Reason why Himani was voted out - Page 2

I think that Himani is no class compared to Nihira. I have lost all respect for her after she promoted walk out. I wish all three candidates who walked out should be disqualified. May be GS has special soft corner for her and that is why Nihira was voted out before Himani.

Well - any one who plays games will not become successful and she has lost respect in eyes of the public.

I completely agree, all three should have been disqualified for their behavior. AS & HR looked so...stupdid to me. They didn't even properly question their own students why they decided to walk-out? They both always came on the stage to get the Topi or hug their student(s) but in this case they were acting and didn't move from their seats. ID atleast walked and asked. The whole thing was planned drama. Himani loosing does not surprize me at all, and next Vinit should loose and then HemaChandra. Let Debojit be the winner. When the public voting is what is been counted for each one to walk-out then why they had to bring politics of which region and which state? It is so shame public's voting was not enough for Nihira otherwise she would have been the winner. ID only cared for Nihira and that is why he is keep on bringing her name, but even she obliged for public response and because she was told that she got less votes, she left without creating any chaos. And if these 3 were planning to leave at that time why didn't they? They didn't have to wait until Debojit got more votes to leave the stage. That proves that they never had any thoughts of walking out they were minipulated by their mentors. So, let them go to hell and let Debojit win. Personally I too liked Sharib, Nihira & a couple othe who were ousted out already, Debojit was never my choice but now after seeing all this I feel like voting only for Debojit.

Trueandlovely wrote:

In the beginning the show said there were going to be TWO winners and it was kind of hinted that there would be one male and one female winner. When people saw that Himani was the only one remaining in girls, they assumed that she was already a winner in girls and they had to pick a winner among boys. Unfortunately for the fans, Gajendra Singh got cold feet and maybe got a little greedy too and decided to give flat to only ONE person instead of TWO.

Does anyone remember it being ever said that there will be only one winner ?


I agree with you

well said musci99
HR & AS is biggest idiots in bollywood music ,i lost all the respect for them specially HR ,they make this show real dirty ,i have lost interest in this show,they cannot see when debojit got so many votes ,i hope debojit wins this challenge ,all the viewers please pass the message to friends to vote for debojit ,than only next time nobody talks about walking out in front of millions of fans watching the show to listen to music not watch this garbage on tv,one thing i want to see that AS really hit someone from audience ,if was sitting there i will break his legs for sure .
Kfaisal

Originally posted by: kuttakamina

But Nihira was voted out before Himani.

Only & Only coz' of DEAF people lke you.. Shame on you & all those like you.....

yes TrueandLovely
u are absolutely right they had announced two winners in the beginning but now they have changed donno why!!!!Gajji is a very unpredictable guy!!!!!!!!!

Well firstly I think himani may be able to sue given the original premise of
the show.

As Shaan did not make it clear that Himani was not the girl winner the
week before, maybe people stopped voting for her on that basis and so
she could sue for that.

Of course Zee could her and her cohorts for brech of contract.

IMO I think Himani suffered also because without Nihira as a
counterpoint, people like me got sick of hearing her. i think that is why
you rarely have a soundtrack featuring Richa Sharma exclusively -- not
that I don't like her but...

So Himani lost for a variety of reasons.

The only reason Debojit is still in the race is because of all those Bengal,Assam and other north east state votes. It's easy to draw parallels to Ganguly's selection in to the team under pressure from jingositic Bengali's. If Zee TV wan't to do it right they should not reveal the place where they r from. Also in most surveys the highest and lowest scores are automaticaly eliminated and other scores are averaged out. There are also other more complex formulas to ensure fairness in voting, but the current format benefits zee because it makes people all over India watch the show.

Anyway real talented people always find a way to succeed.

Originally posted by: music99

I am glad that SRGMP can disaasociate from the likes of HImani and her mentor AS. There is noplace for greed, jealousy and hypocricy in this great talent contest. AND THAT is WHY HIMANI is OUT. AS As said der hai andher nahi..yes der se out hua...better Himani got voted out before she caused more damage to the show. Now Hema should go under ID and AS should be booted out to share in Himani's misery.
I am very disturbed BY AS and HR too when they cheered that stupid lady from the audience who alluded that Assam's voice does not mean India's voice.Shame on her and her backers. No wonder goras could easily divide and rule India. I liked debu but never voted for him. Now I am going all out to ensure that Debo wins...to prove that Assam's voice can be INDIA's voice. To hell with AS and HR. MOderators please do not edit out my commenets. Even Gajendraji showed on the show all the dirty politics of As and HR.

UR A FKN LIAR.. SHES OUT COZ EVRI1 THORT THERE WERE 2 WINNERS SO NO1 VOTED 4 HER COZ SHE WAZ THE LAST GURL LEFT.. DNT U DARE EVA INSULT HIMANI.. UR A STOOPID LOW LYF IF U HAD THE GUTZ 2 SAY THAT..