Channel will give pref to SVOI n SCU singers - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

23

Views

2.2k

Users

9

Likes

18

Frequent Posters

198646 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: tinaasania



thanks for the info....i havent seen SVOI 1 or 2.....like I said earlier I didn't even know that Ravi Shukla had won SVOI 2.......I knew abt Harshit bcoz of Ishmeet's sad news n I heard him in JJWS.

also, even Indian Idol 1 seemed to have been most popular, so may be SVOI 1, shows seem to go downhill due to heavy manipulations.

also, if Gajji or channel had some hand in Ravi Shukla winning, they won't let him go out till semi-finals.

I agree with u abt what Gajji is doing, but finally trophy will go to Shaan's team,
after Himesh vs Shaan final.
So, it is all scripted n rigged?

Even if it is not rigged, you all will say it is rigged...so let it be that it is rigged😆
All said n done, I wud be glad to see Shaan Vs HR team.
Harshit, Anwesha Vs Vinit, Aish...my day will be made😃,...but I will miss Shreya😳
Edited by baddie - 15 years ago
198646 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: tinaasania

the predictability is disappointing 😔

enjoy the music n not the predictability of result😛
t3rmin4t0r thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: baddie



<FONT face="Comic Sans MS, Times, serif" color=#0000ff>You have put across each point very well and I agree with it all, excpet the bold.</FONT>

<FONT face="Comic Sans MS, Times, serif" color=#0000ff>While VOI1 was in its first year, a new step taken by Gajji, SRGMP had already been an established since many years.</FONT>

<FONT face="Comic Sans MS, Times, serif" color=#0000ff>TRP of SRGMP was bound to be more than a new show on Star. This does in no way prove or establish that C-07 was bigger or better than VOI1.</FONT>

<FONT face="Comic Sans MS, Times, serif" color=#0000ff>Ishmeet, Harshit,Toshi,Abhaas n Abhilasha all proved to be better than SRGMP singers. The GF of VOI1 was better than SRGMP( my POV).</FONT>

<FONT face="Comic Sans MS" color=#0000ff>So, saying that SRGMP beat VOI1 is incorrect.</FONT>





u r missing irfan too, he was just superb...
harshit and toshi unbeatable but sad that toshi has deteriorated too much since then :(
mintyblue thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: baddie

You have put across each point very well and I agree with it all, excpet the bold.
While VOI1 was in its first year, a new step taken by Gajji, SRGMP had already been an established since many years.
TRP of SRGMP was bound to be more than a new show on Star. This does in no way prove or establish that C-07 was bigger or better than VOI1.
Ishmeet, Harshit,Toshi,Abhaas n Abhilasha all proved to be better than SRGMP singers. The GF of VOI1 was better than SRGMP( my POV).
So, saying that SRGMP beat VOI1 is incorrect.

I do agree with you that we cannot compare a new show with an established one. However I don't agree taht the VOI 1 singers proved to be better than saregama 2007. I do feel that when a show is a big hit it is usally becaue there are different styles of singingon offer and a lot of variety. If you look at it that way BOTH saregama 2007 and Voi 1 had a lot to offer.
SAREGAMA 2007 - There were different styles of singing like sufi and qawwali style( raja and Musharrat), Sonu Nigam style singing and romantic song expert( Aneek), classical maestro( Amanat), powerful raw voice( Poonam) and sweet, husky voice( Sumedha). In short the top 6 had a lot of variety to offer, and they were all very good, polished,refined singers!
VOI 1 - I agree 5 singers were very good and had different styles - Harshit( he haad a good base voice, also was a big fan of Kishore kUmar school of singing), there was Abhilasha(very melodious, good at romantic numbers, great voice quality), Toshi(he was again into sufi singing and had a good classical base), Irfan(versatile all rounder), Abhas( very good at Mohammed Rfasi numbers.) Apart from there them was another girl Arshpreet whose voice and singing was very good, but she got out early. Then the winner Ishmeet though not trained, was a big fan of Shaan and had a good voice quality.
Both shows were big hits, but probably saregama was a bigger hit because it was established.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".