CID writers & directors - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

14

Views

2.7k

Users

6

Likes

4

Frequent Posters

AlexithyMia thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#11
WE WANT DAYANAND SHETTY BACK IN THE SHOW AS SENIOR INSPECTOR DAYA...
Kal El thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#12
I agree that there were many scenes which made little sense in the end. When Daya took the glass from Abhijeet's home and went to the lab, I believe he was trying to compare "Abhijeet's" fingerprints to those of the real Abhijeet on file to figure out if he is real or fake. At least that's the way I interpreted it. They should have had one scene where Daya comes to suspect that even the ACP could be fake (this would then explain his odd comments about the ACP and breaking into his house).

But the rest of the faults were just, weird. Some of them were the result of the writers/director trying to be oversmart in confusing the audience. 😳

At one point I assumed that there could be 2 imposters in the team but then they went in some other direction and things stopped making sense. The editing was sloppy, as usual. I expected a scene at the end where Daya would explain his odd behaviour and even the ACP would explain all those weird phone calls. But nothing like that happened. 🤔

I dunno, they've created a situation for themselves where they are going to look bad either way: having Daya die in an episode with such sloppy editing and directing is bad and undoing his death next week would drag the show down to Ekta's level.

I've said this before: the show needs to take a break and a new creative team needs to be brought in. They should watch the first 3-4 years worth of episodes to figure out what made CID work and then take the show back to that level of quality. 😳




-De.De- thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: suchi_dev2006

Hello CID unit, I thought this independence day I would give you a warm wish, but?..very sadly, today I just can't giving you that,

How could you show such an episode that indicated the sheer failure of CID team?

Daya had to die, but wouldn't you give him a more respectful death???

Did you read the storyline just once before showing it in the television??

All the sequences were confusing & wasn't matching with one another.

Firstly if that daya was real daya then how could he badmouthing about ACP sir?

" Abhijit tumhe nehi lagta hai ki ACP hamare sath thik nehi kar rahe hain?"

How ridiculous is this, Real Daya can never be so mean.

Secondly if for the sake of the story I have to believe that he was real daya & he knew about rocky then he should inform it to ACP, how he could say to rocky to go inside the car in which a bomb had been planted before, & he himself was relishing the scene standing there?

Look Daya is a character who never wants even the criminals to die in this way, & he was trying to kill abhijit aka rocky!!! Why?.Becuase it was important then to keep rocky alive for extracting the information about real abhijit.

Thirdly , why did he go to forensic? & why was he trying to steal the confidential information from forensic? What did he do with that glass which he picked up from abhijit aka rocky's home??

Salunkhe was real, & as salunkhe said that daya was stealing the confidential information from forensic that means it was true,

Why the hell daya was in forensic? If he was real daya then he should try to gather information about abhijit aka rocky & the real abhijit

& also why did he go to ACP's home like a thief? What did he do there?? Why didn't ACP ask that " tum yah ape kya kar rahe ho? Agar abhiit pe shaq hai to uske ghar pe jake chhanbin karna chaiye na, kyu aise upar me chale gaye tum?"

Fourthly Why did he behave like that> The person who never touched alchohol why did he go to bar & then went to Sangita's home?

Fifthly , from where CID found Dr. Prakash's body, there CID also found the torn pieces of Daya's photo with measurement that was necessary for doing plastic surgery,

If rocky's face had been changed as of Abhijit, then why they kept there Daya's torn photographs??

Sixth flaw?Why daya was talking with that goon who was present at the very first when dr.praksha has been oparetaed rocky's face ?

That goon was talking with Daya ,the way one goon talks with another

& when abhijit caught daya then why daya was firing so recklessly upon his own team??

He did tell that goon " tujhe kya CID wale yuhi chhor denge ? chal bhag"..

What was that? Orginal Daya can never fire upon his own team so recklessly

seventh flaw: why Daya was behaving so awkwardly coming infront of Sangita's home? when ACP sir ordered him to break the door, why he was fumbling ? was it normal? just notice the previous episodewhere daya himself was just asking ACP if he would break the door down indicating with his fingers. ACP sir didnt has to tell that.

Everything was indicating that Daya was not real Daya, but it was not only surprising but totally absurd what was being shown at last.

Daya is no more. Is he real daya ?

I hope you would explain something in next episode

& if you don't explain it , then at least I will say Good bye to CID.

It's not a game sir, a story should be believable, it should have proper link among the sequences, but now a days you are totally arrogant & adamant about the storyline.

Anything you are writing & thus showing with confidence.

Confidence is good, but you have over confidence which is poisoning CID slowly & slowly.

Well , it's your choice sir, but Daya should be given a little more respect when he was going out from CID.

Daaya is Daya afterall, After ACP sir he is the most senior member among the CID team.

Even before Abhi, he joined CID, has done numerous dangerous stunts even taking the risks of his life, has injured himself for the sake of CID,

Couldn't all of you give him a death like a hero??

Okay you can't,

Good bye CID,

& a very big thanks to entertain me for twelve long years.

Regards

Oh My Suchi.. you ok?🤗🤗 When I overcame from shock of Daya's death I thought about you. You ok? sorry itne time se contact nahi kiya. But I really missed you and still missing you. You are ok na? Don't worry suchi, I have not lost hope yet, I have faith that daya will be back.

and in the bloopers I totally agree with you. From the behavoir it was obvious the behrupiya was Daya but they changed it to abhijeet. But you are right in some scenes it was totally confusing and they didn't even clarified in the end why everyone's behaviours are changed. Maybe they do that next week, there might be anotther part of this episode.

suchi sweetheart, don't give up just yet, just wait till the next episode. We'll shed tears together, just keep hopes alive till then.

And for the 5th flaw, maybe it's fake abhijeet (rocky)'s poeple planted that picture so they don;t find who the REAL ROCKY is.

For 4th flaw maybe he went to bar n behaved like this so he can gather information for Sangeeta, as she was part of this gang/plan all along n knew alot!

luna_lovegood thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#14
wow Ika.. jinkies same pinch.. evn I thought of Suchi the first thing I was able to think...

and I am sure it will all be fine
-De.De- thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: luna_lovegood

wow Ika.. jinkies same pinch.. evn I thought of Suchi the first thing I was able to think...

and I am sure it will all be fine


Yea.. coz i know suchi alot and know her feelings for Daya, so first thing came in mind was Suchi!

Related Topics

CID Thumbnail
CID

Posted by: SilverBell

1 months ago

Writers Write A Story Where The CID Finally Kills The Eye Gang

Hey Writers Please A Write A Story Where The Eye Gang Gets Killed Off By The CID Officers Instead The Dragging In The Series So We Will Be Happy...

Expand ▼
CID Thumbnail
CID

Posted by: Nikita_99503

6 months ago

CID BTS/Spoilers & Social Media updates Thread #01

Hello everyone!!! Welcome to the CID BTS, Social Media updates and spoilers thread. Kindly share all updates regarding the show here in this...

Expand ▼
CID Thumbnail
CID

Posted by: chatterbox

26 days ago

CID Thumbnail
CID

Posted by: Ranjha2.O

1 months ago

Airing Schedule of CID On tv

So guys This topic is created to Acknowledge all the forum members about What is Nowdays happening on tv with CID First of all I hate sony to...

Expand ▼
CID Thumbnail
CID

Posted by: Minionite

27 days ago

CID New Timings Starting 19th July

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LyLSYuj4_fE

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LyLSYuj4_fE
Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".