My take on samrat-suhani's past

sajanFan thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#1
We all know by now that samrat hates suhani ( as told by suhani to gunjan). We also know that they shared a very gud bro-sis bond till some point when they were kids...
Also it looks like samrat was also in London when he was kid ( suhani was saying to him in car 'looks like u know london very well.....' or something like this .....)
Also for all we know is suhani is from london.
Now some questions which most of us have in mind:
1. When did samrat come back from london?
2. what turned samrat to hate his sis who till some point loved her so much?
3. Is samrat younger or elder to suhani ?
My analysis on this track:
Samrat may be the adopted kid on Mr & Mrs. Shergill( samrat-suhani's parents). Suhani may be their only biological daughter. Later they adopted samrat ( lets not dig the reason for adoption 😉)
Usually when we are kids we all will be unaware about such sensitive issues like own parents, siblings etc.
Same must be the case with suhani-samrat. They both were totally unaware of them being not own bro-sis. And they enjoyed their childhood together till some extent. Until unfortunately may be when samrat was around 8 yrs, suhani came to know somehow that samrat is not her own lil bro but an adopted one . ( this age guess is from samrat's own statement that he loved vacations till he was 8 yr old or soemthing 😉 ) . By then suhani must be some 11 yr old. At the age of 11 , we tend to take such things lil more seriously .
May be soon she started distancing from him and then there is a possibility that she has forced her parents to send him away from home.
The senior shergill's quite concerned about samrat and at the same time had to bend down to the demands of thier daughter must have sent samrat to boarding school. And obiviously since they were from Indian origin, they put him in boarding school in India.
And from then on, they keeps supporting his financial needs to the maximum. Hence he has enuf money to live lavishily 😃 . Thatz how he manages car , bike , home and also a farm house .
But unfortunately for samrat, at that tender age when they sent him away , he must have felt disowned and developed this hatred towards them . Thatz the reason he neither speaks to them on phone nor speaks about them to his friends or gunjan .
And since he feels suhani is the reason for all these, he started hating her as well.
Guys, hope I have done justice to my analysis so far 😉
Now coming to the question whether samrat is elder or suhani is elder , my analysis goes something like this:
Suhani is definitely elder to samrat. As MJHT records say , she is elder by 3+ yrs 😃 . Let us take this as DOB proof 😆
Suhani calling hiim as 'bhai' is just casual . Quite a few of us call younger bros as bhai or bhaiya . and our cool dude must have been the same cool dude in his childhood also. And hence he calls her by name and not 'di' 😉
Now how come in Excel she is just 1 year senior to samrat? My take on this is may be in London she did some other course for 2 years before she switched to main stream graduation course . then the first two years of graduaiton she conpleted in london and now joining Excel for final year. 😃
Lets take it positively this way instead of thinking that its blopper shown or that the creatives has messed with this confusion :)
Wat say guys?? let me know your thoughts as well....
I know my analysis has gone too lenghty.... sorry coudln't keep it short .
Edited by sajanFan - 15 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

14

Views

3.2k

Users

6

Likes

35

Frequent Posters

aashizin thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#2
woooooooow very good and deep analysis 👏 i totally agree with you 😛
DiyaS thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 15 years ago
#3
Hey, a few of us were discussing just this some days ago.

One possibility - the adoption story you've brought up.

Another possibility - Samrat's parents divorced or his mother died when he was small, Samrat's father married Suhani's mother. Stepmom was always jealous of Samrat, but Samrat and Suhani bonded well initially and really cared for each other. Samrat's stepmom started poisoning her husband's and daughter's minds against Samrat - maybe childhood accidents were blown out of proportion, he was fearless and led Suhani into trouble or got her hurt. Then there was some major accident around the time Samrat was 10 (since in the flashbacks he was driving a car at the age of 10), stepmom blew things up, said that Samrat did it on purpose to hurt Suhani and Suhani also sided with her mother, or she got really badly hurt or something. So Samrat was sent off to boarding school. Which is why he hates them all, his dad for sding with his stepmom, his stepmom for getting rid of him and his sister whom he feels got him into trouble. Maybe he feels extra betrayed by his sister because he loved her a lot and was really close to her and she was the reason he was actually sent off.

Too filmy?

Agree with you on the other points - about the age and the studying in which class - even if Suhani had studied abroad, she could have taken admission in a junior class just to be closer to Samrat.

Had some more thoughts - can't remember them right now! 😛
MoccoLatte thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#4
I agree Divya

but once Samrats mother called from Paris this episode was aired when the exams took place. But why would Sam's mom show soo much concern? well still nice post! I But when Suhani is from London Sams parents are from Paris? some connection there?
AmbyCious thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#5
Heya,that was extremely superb!I think that is the same thin...but in that case..suhani is the villian 😆..but anyway...not an mjht fan/or viewer...but i like this track!
sajanFan thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#6
@DiyaS:
This is also a nice angle
@Chocoretto
Lets assume samrat's parents shifted to london just few years back. And suhani said London intentionally so that samrat will not have any doubt and also since samrat has memories of London but not Paris
Too many assumptions huh 😃😆 ... i was just trying to wear the creatives cap😉
Edited by sajanFan - 15 years ago
DiyaS thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 15 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Chocoretto

I agree Divya

but once Samrats mother called from Paris this episode was aired when the exams took place. But why would Sam's mom show soo much concern? well still nice post! I But when Suhani is from London Sams parents are from Paris? some connection there?



True, I forgot about that. Maybe his parents are divorced and mother is still living? Though that doesn't explain why even she is not in touch with Samrat ... 😕 But was it his mom who called or his dad ... I don't remember whether it was specified.

As for Suhani's parents being in France and she's studying in London, that's quite common. Parents are now in France, but they lived in Mayfair when Samrat was a kid, so Suhani might have decided to stay on and study there. Also it's believable for kids having US passport and studying in UK - if you're born in the US, you get a US passport, wherever you live after that, doesn't matter.
sajanFan thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#8
@DiyaS:
Nice assumption. The probability of the track turning ur way is pretty high
280200 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#9
great thoughts !! i loved reading it !!! This could be possible..!!!
There was another thing which came up to my mind yesterday morning...but its not thaaat realistic to be honest.. =) thought of still posting it though :)
maybe Samrat & Suhaani were real sister and brothers...and sometimes parents have preferences over their children...and maybe they liked suhaani more, which led to the fact that samrats parents neglected him...and he left the family.....
DiyaS thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 15 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: sajanFan

@DiyaS:

Nice assumption. The probability of the track turning ur way is pretty high



SajanFan

I wouldn't bet on that!!! 😉 Creatives are so mahaan ... they can twist this in any unbelievable way! 😆
Still, atm at least there is something interesting to discuss ... and some remote semblance to a storyline!!!

I personally felt that the Mayur track they started had huge potential ... but it seems to be going nowhere 😕 ... god knows what goes on the minds of these creatives!!!

Anu ... at the age of 8 or 10? I thought of that too ... but going off on his own at such a young age - unlikely. Especially since he seems to have all his needs taken care of, like house, enough money etc. I thought of the hare rama hare krishna type track of parents separating and one child with each parent, but after the last couple of promos where samrat hates his family, that was also out.


Edited by DiyaS - 15 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".