Ramanand Sagar's Ramayan or NDTV Ramayan? - Page 53

Poll

Which one do you like better?

Login To Vote

Created

Last reply

Replies

571

Views

31.1k

Users

24

Likes

333

Frequent Posters

461339 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: _LalithaJanaki_

How do you know he didn't consider any alternatives? Could you read his mind? He took the entire night to come to a decision. Though to some people this may seem too little, he had to take a decision before things went out of hand



Well let's see, he calls his brothers to his inner quarters, and instead of counselling with them, he just informs them of their decision, Lakshmana tries reasoning with him, but he has none of it.... and then commands him to take Sita to Chitrakoota, as she was expecting to go for a visit... and abandon her there and then.

Originally posted by: _LalithaJanaki_

Anyhow, a rebellion probably would have formed if the issue had been supressed. How do you think mobs form? First it's a baseless rumor, then it grows into something ugly.[/quote]

This was Rama Rajya, if you read the very end of the last chapter of the Yuddha Kanda, it says that everything was just perfect in his rule... no crime, no disease, everyone is content and happy and lived for thousands of years... ofcourse this is where original VR actually ends.



It was a rhetorical question, I wasn't expecting an answer... but a man who cannot provide justice to his own wife, how do you expect him to provide justice to any of his subjects.
Edited by Emptiness - 15 years ago

blue-ice. thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: cuckoocutter

lol now that's an astonishin admission. 😆so all along ppl sayin Ram is not perfect even when they dont know what the perfect choice wld have been?😆



I said that I don't know what is perfect choice for a God would be😆.......of course we as human beings know what a perfect choice would be for a human being....that is upholding the truth in any case.....but a perfect choice may not always exist/be possible.........like in the case of a starving child......we can only think with our limited brains and the reason why I question what I question is because I consider Ramji as a human being and not a GOD........If I considered him a God then I would not question his actions because I don't know what decisions a GOD would make.....

OK we are all beating around the bush now😆....like Lalita I am also out now..😆

karandel_2008 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: angie.4u

Even God is not perfect if we keep looking at God as a concept from a diff era. eg Indra, the King of Gods- there are innumerable stories that show him as jealous, coward, weak . Concept of God has evolved with man so there is no such thing as perfection.



I didnt mean Indra when talking about God. I meant one supreme God and other Gods like Indra are the forms of that supreme being.

I believe that supreme God is perfect. Belief is subject to verification and I will do that when it will be possible. 😛


463523 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: blue-ice


I said I don't know what a perfect choice for God would be.......😆.............what is perfect for a human being might not be possible..........thats whay I said that they MAY NOT exist for human beings.....doesn't mean that we all don't know what they are..........if we think with our human mind which is limited we know that upholding the truth in any case would be the perfect choice for humans although this choice may not be possible.......like in the case of a starving child........we can only think like human beings and that is what we are trying to do.............I would not question anything if I considered Ramji as GOD ...........I am questioning because I consider him a human being....

OK we are all beating around the bush now.😆.........I am out of this topic now......😆

lol speakin for myself n myelf alone, i m not beatin around any bush, but what bush u beatin around? 😉😆
so u r questionin because u consider him to be a human being. n u consider him to be a human being because u think he did somethin a perfect God wld not have done, even though u dont know what a perfect God wld have done. then somewheres u suggest that perhaps what he did was ideal (though u still insist without substantitatin that he was not perfect because omg u dont know what perfect is). tell me, is this soundin as bad for u as it is to me? 😉😆 or r we just emotionally opposed to the general idea of him bein avatar, so logic can now go for a walk?😉 if any of this is the case, that wld be ironic given the post on logic in debates that was delivered a while ago by someone holdin ur viewpoints. 😉😆
_Angie_ thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: karandel_2008



I didnt mean Indra when talking about God. I meant one supreme God and other Gods like Indra are the forms of that supreme being.

But I think its God Vishnu's avtar Ram who is being considered as God & not the supreme being . Hence my eg of Indra. However I do get your point.
463523 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: Gauri_3

So, what are we up to now --- kisis ka batcha bhookha hai, kisi ka batcha ghar sey bhaag gaya, kisi ka batcha ro raha hai, kisi ka batcha hans raha hai --- what does dharma preach for such scenarios 😆 Cool 😆 If this is what floats their boat 😆

Let's hear on Gandhari vs. Mandodari --- Lola came up with a pretty good suggestion for next discussion. I am waiting to hear from folks here on how they interpret the similarities and differences between these two women.

lol since this is obviously directed at me, hope u wont mind if i mentioned that the hindi bhasha evrywhere certinly seems tofloat ur boat.😆srsly if that is all u got outa those posts, i can see why u rely on the funny hindi for rejoinders😆
yeah, i m all for the new suggestion, new insights to gain into the frailties of the human mind😆
blue-ice. thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: Gauri_3

So, what are we up to now --- kisis ka batcha bhookha hai, kisi ka batcha ghar sey bhaag gaya, kisi ka batcha ro raha hai, kisi ka batcha hans raha hai --- what does dharma preach for such scenarios 😆 Cool 😆 If this is what floats their boat 😆

Let's hear on Gandhari vs. Mandodari --- Lola came up with a pretty good suggestion for next discussion. I am waiting to hear from folks here on how they interpret the similarities and differences between these two women.



u are righ😆t..........logon ke paas ab koi point nahi bacha hai to biwi bachhe...le aaye topic mein..........dekhti jao abhi UP Bihar bhi aane waala hai....🤣.......I can't believe that people start twisting the words when they run out of arguments.........I hope they sound as bad to them as they sound to me..😉😆😆
blue-ice. thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: blue-ice



u are righ😆t..........logon ke paas ab koi point nahi bacha hai to biwi bachhe...le aaye topic mein..........dekhti jao abhi UP Bihar bhi aane waala hai....🤣.......I can't believe that people start twisting the words when they run out of arguments.........I hope they sound as bad to them as they sound to me..😉😆😆



see I told ya.........UP bihar is about to make entry....😆😆running out of points....haan😆😆
karandel_2008 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
There is Ramanand Sagar's Ramayan, there is NDTV Ramayana and now here is the DM version of Ramayan.😛 (tell me if it offends someone and i will delete)

King Dasharatha opened a forum called Ayodhya. He had a son Rama who married Sita. They used to login together on the forum and used to like each others post.

Dasharatha wanted to make Rama as the global mod, but Kaikayi was jealous and she asked him to ban Rama. Dasharatha had to give in to the demands because of a past obligation. Ram, Lakshmana and Sita were banned and they moved to the forum Vanvasa.

Ravan was a miscreant, because no one liked his posts, and he started trolling the Vanvasa forum and always used to create "Sita is mine" topic. One day when Rama and Lakhsman were distracted then he trolled and hacked the account of Sita. He hacked the firewall created by Lakshman and stole the password. Now Sita couldnt login and was trapped.

Later, Rama organised an army to punish Ravan and they went to his forum Lanka. Rama tried to ban Ravan's account from all the forums. However Ravan had 10 mids (sorry for ppl with mids, I didnt mean to offend them) You kill one then another one came up. So Rama hacked into Ravan's server, recovered Sita's password and deleted Ravan's account.

In the end everyone was happy. They were welcomed back, etc
😛


Edited by karandel_2008 - 15 years ago
Roadrunnerz thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: angie.4u

Even God is not perfect if we keep looking at God as a concept from a diff era. eg Indra, the King of Gods- there are innumerable stories that show him as jealous, coward, weak . Concept of God has evolved with man so there is no such thing as perfection.

yeah I think it depends on our concept of God

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".