first day analysis

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

jyothi

@jyothi_cool

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

#11

Originally posted by: Bugger
The show was definately gud !! i mean questions were way too personal ......and i was actually thinking wat wud b the last question!!
first i thot tht there shud b a limit till these ppl can go for seetingt up teh questions .....but on teh otehr hand its solely the participants choice!! as teh questions had already been asked they already know wat type of questions they can expect and if still they r going on wit it, its their choice!!

rajeev himself said manyt times to smitaji tht u can quit as u already know the intensity of the questions but she chose to carry on

even her relatives is given a choice of getting the questions changed once so according to me .........the participant has their choice bout wat to choose truth and money or their family and relationships

thts teh show is ll bout!!

but i wud like to ask a question if anyone know .......r plygraphic tests r 100%authentic ....or there mite b a mistake there?

polygraph test does not read your mind so there are chances of errors for example if u are very tensed then it can show that you are lying

Quote

Lara

@lovepyar08

Navigator

Posted: 16 years ago

#12

Simply Mindblowing. Yeah this show will RULE. Indians love gossip and bring and carrying news. All the wives/husbands/elderly will love this show. Even the kids if they know the people. People will tune in to see if they know that family to spread more and create issues. So yeah this show will rule Star Plus Rating.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Pinka

@pinka28

Inactive

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

#13

Originally posted by: ishq008

So right. But like the hair in him now. He is so hottttttttttt. This show in India leaves alot of be analyzied. I agree everything is hush hush and kept behind closed doors. But people love Saas Bahu crap so this will be a welcome to seeing a person of real stating the truth in their lives.

yaar ye he to panga india mien sas bahu ka crap chal jata hai per sachai ko samne dekhne ki use accept kerne ki himmat nahin hoti...
and i also feel ki itna sach kahne k baad last satge tak ki money contestant ko deni chaiye...
atleast they shouldn't feel, they didn't get anything after accepting so much in front of whole world...
koi bhi contestant koi sant mahatma nahin ki free mein aya hai vo definetly use money k liye hai jisk liye vo khel raha hai sach kabul raha hai ...
sach bol ker use hero bna ker ek jhuth pe zero dena acha nahin
i agree with you he is looking too hottttttttttttttttttt
i dont know who said somewhere in her post that his hair looking chidiya ka ghosala ... jispe mujhe kafi jyada hasi .. becoz his hair style is looking like chidiya ka ghoslaya
but he is looking too hot in this chidiya ka ghosla yaar

Quote

Bugger

@Bugger

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

#14

@jyoti- thx for replying !! so tht means there can b sum errors while the tests

Quote

sheela

@Aamnakideewani

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 16 years ago

#15

i reallyy didn't like the concept of show its quite vulger so LS how realtions can be put on danger just 4 teh sake of so called courage or money think of that woman who came on the show how much her life will be effect like such questions😕😕😕sorry BAD concept😕

Quote

Sunaina Mitra

@sunaina02

Inactive

+ 6

Posted: 16 years ago

#16

Ok I have seen the first episode .

It is competely different experience to watch on TV than online.

I must first praise Rajeev because he has done a very good job . 👏

Whatever limitations there were - they were due to the direction of the show : e.g.

1. all through the promotion they have been using Rajeev so we expected a grand entry when the show started. But they did not give him any time and space after the entry which was also somewhat sideways. (They would not have dared to do that with SRK or AB 😕)

2. Rajeev should have been given more time to tell little bit about the show , introduce the lie detector machine and polygraph , explain the hieraarchy of steps and then intorduce the contestant and the family . More questions should have been asked about the husband. Few jokes may have been cracked the way other celeb hosts do.

3. Rajeev only needs to be little more active in moving around. I wish they would change those high chairs if the format allows. It is not naturally easy to get on and off those chairs.

4. As far as I am concerned - the questions were not very unusual for this type of show . And most probably more than truth , brain work is needed to win. The contestant knows which fifty questions were asked . She also knows which one she lied and which were the most awkward ones. So not to be caught up with that question and still win money she could have easily determined where to stop and win at least one or 5 lakh.

4. More thoughts should have beem given to the setting itself . At least better lighting should have there.

5. So overall Rajeev - good job!. 👏👏

Quote

Sunaina Mitra

@sunaina02

Inactive

+ 6

Posted: 16 years ago

#17

Originally posted by: Bugger
@jyoti- thx for replying !! so tht means there can b sum errors while the tests

Polygraph is the final word here. If also there is any error - the polygraphs verdict will be accepted.

Quote

Pinka

@pinka28

Inactive

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

#18

Originally posted by: Bugger
@jyoti- thx for replying !! so tht means there can b sum errors while the tests

i guess ye to kudh RK ne bhi kha ki polygraphic test ka man se koi matalb nahain hai vo sirf apk sharir ki haulchul ko dekhti hai
ye test criminal k sath hota hai
actually not with criminal those has done biggest scandals...
unse baar baar alag alag question puchne hai kuch bhut normal jo bhut usually hote hai kuch unk life kuch alg aur aur bich mein unse unke scabdal ya jo bhi galt kiya hota hai vo puch jata not only just one times

so basic things vahan dekha jata hai ki normal question pe kya reaction tha kya vo unki polygraph ko increase ya decrease kerta ahai
usse pata chalta ki aas juth bolte ve kitna polygrpah gaya aur kitna stable thaa sach bolte and jab phir unse other question kiye jate hai tab aisa hota hai ki unhe high polygraph pe pata chalata

per yahan aise nahin hai ye koi incidence nahin hai
yahann sirf ek man ki soch k question hai jo kabhi humare tnsion pe sach ho sakte hai kabhi juth
likeshow se pahle hue test mein tumse question pucha jaye aur tume sach bhi bolo per nervousness k karn vo polygraph use juth samjhe

jruri ye hai ki same question tumse kam se kam 2 3 bari puchne chaiye show se pahle
i mean test on same question pe 2-3 bari ho na chaiye jisse most similar result of that question accurate mana jaye

Quote

Bugger

@Bugger

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

#19

@sunaina - ok but tht wud not b rite ....like if u take for eg smitaji ...the last question cuz jeopardise her life ......and thts too ther mite b chances tht the machine got wrong and she was rite......well anyway ....i dun think there is any otehr to know the truth!

@pinkaanshu - thx buddy for the reply and the info

Quote

Vertika Srivastava

@Vartika07

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 16 years ago

#20

All i can say after watching the two episodes is that :-

1. The serial contain indeed a bold concept but the i don't think we can watch it with our family members because the questions are still too much bold.

2. One thing is that may be our Indian ppl will not like such type of shows because these can break their trust in relations after hearing the truth.

3. Something must be hidden from everyone so all shouldn't be revealed.

4. Amount money shouldn't be loss after using a wrong answer atleast some wininng money must be given to the contestents.

5. The way RK is hosting the show must be more friendly. Though he has improved a lot but still i think he should have learn so much about hosting.

But still i think bcz of RK it's interesting to watch the serial n one more thing is that RK pls dear cut ur hair for us.

All the best to the team members but i have doubt about it's sucess.