Stand By For Wild Is Cheating ;)

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

akanna

@akanna

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 15 years ago

#11

Originally posted by: orbittle
If you think about it...its unfair for the standbys...the others have had that previous exposure and have had that time for them to get a solid fanbase...whereas the standbys just appear out of nowhere...and if they do get a spot...they won't have a strong fanbase when compared to the others who remained in the competition...so they're more vulnerable to be voted out in the weeks to come

That's not true... There were so many members here who wished to see some of the stand-by contestants instead of some others who made it to top 18... Even with the wild card rounds coming up, many here were anticipating to see them in it.. So with the auditions itself, many like Jack, Melvin, Farheena and all had made a good fanbase... BTW, I dont see any problem with the stand-by being included in the WC round... At least we can see them perform and if they are not good, then we can stop feeling bad for them for not being selected in top 18 earlier...

Quote

orbittle

@orbittle

Inactive

Posted: 15 years ago

#12

@ Akanna

I don't think that we can take the feelings and opinions of the people participating on this forum and apply it to an entire population...I'm not discounting that there may be occurrences of those exact same feelings in the population...but it's not correct to make a sweeping generalization about the whole of India (or at least the portion that follow the show) to have the same sentiment...I was speaking in that sense...and solely in that sense I feel that they have the danger of being voted out...though it didn't happen last season cause the people who came back were people who were eliminated during the competition and not in the preliminary

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

akanna

@akanna

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 15 years ago

#13

^^ True... I agree with you that we cannot generalize the entire India based on the opinions here... Last season also they had Anshul, Tanvi, and two more for the WC round, and only Tanvi made it to the Final 7 for voting round I think... But none made it to top 12... But somehow I feel that this season it might be different... But then it could be predecided by the producers too... Also I believe the regional factors will play a big role for some, as there is no representation from certain regions otherwise...

Quote

1 2

Stand By For Wild Is Cheating ;) - Page 2

Related Topics

Explore Topics