Salman's Chao & Dharmesh's Thayam

phadukaran thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#1
it's funny, how Salman's Chao, was a wow factor, and despite there wasn't much, he did, but still every was wowed by it, but Dharmesh's Thayam, is a down low, just because it's not Remo and it's Geeta's gang. such double standards of other mentors, and Zee

Created

Last reply

Replies

7

Views

2.3k

Users

3

Likes

4

Frequent Posters

408098 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: phadukaran

it's funny, how Salman's Chao, was a wow factor, and despite there wasn't much, he did, but still every was wowed by it, but Dharmesh's Thayam, is a down low, just because it's not Remo and it's Geeta's gang. such double standards of other mentors, and Zee

Go and watch both dance again then open a thread. Where was fire in thhayyam. Both are different form of dance with different level of difficulties and dangerous factors. Dont want to put down what Dharmesh did, it was also very tough dance but I just wanted to point out that both are not same dance in any way.
Edited by ChupkeChupke - 15 years ago
petticoat thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#3
lol i dont think remo was complaining about a WOW factor!

anyway he said he didnt knw thayyam and wouldnt say anything abt technicalities..he was more into clarifying doubts...in THIS care remo was quiet and actually thanked geeta
phadukaran thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#4

i had Seen Salman's Chao, it had fire at the end, of the dance, but at first it was bit confusing, until remo told everyone what is it all about after performance , and if fire is the danger factor, then, Siddesh did fire act at the Finale of DID1, which was more dangerous then what salman had done. (he was standing on a nail carpet and had chain with fireballs, in his hand).

Dharmesh's Act was more of a posture, and facial expression and body movement dance, and Salman's involved more of a movement, foot work and facial expressions, but why even bother argue.

Cuz it's Mithun Chokrobarty, who will never understand D of Dance, and K of kya Baat, because, he gives kya baat to everyone, and as many over here had already said, that Mithun follows what mentor comments about a dancer and makes decision, and today he showed it yet again.
petticoat thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#5
^
i agree...i wonder why the crucial decision of kicking out a dancer on saturday is in Mithun Da's hands

on waht basis is his judgement..everything on whether he likes it or not...

oh well....janta ki kasauti is just going to make things weirder
phadukaran thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: carolinecj

lol i dont think remo was complaining about a WOW factor!<br><br>anyway he said he didnt knw thayyam and wouldnt say anything abt technicalities..he was more into clarifying doubts...in THIS care remo was quiet and actually thanked geeta<br>



well i am not saying that he didn't appreciate it, i am saying is way they showed Salman's performance as if he had nailed the Chao dance. and it was my fortune that i got to see Chao Dance, when I went to a small town near Orissa last october, and what i saw was more of a WOW factor and what Salman did was nothing compared to the Chao Dancers... but still got Terrance's wah wah, and mithun's wah wah (just because he was in a movie which had chao dance). one hand everyone want's to see variety, on the other hand, they protect their Contestants by letting them do what they are good at... Jago Geeta ab to Jago,
408098 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: phadukaran


i had Seen Salman's Chao, it had fire at the end, of the dance, but at first it was bit confusing, until remo told everyone what is it all about after performance , and if fire is the danger factor, then, Siddesh did fire act at the Finale of DID1, which was more dangerous then what salman had done. (he was standing on a nail carpet and had chain with fireballs, in his hand).

Dharmesh's Act was more of a posture, and facial expression and body movement dance, and Salman's involved more of a movement, foot work and facial expressions, but why even bother argue.

Cuz it's Mithun Chokrobarty, who will never understand D of Dance, and K of kya Baat, because, he gives kya baat to everyone, and as many over here had already said, that Mithun follows what mentor comments about a dancer and makes decision, and today he showed it yet again.

Comparing Siddhesh's fire act with Salman's fire act is also not justified. Siddhesh was holding the fire ball and Salman had fire on his body. Again both were good but can not be compared due to danger factor. I will suggest watch all 3 performances with open mind, you will find all kind of differences among them.
phadukaran thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: ChupkeChupke


Comparing Siddhesh's fire act with Salman's fire act is also not justified. Siddhesh was holding the fire ball and Salman had fire on his body. Again both were good but can not be compared due to danger factor. I will suggest watch all 3 performances with open mind, you will find all kind of differences among them.



well, i have seen all the performances, thoroughly, and follow on each mistakes and each pointer that mentors had made after the performance, because i am Choreographer of 11 years now, and i had seen many dances and attended a lot of dance shows, and stages shows, etc. so i do have knowledge what is a dangerous act, and what is a piddi act, but me screaming and you screaming is not going to change anything.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".