When Deb/Vinit sing Hem's Taal song.???

How it would be when Debo or Vinit sings Hemachandra-Mere paas hai from Taal. They can justify the song???

same can be sad how it would sound if Hema or vinit were to sing "Hundum suniyo re" you can't do comparisons like that. Every one has a unique voice.

Originally posted by: Dazlingflower

same can be sad how it would sound if Hema or vinit were to sing "Hundum suniyo re" you can't do comparisons like that. Every one has a unique voice.

agreed 👏

Originally posted by: Dazlingflower

same can be sad how it would sound if Hema or vinit were to sing "Hundum suniyo re" you can't do comparisons like that. Every one has a unique voice.

I think Hem can sing any type of song. if you are watch SRGMP from begining...Hem sang songs of different singers. I think both these Debo/Vinit can not sing all type of songs....

Dazlingflower, I too am a fan of Hema & then Debo. But Let me tell you Hema can sing this song much better than Debo. Debo sang well, but I really miss hearing Hema's voice in this song..
I think at the quarter/semi-finals level, all singers should have been given a same song.. Like how they earlier use to do at the elimination rounds - Jugalbandhi type. This will definitely help people to gauge the singer's strengths and weaknesses.. If this had happened, Rajeev and Vinit would have packed their bags before everybody else...

Originally posted by: Dazlingflower

same can be sad how it would sound if Hema or vinit were to sing "Hundum suniyo re" you can't do comparisons like that. Every one has a unique voice.

Originally posted by: Dazlingflower

same can be sad how it would sound if Hema or vinit were to sing "Hundum suniyo re" you can't do comparisons like that. Every one has a unique voice.

true u cant really compare like that but now that u'v asked, i'm sure hma could have done justice to humdum and vinit also prbably could have. personally i don't think humdum was a part of debo's best songs... he over accentified it.

Originally posted by: ComeOn123

I think Hem can sing any type of song. if you are watch SRGMP from begining...Hem sang songs of different singers. I think both these Debo/Vinit can not sing all type of songs....

Lets keep Hema as a very good singer, please don't try to promote him as a LEGEND. I am a Hema fan too but not a fanatic.

I believe that Debojit can do justice to the Taal song. It might not be as good as Hema but it would be close. If the singer has a strong classical background, then things become much easier. And both Debojit and HEma has a strong classical background.

I am not sure about Vinit. He does not have a classical background and thats why he lacks versitility.

If we look at versitility then, Debojit is no doubt the most versatile. So, this kind of comparision is just meaningless.

Originally posted by: MrspetloverUS

Appaji,

With due respect If I can make a request to you. Please do not call other contestant's fans fanatic. Especially Hema fans. Because when you say that it makes you sound more fanatic than any one else. There is no offence meant by this but just a request.

Thank you.

MrspetloverUS ji,

I try not to have a one track thinking. I have always appreciated all the contestants, when ever they sang well. Be it Hema, Vinit, Debo, Himani, or Nihira. These people are good singers and I would like to think them as just singers. When they are right, they are right. And when they are wrong, they are wrong.

How many times do I have to say that I am a Hema fan too. I try to write whatever I personally feel is right and don't follow my favorites blindly. After Hema's elimination some of the Hema fans have started behaving hostile, it was not like this with the Hema fans before. There should be a difference between a Hema fan and a Vinit fan. We should not write comments like Debo sux, or Hema sux and Vinit rox. Hama was a genuine singer and his fans should behave in a more matured way. I personally feel that it is good for Hema that he is out. Or else he would have been stuck with the Zee contract.

If someone thinks that I am not Hema's fan because I have said somethings against him, then its their personal opinion and its their problem.

Guys,

Let us not compare if Hema sang this song good,would the other person sing it same? That is not fair to any contestant.

Ei mere vatan ke logo : In this song Nihira was way better than Himani. But this song is not Himani's style. Nihira would not be able to justify some song from Himani.

It is like sayimg Phir wahi Raat from Talat Mehmood could not be sung well by Kishore Kumar.

Everyone is good in their own way, but as per singing ability and calibre they have to justify the song they select.

Imagine how it would be when debo takes presy node in that song(I think its about 15 seconds alap). 😆 😆