Rosalie & Leah

both gals have had a tragic past (obviously Rose's is more tragic) but Leah's situation is sad as well and that's why I HATE Sam😡🤢 both girls are basically treated like crap by the main male leads.....I wanted to punch Edward esp in NM when Rose apologizes and Alice and Eddie are like screw you and Jake's anger towards Leah and telling her she's nothing to the pack or somethingis just appalling😡 both were changed into something they really didn't want to by choice...and they're expected to deal with it as if its a fairy tale or something😡
• both girls have a LEGITIMATE reason to complain about their miserable existence...which is a lot more than a pathetic break-up which causes" a hole to be punched through some one's chest" (<--- that argument was brought up on twilightsucks.com...and I full heartedly agree with it...I mean Bella's allowed to complain about every single thing in her life but when these two complain all hell breaks lose?? WTH😡!)

anyways just wanted to know your opinion on these two characters

Originally posted by: fly_chick

Agreed- i love both of them

Rose is honest and like innocentdevil said she's right in her own way. Most of the charecters in the book were selfidh and didn't really understand Rose desire for a child- everyone wants to be a mother i mean esme nearly killed herself as a mortal for a child then found edward and everyone who she then treated as her own- rosalie didn't have anyone she could treat as her child right and both her and leah are in a situation they don't want to be in- they portray the negatives to werewolf/vampire life which is gfood because they're not a fairytale life right.

I like leah because she's emotionally hurt and if everyone (twihard fans)feels sorry for bella then why not leah- she's not to blame. Sam left her because of the situation he's in and fine but it's even worse when she can hear all his thoughts and the fact that he's with her cousin. When edward saw jacobs though when he left bella it hurt him and we all felt sorry for him, then why not leah- she constanly hears sams thoughts which would probably be aboput emily.

I disagree on the part that Rosalie is treated like crap. Its not true. They may not have shown it in the movie but in the book everyone loved her as a daughter and did sympathize with her always provided she always spoke in a rude manner. It wasn't hidden from anyone that Rosalie had a depressing past; it was only Edward who avoided her like a plague. The reason why he did act like this is also stated in Eclipse. He thought Rosalie was big headed, too proud about her beauty and c'mon anyone would find it bit annoying if someone throws attitude 24/7. His anger is very much justified for what Rosalie did. For her Edward was sacrificing his life to the Volturis. The Cullens would have lost a son if it weren't for Bella who traveled all the way to Italy to save him. This is not a random mistake, a grave one and she deserved the hatred.

Originally posted by: innocentdevil.

Yay a good topic!


Okay so i love both of them.


Rose because well in the book i felt everyone was selfish, they didn't care how being a vamp would change/affect Bella's life they just wanted her to be one of them, but it's not a life anyone would choose so Rose voted NO. Now all the fans hate her. She's worried because Bella might spill the secret. What's wrong in that? I mean she's worried for herself, who wouldn't be? Everyone else trusts her blindly but since Rose is worried and maybe even suspicious she's hated. Wow. I have to ask WHY people hate Rose so much. Examples please?


Leah: I just love her :)

Originally posted by: Ambrosia

I find it difficult to believe that people actually hate Rosalie. I mean her maybe not Ms goody-two-shoes but she wasn't exactly a bad vamp.😕 She cared for her family and the reason why she voted a NO is also stated in Eclipse. Someone who has not followed the saga and had stopped reading after New Moon only can feel hatred towards her. Because honestly when i first started reading the books she was a quite the "itch" of the whole books. but when i finally learned her story, i actually felt quite sad for her.

both gals have had a tragic past (obviously Rose's is more tragic) but Leah's situation is sad as well and that's why I HATE Sam😡🤢 both girls are basically treated like crap by the main male leads.....I wanted to punch Edward esp in NM when Rose apologizes and Alice and Eddie are like screw you and Jake's anger towards Leah and telling her she's nothing to the pack or somethingis just appalling😡 both were changed into something they really didn't want to by choice...and they're expected to deal with it as if its a fairy tale or something😡
• both girls have a LEGITIMATE reason to complain about their miserable existence...which is a lot more than a pathetic break-up which causes" a hole to be punched through some one's chest" (<--- that argument was brought up on twilightsucks.com...and I full heartedly agree with it...I mean Bella's allowed to complain about every single thing in her life but when these two complain all hell breaks lose?? WTH😡!)