If you had to choose gharan........

Guys,

Can u please consider this question and let me know that if you participated in Challenge 2005 and were asked to choose anybody's gharana, whose gharana of the following would you choose and why?

ID

HR

AS

JL

Give reasons too!

ok agreed but my question is not that which music-director is good. Meaning of my question was which mentor you would prefer so as to you get a feeling that he is a good teach and would guide you very well and you would go far ahead in the race? Guys please note

ok tell me what made you say AS? Tell me whether you felt that you will get enough guidance from him to make it to the top? Give reasons.

Originally posted by: sree's sree

Guess Ill choose my dad's
Cahrity and talent should begin first at home and stay there like a good child😛

😆😆

That was a good one !

Originally posted by: Nehakapoor

ok tell me what made you say AS? Tell me whether you felt that you will get enough guidance from him to make it to the top? Give reasons.

well i feel he is givin the ggod guidence in every terms..
not doin over publicity like HR.. and neglectin the otheress... and not like ID, poor song selections...
JL.. no comments 😃 😃

Well I would have chosen ID's gharana.

Because as candidate this is process of learning for me and therefore I wld like to be with best music director.

If you check the site " music india online" for other music directors past assignment, u will find that whatever work Ismailjee has done is a class in itself.

Compared to him AS is an avg director... go ahead chk for your self Aadesh Shrivastava's work.

Nihira's song selection must not have worked for 'aam public' , but tell you guy's for those who enjoys music unadultered... it was treat.

I would have chosen ID since he would be like a father who is proud and happy when the child does something good and who would scold when the child is wrong to show the right path.