ARE THE JUDGES MENTAL???

I honestly think their is something wrong with Anu Malik and Farah Khan.

For example"

IN the girl gala, Anu said to Antara "no world power can stop u from coming to the next round ........but in the results episode he saw her in bottom 3

same with Neha, he said she doesnt have the word impossible in her dictionary. then he put her in the bottom three

THEN THE JUDGES SAID AMEY SHUD BE IN THE BOTTOM THREE 😕

i do aree wid u
sum of the comments r really sarcastic as well as ironic

onli anu and farah....sonu gives fair judgements

FG judges were much better even though Javed Akhtar got too personal with his comments. But I have to admit JA did mention good points about diction and pronunciation despite not being a singer himself. I think Sonu is the only fair judge, he understands what the contestants are going through, ie. the anxiety, nervousness etc so he makes fair judgements. Anu is supposed to be the 'Simon of II' but he's too nice, at least in the gala and piano rounds, barring a few rude comments here and there. Audition were a different story though. Farah may be the Simon of II. 😆

i was watching american idol yesterday and simon did remind me of farah wen she said she didnt like meenal's performance....and anu and sonu both said they did

den sonu's like...wat r u saying..meenal was good and farahs like sorry i didnt c it...i cant feel it...itz my opinion

simon did the same thing with paula and randy...he didnt agree to them, even tho the ppl were good...he's like sorry...i dont feel it..i dont think it was good...sorry

lollll

Simon never agrees with Paula and Randy. 😆 Paula & Sonu Nigam are similar. Even when Paula rejects someone, she usually gives them some advice or suggestions for the future unless they're really bad. Sonu is like that too, he encourages the contestants regardless of how they sing. Even with Jolly's perf, he told her to not lose hope since the final decision lies in the hands of the janta.

lol, Farah is the next Simon. Neither are singers so it works!

yeh only sonu gives fair judgment btw neone tell me who ws the first americal idol?

no i don't think they're mental, i think what happens is when they have to name the bottom 3 they try to guess what the audience was thinking and how they might have voted...i think they're asked "who do you think will be in bottom 3?" not "who do you think deserves bottom 3?"

yea, the judges r asked who they think will be in the bottom 3, not who they believe should be in the bottom 3....they r just supposed to guess how the janta has voted. I cant imagine Sonu thinking tht Amey n KArunya deserve to be in the bottom 3!! 😕 😕

PLease dont insult Simon by comparing him to farah. Simon doesnt knw music but he can recognise a star frm miles away...farah khan doesnt even come close to Simon's rudeness or his persona. NO one can be the Simon of II, coz what Simon does is natural to him---he's the real star of American Idol 😳 😳

Please don't take the comparison seriously, we didn't mean it. 😆 Simon is Simon. To be honest, he's not a singer, but does have a good ear for pop music. The fact that we're comparing Farah to Simon only means that Simon is better in every way. Farah can never say some of the things Simon says...no one on II can. 😊