Is '3 Idiots' the next 'Sholay'?

ar78655 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#1
Is '3 Idiots' the next 'Sholay'?

The Aamir Khan starrer has smashed several box office records so far, leading exhibitors to smile and say, "All izz well"
3 Idiots has grossed about Rs 240 crore in just 10 days of worldwide theatrical business and may touch the staggering Rs 300 crore figure, according to most trade pundits, by the time it finishes its run.

(l to r) Aamir Khan, Raju Hirani and Vidhu Vinod Chopra


It has overtaken Aamir's own film Ghajini's collections, which held the previous record of the biggest business done by films in the post-multiplex era.

The film, apart from breaking Indian domestic market records, in this time has also emerged as the highest Bollywood earner even in the overseas markets. The film has done well in multiplexes as well as single screens despite its seemingly English title, which is considered a detterent in single-screen markets.

The film has given exhibitors a huge relief. Managing director of G7 Cinemas Manoj Desai said, "2009 had been very bad for exhibitors but Paa and 3 Idiots came and saved us. In fact 3 Idiots has created history at the box office and I can easily call it the new Sholay of Bollywood."

"In many ways this is a mysterious success. Everyone knew that this film might do well but this is enormous and cuts across various segments. It has come during one of the darkest periods of Indian box-office history," a trade insider said.

Trade analyst Amod Mehra agreed: "It took 34 years for a film to reach Sholay's level. This film is set a new benchmark for the film industry. The film will earn a revenue of nothing less than Rs 150 crore net in India and the business in the Bombay circuit will be about Rs 30 crore. The maximum a film has done in the past in this circuit has been Sooraj Barjatya's Hum Aapke Hain Kaun (Rs 20 crore)."

Trade analyst Taran Adarsh too believes that 3 Idiots has shattered all box-office records. "The arithmetic of the box office has gone for a toss. No one expected it to be such a hit and the way it is performing in its second week is incredible," he said.

PVR Pictures marketing head Ranjan Singh said: "This is the third time that an Aamir Khan film has worked like magic in the last week of the year. The film has created history all over the country and cut across all segments of the audiences."

Edited by Lubnavaishali - 15 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

30

Views

2.9k

Users

8

Likes

18

Frequent Posters

MalahFirangi thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#2
good news i like 3i more than any film
Ultimate_Shadow thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: syedaliayaz

good news i like 3i more than any film

first to all members : This is my genuine opinion no offence to anyone :)
3I is the best movie😛...last yr movies were BAKWAAS ! BAKWAAS ! AND MORE BAKWAAS!!!!🥱 3 I saved us...aree bhaiya al is well😉
Edited by Human_Torch - 15 years ago
415781 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#4
Oh I'd watch Sholay over 3 Idiots any day.

Its the biggest blockbuster of all time for sure, but not a patch on the Munnabhai films forget Sholay.

Sorry Human_Torchji 😳
Ultimate_Shadow thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#5
^^^
lol why r u saying sorry...u must be having ur opinion..😆.uh i just slipped to tell tht KAMINEY was the worst movie i saw lst yr...damn i want my money back..😆
no offfence to any...
-Aladin- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: -bluemoon-

Oh I'd watch Sholay over 3 Idiots any day.

Its the biggest blockbuster of all time for sure, but not a patch on the Munnabhai films forget Sholay.

Sorry Human_Torchji 😳

Please, 3 Idiots is a great film. Looking at track record of the box office, 3 Idiots and Ghajini are the top grossers, but that does not translate into them being THE TOP movies ever made. There are much better movies. 😛
Living is delusions is good for some people, if it makes them happy. 😆
Sholay is Sholay. Enough said.
Kaminey was an average movie, since some brought it up. 😛 Some people put too much credit by the box office, and some by critics. 😉 I don't care about either. 😛
Oh yes, why did I quote. I quoted you bluemoon ji because I would also watch Sholay anytime too over 3 I. And yes, I prefer the Munnabhai series over 3 I as well. 😃
Edited by -Aladin- - 15 years ago
415781 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#7
Chalo that is good. You don't like Kaminey - its my favourite film of the year.

I don't like 3 Idiots all that much and its your favourite. As long as we can be respectful about it.
Ultimate_Shadow thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: -Aladin-

Please, 3 Idiots is a great film. Looking at track record of the box office, 3 Idiots and Ghajini are the top grossers, but that does not translate into them being THE TOP movies ever made. There are much better movies. 😛
Living is delusions is good for some people, if it makes them happy. 😆
Sholay is Sholay. Enough said.

i agree....how can we compare sholay to 3I....they have no similarities😕😕
415781 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#9
Aladin

3 Idiots was also praised by the critics quite a bit right? But it still didn't work for me.

Kaminey did - I've watched it a bunch of times already.

Anyway my philosophy about this whole issue is in my sig (borrowed from a critic I like a lot but don't always agree with) :

A diamond is flawed if you can see a blemish in it, but how would you hold up a movie to the light to single out its flaws? It all depends on you, right — how *you* reacted to the film while watching it? It's always relative dude. Always. Baradwaj Rangan





-Aladin- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: -bluemoon-

Aladin

3 Idiots was also praised by the critics quite a bit right? But it still didn't work for me.

Kaminey did - I've watched it a bunch of times already.

Anyway my philosophy about this whole issue is in my sig (borrowed from a critic I like a lot but don't always agree with) :

Yes, 3 Idiots was unanimously liked by most critics and audience alike. 😃 Kaminey had great critics reviews (hardly a single bad review) but when it comes to audience, I have heard mixed reviews. As I said, some set too much score by critics, some set too much score by box office performance. 😛
Fair enough, to each their own. Kaminey is a bit too dull for me, and I know many who feel the same. In comparison, I have yet to come across someone who did not like 3 Idiots. Everyone either liked it, loved it or are obsessed over it. 😆😆 Similarly, Sholay has the same reaction. Hardly anyone disliked it. I'm sure there are some who might have disliked it too, as all five fingers can't be the same. I'm talking about majority here. 😛
I watched Rocket Singh and Wake Up Sid recently, two movies that I had not watched until now, and call me crazy, but I absolutely LOVED Rocket Singh. I actually prefer it over 3 Idiots. Funny, isn't it?
I guess it depends on our mood most of the times, what movies appeal to us. I am one moody person, so I guess it's true in my case. Rest, we are all different, aren't we. 😉😃

Related Topics

Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: JackSparrowcraz · 1 months ago

Is Sholay the best masala entertainer of all time? If not then name those films which are.

Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood · 2 months ago

...

Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood · 7 months ago

https://x.com/NagpurKaRajini/status/1894327775835684981

https://x.com/NagpurKaRajini/status/1894327775835684981
Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: woodland · 5 months ago

Oooh why are the claws out all of a sudden? 👀...

Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: Rosyme · 14 days ago

https://www.pinkvilla.com/entertainment/exclusives/exclusive-after-saiyaara-ahaan-panday-signs-ali-abbas-zafars-action-romance-with-yrf-1397263

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".