Mahi did give up her daughter to Soni so that her sister could experience being a mother. She did a great deed and deserves more than just a round of applause. She definitely doesn't deserve to be ill treated by Soni's family. However, she went to ask for her daughter back because she needs her "Laxmi" back in the house so that things will get better for their house.
Soni who has seen the pain of almost being a mother and then having it all taken away also deserves sympathy. She should be willing to fight with her family to help out Mahi at her time of need, just as Mahi did for Soni. And if that means giving up the daughter Mahi gave her, so be it, right? Now, Soni seems to be influenced by Jeet and Durga to keep the child that was never hers to begin with to keep their "good luck charm" in the house.
Both are fighting for a baby not because they want the baby but they want their "laxmi" back. Should we sympathize with either one or none .. ? What do you think?