Originally posted by: 3M652XFCQ5MW56QK
<BLOCKQUOTE dir=ltr>
<FONT face="Times New Roman, Times, serif" color=#000000 size=4>I really fail to understand exactly who is ISMAIL'S choice....Nihira or Himani.....help me out???.......i agree Ismail is the only impartialjudge among the remaining 2.....but don't u guys think somewhere he himself is responsible for Nihira's exit......Nihira is much much better than Himani in terms of versatility.....but Ismail has always given Himani much more publicityn appreciationcompared to nihira......then why the hell he did the so-called drama on Nihira's exit??.......i really don't understand being music directors can't they point out that Himani always sings same jonre of songs.....she is not versatile as Nihira is...
haven't we been saying the same thing. His support for Himani has been too ostentatious. On the contrary he has not been very forthcoming in the past 2-3 galas towards Nihira. Nihira has been looking quiet down and pale for some reason which has affected her performance to a certain degree. It was the duty of her mentor to have been extremely encouraging and supportive and bring a smile to her face and a swing to her performance. I think this whole drama of walking out in heat and walking back in looks a little farce and even if it is true, seems more like a post mortem.
Whereas Nihira has benefited to some degree under his great expertise as a MD - ID has not been able to lend the support and guidance to make a winning contestant like Nihira walk away with the trophy.
Edited by kaboo123 - 20 years ago