There will be 4 finalists again this time

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

Its_Sash

@Its_Sash

Voyager

Posted: 15 years ago

#41

Originally posted by: charmz517

Any tragic story is heart felting, whether it is Shakti's injury, Kruti's father, or Dharmesh's father. Just because Shakti's performance was related to her incident, does not mean it needs to be told. But it was told.. WHY? That is a way for us to get to know something about her and connect with her better and I don't think there is anything wrong with that. Dharmesh's parents came on the show NOW. He has been voted on the top already and his parents were never involved. So why does it matter?

Screw the TRP. They will do anything to get money. We should vote for who we want to no matter what story. This is a dance show, so we want to support a particular contestant that does well on that particular weekend. 😊

See Charmz, I just want to say that I have got no problem with the tragic stories until and unless it affect the voting process!! Thats it!

Quote

charmz517

@charmz517

Voyager

Posted: 15 years ago

#42

Originally posted by: Its_Sash

See Charmz, I just want to say that I have got no problem with the tragic stories until and unless it affect the voting process!! Thats it!

But that's the thing Sash. It shouldn't affect the voting. Tragic stories will continue to be told all throughout the show. Doesn't matter who it is. Thurs far, I do not think that the tragic stories on this show has affected voting. Think about it this way. When Amrita's parents came on the show, and there were tears and heart touching feelings going around, she still ended up on the bottom. You know what I mean? I don't think we should let any of that affect us. If they deserve a vote then they should get a vote, not based on their stories.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

babli1

@babli1

Navigator

Posted: 15 years ago

#43

Originally posted by: charmz517

That is no excuse. Either way, there is still a sympathy story being told. Doesn't matter who mentions it. Granted that Shakti and Kruti's and Binny's parents came on the show before the voting, but you don't think people get impacted by it? I certainly do. I still get tears in my eyes when i remember Shakti's story, or Kruti's story. Whenever there is a touching story on a show, no matter if before or after voting, people will remember it and feel touched.

It is us who make things so political. Every show has touching stories. That is a way for us to get to know the contestants more and connect with him. We are all smart enough to know who to vote for without getting our emotional side involved. So why does it matter when and who say what?

why are u then not including D sir ka story regd how poor he is and htat his dad used to sell tea on stations and his guru didnt charge hte fees...I dont think Shakti and Kruti 's stories were generated, they were relevant, as the act Shakti did was related to leg injury which she had when kid....Kruti cried when somoen danced with their dad and it was natural....but where was need to show that D sir is poor, tell me

Quote

charmz517

@charmz517

Voyager

Posted: 15 years ago

#44

Originally posted by: babli1
why are u then not including D sir ka story regd how poor he is and htat his dad used to sell tea on stations and his guru didnt charge hte fees...I dont think Shakti and Kruti 's stories were generated, they were relevant, as the act Shakti did was related to leg injury which she had when kid....Kruti cried when somoen danced with their dad and it was natural....but where was need to show that D sir is poor, tell me

Ha Babli -- D sir is not the only low class contestant. We already know that Kishore, Amar, D, Vandana, Parvez -- all come from a background where it is tough for them and a struggle. We know all their stories not only Dharmesh. Majority of the people that audition have some financial drawback. For the first time Dharmesh's parents came on the show and all the contestants will mention how their family life is and the struggles, so what is the big deal? Him being poor, or anyone else being poor should not matter. Actually, the word "poor" is so bad! Let's not say that.

Quote

tarun.guptain

@tarun.guptain

Beginner

Posted: 15 years ago

#45

Originally posted by: yipee
i totally agree ...my top 4 is certainly amrita shakti amar and punit...

but am sure it will be D and binny...i hope we get a surprise frm zee if amar is in top 4

why they dont deserve??? Just because u dont like?

Quote

p.budee

@p.budee

Beginner

Posted: 15 years ago

#46

for me its punit shakti amar and dharmesh

Quote

Jess.

@Jess.

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 15 years ago

#47

Originally posted by: charmz517

That is SUCH a horrible thing to say! So you say the same for Shakti who shared a tragic story about her injury? Or Kruti's tragic story about her father? Are you saying all of them were using tragic stories to get ahead?

Wow, what an amateur thing to say. This is a real life dance show, and regardless of a competition, they are all HUMANS.

Please dont characterize the other member as "amateur"
Its considered a personal attack.

Quote

charmz517

@charmz517

Voyager

Posted: 15 years ago

#48

Originally posted by: Jess.

Please dont characterize the other member as "amateur"
Its considered a personal attack.

My sincere apologies if you feel that way Jess. I was no where near calling anyone amateur. I do not give myself the right to judge anyone. All I had specifically said was, "what an amateur thing to say" due to the post. Please read the bolded blue portion one more time. That is outrageously an unpleasant thought, even as a joke, hence my normal reaction to say that such a thought is amateur (not the person).

Again, the last thing I am trying to do on this forum is personally attack anyone. We are all on this forum to share our opinions. If you feel I was characterizing someone, I apologize.

Quote

1 2 3 4 5

There will be 4 finalists again this time - Page 5

Related Topics

Explore Topics