Amey and Debo sing the same song...

It is "Dil ne tumko chun liya hain, tum bhi usko chuno na....." from Jhankaar Beats sung originally by Shaan......

In the episode when Shaan was the Judge, He asked Debo to sing this song. Also Amey Date sang the same song in today's Gala in Indian Idol. So those who follow both the programs, please tell about your opinion of who sang it better?

Thanks.

I love both the singers, but still I thought Amey was better than Debo this time.

wow...that's quite freaky...i'm listening to amey singin it on indian idol right now!

haven't seen debo's version yet...but i'll let u know when i do...amey was pretty good

mani, do you know if could listen to Amey's song online?

Hey mystica,
Here is the link. And thanks to varmap for uploading it.
http://www.youtube.com/w/Gala-13/02/06?v=qrsvu0xu62I&sea rch=II2%2CGala

Originally posted by: manimau

It is "Dil ne tumko chun liya hain, tum bhi usko chuno na....." from Jhankaar Beats sung originally by Shaan......

In the episode when Shaan was the Judge, He asked Debo to sing this song. Also Amey Date sang the same song in today's Gala in Indian Idol. So those who follow both the programs, please tell about your opinion of who sang it better?

Thanks.

I love both the singers, but still I thought Amey was better than Debo this time.

Although I may sound prejudiced, but I am sure Amey sang it better. He is a much better singer than any of the langoors on SRGMP. His last week's performance of "Laga Chunri mein Daag" was scintillating, most of the SRGMP C-2005 contestants would pee in their pajamas listening to Amey sing.

I think Amey is a much better singer than Debo. I am an avid fan of SRGMP, and did not like II1 that much. But have to say, the level of II2 has increased. Good voices. Amey definitely better than Debo and Vinit.

Amey is a far better singer than debojit. BUT this song was debojit's song...it had a romantic feel, a softness he brought in the song was good. Amey may have been technically perfect and debo might have slipped sur here and there, but in overall effect debo was better.

I personally feel amey sang it better nothing to take away from debu he also sang it beautifully

amey was better than debo.. debo lost sur in 2 times,
but amey never..
and to say, debo was not given this song on the spot..
it was already prepared.. if u notice, he had to sing the full song and without the wordings, he cannot sing on the spot.. he keeps the wordings with him everytime..

BTW what happened to Karunya MPLji......?
I dont follow that show but you used to like him.