The Good and the Bad

skeptical thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#1
I didn't see the whole episode....... (as usual). But I saw the latter half.
My own brand of random thoughts: 🤔
The Good : ~
1. I liked the way Vidya pointed out her Mangalsutra (MS) and reminded her father quite pointedly that she was still married. Mayb she's having second thoughts after all. Or the initial shock has worn off and she has started thinking of solving her problem a little more practically. 👍🏼
2. I liked the way Aditya in the last scene declares that Antara is his daughter and instinctively and protectively puts his arm around her. Well done........... 👏 👏
3. I liked the way the bespectacled neighbour offers to take care of A and then is really kind to her. 😊
The Bad : ~
1. The father doesn't give up trying to drive wedges betw his daughter's relationship with her husband. He's revolting when he brings money into it. 🤢
2. The two ladies so easily accuse the child of pilfering and make no attempt to stop ppl from harassing Antara. Only the bespectacled good soul tries to. How can those two women stop Antara from living in that society?? How absurd................. Nobdy interferes that much 😡 Unless immoral or terrorist activities take place, no society can bar a small child from living in a building complex.
Creatives...............be realistic!!!!!! 😒
3. It was obnoxious to show the children heckling A and calling her "mad". What a shame !!!!

Created

Last reply

Replies

7

Views

931

Users

7

Likes

2

Frequent Posters

antratma thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#2

you r right buddy , i never seen such a society where any society president will take such a action, they cant bycot antara, i think creatives are trying to put zabardasti ka drama without logic...

ranjnanarang thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: skeptical

I didn't see the whole episode....... (as usual). But I saw the latter half.

My own brand of random thoughts: 🤔
The Good : ~
1. I liked the way Vidya pointed out her Mangalsutra (MS) and reminded her father quite pointedly that she was still married. Mayb she's having second thoughts after all. Or the initial shock has worn off and she has started thinking of solving her problem a little more practically. 👍🏼See the cnage is coming I am sure she will think logic regarding kids soon. She might not forgive Adi which is perfect she should not, but for the sake of kids I am sure she will come around.
2. I liked the way Aditya in the last scene declares that Antara is his daughter and instinctively and protectively puts his arm around her. Well done........... 👏 👏Good progression. He was not accepting the fact himself and hence it was more difficult for him to get is family together, now since has has accepted he will be able to do things more rationally.
3. I liked the way the bespectacled neighbour offers to take care of A and then is really kind to her. 😊Few good people around thankfully.
The Bad : ~
1. The father doesn't give up trying to drive wedges betw his daughter's relationship with her husband. He's revolting when he brings money into it.
I think it might sound bad but he is justified in his own way. He hates Adi and had nave made any bone about it he still tolerated him for his daughter's sake ane now Adi has betrayed vidya so badly he is justified in hating him even more. He is seeing this as an opportunity to get his daughter out of this mess (his perception) Infact is these situation parents get hurt more than the actual parties.
2. The two ladies so easily accuse the child of pilfering and make no attempt to stop ppl from harassing Antara. Only the bespectacled good soul tries to. How can those two women stop Antara from living in that society?? How absurd................. Nobdy interferes that much 😡 Unless immoral or terrorist activities take place, no society can bar a small child from living in a building complex.
Creatives...............be realistic!!!!!! 😒Skep these things happen I have seen them happening practically had ot face it myself when my little one dropped his soft ball from our house and people made issue out of it saying that what if our windscreen would have broken 😕 I wonder how a soft smash a cars wind screen. people and their whoped ideas.
3. It was obnoxious to show the children heckling A and calling her "mad". What a shame !!!! People can be real obnoxious at times but then they dont realise that they are giving a very bad attitude to their kids.

Goon analysis skep my replies in blue
skeptical thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#4

Ranju ............... i was just wondering::::::::: 🤔

How many of us are watching this show to understand Antara and her condition and how many of us are watching it to just see cute children? 😕
rashi77 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: skeptical

Ranju ............... i was just wondering::::::::: 🤔

How many of us are watching this show to understand Antara and her condition and how many of us are watching it to just see cute children? 😕

I'm sure many have started watching this show for the cute little kids, but ultimately they will understand (or at least try) Antara and her condition. I have a very good friend that teaches autistic children and I swear she deserves an award for her patience and compassion. As a matter of fact, I was watching the local news in my area last night and they showed a segment on a picnic that was given for autistic children. One mother was so happy because they food vendors had pictures of the food up and her son was able to point out what he wanted. She said it was the first time in 14 years he had been able to tell her what he wanted to eat and she started to cry...and so did I. These children are very special....and this show will definately be pulling at all of our hearts.
poetic thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#6
People do react to 'different' children and people in this way. If a child is different, ragging by the other children in the society is not uncalled for.

A lot of people still needs to understand these different children and that's the basic idea of the serial.

And society members do complain about weird stuff, so it's not totally illogical either.

As for Vidya's Father, he is acting normally from his POV and he is not the villain. He is just stating stuff that seems correct to him.

jihadha thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#7
i just hate this SOCIETY KA PRESIDENT.......but vidya n aditiya are just toooo good..they r v real..
snowwhite30 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#8
somebody kick d president out...........

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".