this, if you find the whole "act" not to be the same, good for you truly. All I can say is that I was initially very impressed, only to be hugely disappointed by the whole thing about "copying" and then not giving credit. You want to take a concept, good enough, but man, at least put something of yours to make it special. Otherwise, she could just have shown a video of the previous act!




For Geeta, all rules can be bent.. 😛
-Sneha thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#36
SAS... 😆

Jokes apart though, that's truly unfair. It should have been hugely protested against by Terence and Remo. Both for the butterfly/bird act, and for this one. You canNOT accept a master just taking another concept and putting it onto your own while other masters and their assistants work day and night to come up with new stuff.

What's more disappointing is that I know Geeta can do it. If she can choreograph that waltz on that roof house, forgot on which song it was, I can't accept anyone telling me she can't do good choreography. That was mind blowing in terms of choreography for me. If she can do it once, she can do it every time. Then, why the laziness for other episodes?
Ishan. thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 15 years ago
#37

Originally posted by: sunandshine



From that dance, Kaaliya seemed to have gotten the better of Krishna..did you see how Kaliya gav a hard time to Krishna??😆



SAS , whatever that is , I was impressed with the choreography and yeah that's all what matters to me ! And moreover Geeta had already given credit to her team so I don't think she wanted to take all the credit herself !!

Edited by Ishan. - 15 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".