sentimentalfool thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#1
This topic is kinda random, but have you ever participated in a shipping war..and tell us your experiences.....did they scar you for life.........😆

Do you enjoy shipping wars?
Do you think ppl focus too much on romantic pairings in the HP fandom?
Do you like the way jkr writes romance? what do you enjoy the most..reading shippy fanfiction or reading canon pairings?

I don't there's ever been huge shipping wars on IF per se, but forums like Leaky and Mugglenet have had huge brawls between R/hr and h/hr shippers and it was so much fun lol. It was so bad that they banned shippy talks altogther:) have you participated in anything as such?:)

and finally what is your OTP? (one true pair- as in your primary ship)
oh btw for those who don't know shipping = the romantic pairing you support

Created

Last reply

Replies

10

Views

1.3k

Users

8

Likes

14

Frequent Posters

-Navi thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: VirgoVixen

This topic is kinda random, but have you ever participated in a shipping war..and tell us your experiences.....did they scar you for life.........😆

Do you enjoy shipping wars? When the shipping wars were REALLY happening I wasn't fully active in the fandom considering that I was about 12 so yeah ahah. But a little healthy competition isn't bad at all :)
Do you think ppl focus too much on romantic pairings in the HP fandom? Yes, romance is a very SMALL part of the series. But I feel like a hypocrite because when it comes to hp fanfic, I read ff's that are centric to my favourite ships.
Do you like the way jkr writes romance? what do you enjoy the most..reading shippy fanfiction or reading canon pairings? JKR is a great writer, no denying that but romance is not very fitting for her. So her romance was messy but that's how the pairs were supposed to come together. Canon anyday but I love fanfiction for what it is.

I don't there's ever been huge shipping wars on IF per se, but forums like Leaky and Mugglenet have had huge brawls between R/hr and h/hr shippers and it was so much fun lol. It was so bad that they banned shippy talks altogther:) have you participated in anything as such?:) I have on ontd (on livejournal), whenever any HP news gets posted.. ship wars always come up.

and finally what is your OTP? (one true pair- as in your primary ship) Eek, only one? Ummm, R/Hr I guess because I believed in them since I was about 8. But I love MANY ships even though they completely contradict each other. In fanon, I love Ginny/Slytherin. So fun to read :)
oh btw for those who don't know shipping = the romantic pairing you support

0o.Leah.o0 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#3
Lolx.....I have never experienced any Shipping wars as yet..

So....I will just start one !!

HARRY AND HERMIONE FOREVER !! (Fight me !! 😆)

Mazzy101 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#4
lol! i havent experienced one b4! im sure its fun though!!😊 i thnk tht hermione and harry wud be a much cuter couple!!! i also like the couple of lupin and tonks! i thnk its really cute tht she wud gv up thngs for him!! lol, if u knw wht i mean!!!!
Eloquent thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: VirgoVixen

This topic is kinda random, but have you ever participated in a shipping war..and tell us your experiences.....did they scar you for life.........😆

Do you enjoy shipping wars?

Hmmm...not much. I just like to discuss my fav couple. Thats it. All the huge mind-breaking debates pre-HBP REALLY broke my mind.

Do you think ppl focus too much on romantic pairings in the HP fandom?

Yeah. But then again everyone knew Harry was ultimately gonna squash Voldey-poo like a soda can, so there wasn't really much point discussing THAT. What was interesting was who was gonna land up with who. However I, myself, liked the debates on the mystery aspect of the series too, the debate on the Horcruxes et al.

Do you like the way jkr writes romance? what do you enjoy the most..reading shippy fanfiction or reading canon pairings?

Absolutely! I just LOVE the way she infuses her romance pairings with lots n lots of humour! In the case of R/Hr in HBP I was completely ROFL-ing all the way till the end when Won-won dumps Lav-lav. Even the GoF Yule Ball fight between R/Hr was hilarious! 🤣 Not to forget the famous showdown between L/J in the Pensive scene in OotP. JKR just manages to NOT make her couples mushy and annoyingly sappy! Remus/Tonks were a nice surprise!
I also liked the DD/Grindelwald revelation. It added a new dimension to the mystery that is Albus Percival Wulfric Brian Dumbledore!

Coming to what I like to read: I love to read fanfiction based on canon pairings. And it has to be well-written as I hate to read a crappy fic even if it is on my fav. pairing. Non-canon ships are out of the picture. And absolutely cannot tolerate any ship containing Draco Malfoy. Cannot stand the various idiotic fangirly pink shipping that occurs where that character is concerned.

I don't there's ever been huge shipping wars on IF per se, but forums like Leaky and Mugglenet have had huge brawls between R/hr and h/hr shippers and it was so much fun lol. It was so bad that they banned shippy talks altogther:) have you participated in anything as such?:)

Well, I just used to go to those forums (as well as fictionalley.com) to see the discussion and as far as I could read, there used to be a huge floor-length essay revolving around a minor point regarding either R/Hr or H/Hr. After a few such GINORMOUS posts, I would get zapped completely.

and finally what is your OTP? (one true pair- as in your primary ship)

Ah, my OTP was and always will be R/Hr. It breaks through all barriers and is my no.1 pairing universally, whether you consider the HP fandom or you consider books in general or even if you include TV pairings in the list. They are closely followed by L/J.

oh btw for those who don't know shipping = the romantic pairing you support
Lol, I used to be confused about the term but fictionalley educated me on quite a lot of terms! 😆

muffins2waffles thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: VirgoVixen

This topic is kinda random, but have you ever participated in a shipping war..and tell us your experiences.....did they scar you for life.........😆

Do you enjoy shipping wars? Not much, LOL. But I do admit that I get very protective of my favorite couples :P
Do you think ppl focus too much on romantic pairings in the HP fandom? Yes!!!!!!!!! HP isn't about romance!!!!
Do you like the way jkr writes romance? what do you enjoy the most..reading shippy fanfiction or reading canon pairings? She's not bad at it :) I think she's an amazing author, but romance isn't her best genre. And more canon :P

I don't there's ever been huge shipping wars on IF per se, but forums like Leaky and Mugglenet have had huge brawls between R/hr and h/hr shippers and it was so much fun lol. It was so bad that they banned shippy talks altogther:) have you participated in anything as such?:) Nope 😆

and finally what is your OTP? (one true pair- as in your primary ship) Ron and Hermione ;)
oh btw for those who don't know shipping = the romantic pairing you support

sentimentalfool thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: 0o.Leah.o0

Lolx.....I have never experienced any Shipping wars as yet..

So....I will just start one !!

HARRY AND HERMIONE FOREVER !! (Fight me !! 😆)


OMGGG YOU $%&8@%%!!!!😡😡😡 Go away you harmonian😡😆😆
RON HERMIONE FOREVER....!!!!😳
Lol jk. But seriously they are so fun, you've missed out on tons of goodness. Anyway, I'm gonna be back with replies for everyone once I'm done studying for my exam 2morro.😭

sentimentalfool thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#8
Edited by VirgoVixen - 15 years ago
sentimentalfool thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#9
Edited by VirgoVixen - 15 years ago
RamKiSeeta thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 15 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: VirgoVixen

This topic is kinda random, but have you ever participated in a shipping war..and tell us your experiences.....did they scar you for life.........😆

Do you enjoy shipping wars? Hmm, as long as they don't turn mean towards each group.😊 I think if people argue in a mature fashion towards each other, they can be quite fun but once people start getting defensive (as if the ship belongs to them) and insult each other, it's not so fun anymore.
Do you think ppl focus too much on romantic pairings in the HP fandom? Yup; the main genre of the series isn't romance, so people shouldn't get all super emotionall that their fav ship didn't get married in the end. Romance was there only because the main characters are teenagers and it'd be weird if they had no romantic interests, despite fighting battles all the time.😆
Do you like the way jkr writes romance? what do you enjoy the most..reading shippy fanfiction or reading canon pairings? I actually do; her romance isn't mushy or sappy, it's perfect for how teenagers really feel and act towards each other. I like reading canon pairings, since most of my fav couples in the series are canon.😊

I don't there's ever been huge shipping wars on IF per se, but forums like Leaky and Mugglenet have had huge brawls between R/hr and h/hr shippers and it was so much fun lol. It was so bad that they banned shippy talks altogther:) have you participated in anything as such?:) Lol, once, but I left it when it turned nasty.😆 It's surprising how some people can't take even constructive criticism against their fav pairing.

and finally what is your OTP? (one true pair- as in your primary ship)LILY AND JAMES FOREVER! I also love Ron/Hermione, Harry/Ginny, and Lupin/Tonks😊 My only non-canon liking is Luna/Neville😳
oh btw for those who don't know shipping = the romantic pairing you support

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".