Grandma’s tales - An article

SecretKhabri420 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 15 years ago
#1
Hi friends,
Grandma's tales
Dipti Nagpaul D'souza
Posted: Oct 30, 2009 at 1546 hrs IST
The ever-loving traditional grandma of Indian television now bears strong shades of grey

In the heydays of the soap, back in 2000, Kyunki Saas Bhi Kabhi Bahu Thi introduced in its story a character - Baa - who was the epitome of love and warmth; she would forgive the worst of enemies, embracing them as her own. At the same time, she was fair and just and would call a spade a spade even when the kids of her own brood did wrong.

Cut to 2009, Baa is pass. Instead, the grandmother of your favourite daily soaps are scheming, menacing characters, like Ammaji of Na Aana Iss Des Laado or Dadisa of Balika Vadhu, who are not only orthodox in social practices but often conniving enough to play villains.
Purnendu Shekhar, the writer of Balika Vadhu, does see it as a paradigm shift but attributes it to the story structure. "Many shows these days address social issues especially in our rural interiors. And usually it is the older women in the household who, due to illiteracy, blindly follow practices like child marriage or female infanticide. Hence they become the evil factor on the show," he explains. Producer Rajan Shahi of Sapna Babul Ka'Bidaai on Star Plus agrees. He says that often the grandmother - like the Naani on his show who dislikes one of her granddaughters Ragini because she has a dark complexion - is only a victim of her situation. "The naani grew up with a belief system that to have a dusky girl-child is a bane for the family, and she is following it, never mind if the child is her own blood." But Meghna Mallik, the popular Ammaji on Colors' Laado, says that while her character's menace chiefly stems from illiteracy, Ammaji is also a larger-than-life personality to attract audiences. "It's to lend her an enigma that she has been made so evil. Unlike Daadisa of Balika Vadhu who also has a softer side to her personality, Ammaji is evil. And it's her cruelty towards one and all, irrespective of whether it is a child or her daughter-in-law, which draws the viewers. In such shows, the grandmother takes the centrestage unlike before, when she sat in the background and just bore the brunt of everyone else' decisions. She is like Gabbar Singh and Gabbar could not have become popular if he had a heart," she smiles. The popularity of such characters also marks the emergence of matriarchs in television soaps. Shekhar says that traditionally, women are the ones that run a household. "Add to that, the struggle they may have faced in managing the house without a man, like Dadisa or Ammaji did, and you have a powerful figure who also becomes the decision- maker of the family," he says.

But Pratima Kazmi, who portrays the Naani in Uttaran on Colors, does not believe that her character, who misguides her granddaughter Tapasya against the protagonist Iccha, veers away from the traditional image of a grandmother. "Naani may not be like Baa who used to willingly embrace strangers into the household but she loves Tapasya like any other grandparent would. She wants the best for her and is willing to go to any extent for that. But the viewers don't see this because the protagonist is Iccha and not Tapasya."
We're sure a lot of real-life grandmothers would be venting.

Link:
Edited by farislove - 15 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

12

Views

1.4k

Users

4

Frequent Posters

SecretKhabri420 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 15 years ago
#2
It seems like Rajan Shahi doesn't know the story of his serials, Naani was never against Ragini, she was against Sadhna............
KinshukLuvsDina thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#3
l0l yaaaaaaaaaa
zee siss when was ragini in badbook of nani??
she luvdd her so muchhh..nani ne jo sadhna k saath kiyaa haina
woh tu poocho mattt..ufffff taubhaaa..she took sadhna away frm sharma house n apney ghar per akela chod ayee thi..poor thing ran frm there as a guy was disturbing a lonely gurl who was alone at homee...
zee siss wats dis??l0l
nani was alwayss worried abt raginis shaadi n all..she was never against her..
SecretKhabri420 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 15 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: KinshukLuvsDina

l0l yaaaaaaaaaa

zee siss when was ragini in badbook of nani??
she luvdd her so muchhh..nani ne jo sadhna k saath kiyaa haina
woh tu poocho mattt..ufffff taubhaaa..she took sadhna away frm sharma house n apney ghar per akela chod ayee thi..poor thing ran frm there as a guy was disturbing a lonely gurl who was alone at homee...
zee siss wats dis??l0l
nani was alwayss worried abt raginis shaadi n all..she was never against her..

@Bold: When did this happend? 😲, was it long time from begin?, before Sadhna's marriage and Rajvansh family's entry?.........
Edited by farislove - 15 years ago
--Pinky-- thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: farislove

@Bold: When did this happend? 😲, was it long time from begin?, before Sadhna's marriage and Rajvansh family's entry?.........



This happened when Ragini was to marry Puneet..

Nani used to lock up Sadhna in her house and there was a guy around u used to come and harress Sadi after Nani used to leave, one day she ran and the guy and his friends followed Sadi and she went and hid in the gardens of Rajvanch House. That is house the Rajvanch association started.

--Pinky-- thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#6
Nani and Kaushi were always against Sadhna never against Ragini.
The creatives are losing track of their own story.

SecretKhabri420 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 15 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: --Pinky--



This happened when Ragini was to marry Puneet..

Nani used to lock up Sadhna in her house and there was a guy around u used to come and harress Sadi after Nani used to leave, one day she ran and the guy and his friends followed Sadi and she went and hid in the gardens of Rajvanch House. That is house the Rajvanch association started.

Who is Puneet?, the 2nd guy, right?........
@Bold: What do u mean by this?..........
KinshukLuvsDina thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: farislove

@Bold: When did this happend? 😲, was it long time from begin?, before Sadhna's marriage and Rajvansh family's entry?.........

yessssssssssssss
i m telling u i have seen it frm begininggg..
sadhna poor thing her lyf was worseeeeeee at sharma house
agarr ragini naa h0tii ya mamag tu sadhna beechari kaa pata nae kyaaa h0taaa..
seri0usly kaushi nani malti teen0 after sadhna😡😡😡
KinshukLuvsDina thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#9
zee sis puneet was a guy whom ragini lykd he was in sadhna n raginis c0llege..but he lykd sadhnaa..puneet along wid his parents came to sharma h0use..mami nani thought that he came for raginis rishta but they askd for sadhna's hand n not ragini..
ragini cried alott..sadhna went to talk to puneet akele mai that plz marry my jiji shes very nyce n all..but malti ragini k legaye k dekho ur sis sadhna lyks puneet usey akele mai milney jaa re hai...
n nani sadhna ko apney ghar mai akela ch0d ayein mayb tab k0i aur rishta dekh rae thae for ragini..n w0h l0g sadhna k0 naa dekhain s0 nani adopted this way..
nani n kaushi always said that ragini is prettyy
but when ppl see sadhna they find ragini ugly..THIS WAS THERE PHILOSPHY😆😡😆
Edited by KinshukLuvsDina - 15 years ago
--Pinky-- thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: KinshukLuvsDina

zee sis puneet was a guy whom ragini lykd he was in sadhna n raginis c0llege..but he lykd sadhnaa..puneet along wid his parents came to sharma h0use..mami nani thought that he came for raginis rishta but they askd for sadhna's hand n not ragini..

ragini cried alott..sadhna went to talk to puneet akele mai that plz marry my jiji shes very nyce n all..but malti ragini k legaye k dekho ur sis sadhna lyks puneet usey akele mai milney jaa re hai...
n nani sadhna ko apney ghar mai akela ch0d ayein mayb tab k0i aur rishta dekh rae thae for ragini..n w0h l0g sadhna k0 naa dekhain s0 nani adopted this way..
nani n kaushi always said that ragini is prettyy
but when ppl see sadhna they find ragini ugly..THIS WAS THERE PHILOSPHY😆😡😆



Dina that guy was Saket, he was the one who was in college with them and Ragini liked him but he liked Sadi

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".