HR shld apolozige Padmasri Dr SPB/JYD - Page 4

Originally posted by: mohinis

guys, understand , he mean to say that for the south indian singers , its hard to sing, punjabi song, north Indian. thats true, for Sukhvinder ji, its hard to sing telgu songs and vice versa. So use your brain and understand the facts. 😆

Right!👏

jus dont understand Y is it sooooo hard 4 ppl 2 understand dis simple thing! 😕

Originally posted by: mohinis

Adwarakanath ji
for your kind info , on that day hr gave hemu, Ramta jogi, which has very much punjabi touch and moastly sukhvinder songs have punjabi touch. Aur apke kahne se kaya hoti hai, saraswati maan to pehle se hi meharbaan hain, thats why his music is so popular. 👏

ABSOLUTELY RIGHT!

and da person who never wishes 4 ne1s ill, always respects elders and supports da young ones!; can never av a down fall!

saraswati maa ka aashirwaad unke saath already hai n hope k always stays as well!

GOD BLESS HIM!

He feels very threatened amongst South Indians and that feeling of insecurity comes out this way. Even Sukwinder would not want to collect credits from him in this manner.
What is surprising is there are so many people with self esteem out there in Zee studio, Real Musicians. But why are they not raising objections?
Aaj Tak has got some serious job to do here.
HR - that's it Howl to your satisfaction.. There are no takers anymore for your 1000 tunes in database.

Originally posted by: ab_srgmp

He just made an dumb comment...Although he intended to give Hema a compliment, he made a grave mistake by saying the Great (SOuth) Indian singers can't sing Sukwinder's songs.

To be quite honest, can Sukwinder sing some of SPB's and KJY's songs? Why has he always seen Hema as a South Indian singer, instead of just a singer?

Just immaturity and impulsiveness on Hr's part. He says things for the sake of saying them. I don't think he really meant that SPB and KJY were not good/great singers. SPB and KJY have sung way more difficult songs than Sukwinder.

Its not something we should brush aside and move on. Every broom must know its corner... and must remain there. 😡 😡 We know that howler has got lot of newbie spies in this forum. Let them pass on the message to him.

Originally posted by: skw549

The more we discuss on this the more value we are giving to HR's comments. I feel HR needs speech therapy

tellus - I already sent to news channels i know abt ZEE TV's SRGMP show where HR criticized Padmsri Dr SPB/Yesudas ...Im not criticising any singers or MD's here ...Im criticizing ZEE TV for not editing such sick comments

Originally posted by: simky

Right!👏

jus dont understand Y is it sooooo hard 4 ppl 2 understand dis simple thing! 😕

so basically what u guys r saying is that it is ok to insult musical legends right? becuz trust me to compare a veteran singer who has sung in the industry for 40 something years to someone who has sung for 8-9 years is in itself an insult to the great singers.... they have proved tim and again in different hindi songs what their quality is... they don't have to put up with this sort of nonsense with an upcoming MD, who is just now tasting success. since how long is HR successful really? 3 years 4 maximum. and in that much time he thinks he has done enough to actually insult or even compare great singers?....i am not saying sukhwinder is bad... but HR was generalizing it as SOUTH indian singers r all same kind of

Originally posted by: TripleH

tellus - I already sent to news channels i know abt ZEE TV's SRGMP show where HR criticized Padmsri Dr SPB/Yesudas ...Im not criticising any singers or MD's here ...Im criticizing ZEE TV for not editing such sick comments

TripleH, Thanks for bringing this element also....

Please checkout the other thread opened by me on the same subject few days ago, especially the Game Plan I....

http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=196163&T PN=10

I will be including informing the press/tv as Game Plan II in the above thread....

Looking forward to hear from other memebrs on any other plans

HR really committd a blunder by commenting on legendary singers like Hariaran, KJ, n SPB. its totally uncalled for...who is he infront of those legends n their achievements..
what i feel is...we should all teach him a lesson, by demanding a public apology. i have said the samething in anothr thread reg same subject(by Taikoo ji).
i wish Film ppl down south too take this seriously, n take an action...
we can all write to news papers about this same issue...
it would be such a wonderful sight to see him aplogizing in front of whole indian junta..

Don't entertain vinit fans herr..they will come and abuse..and then mods will close the topic...So many nice topics are already closed...

😊 TC

Originally posted by: TaarCheera

Don't entertain vinit fans herr..they will come and abuse..and then mods will close the topic...So many nice topics are already closed...

😊 TC

agree....even if the bacchha party comes here...please ignore them and continue our serious discussion....do not deviate from the subject matter...period....