REPLY TO ADITYA FORMULA

This message is nothing but seed of a sick mind. My message never carried anything against a particular region or religion. It was completely created by someone who doesn't understand what was written nor does know how to interpret something like what I wrote. Does being Indian mean we verbally abuse someone like this? Is this our Indian culture? I don't think so.

I never mentioned that Madhuri Dixit and Abhijit Sawanth were not talented and FYI, I voted at least a 100 times to Abhijit Sawanth because he was my favorite. Both of them are very talented and that's why they could make it big in their respective fields. But what I mentioned about them is what sometime back both Madhuri and Abhijit themselves acknowledged openly. Perhaps you don't read newspapers or magazines regularly. Both of them acknowledged that they had advantage because they were Mumbaiites and Madhuri herself mentioned that she was the only actress from Maharashtra to have reached the pinnacle after Nutan. Now would you call Madhuri also anti-Indian?I didn't mention anything out of context.

I don't care whether you are a Maharashtrian or someone else because even if you are a Maharashtrian my reply would have been the same. I have due respect for all Maharashtrian friends and in no way intended to offend their feelings. I have a Maharashtrian relative in my family and would never do anything to offend him.

Your note itself started with a very wrong interpretation, "I'm a true Indian ! and hope all of u are too !!!! " Now where did I ever mention anything against Indians?

How sure are you about Sony or the judges not promoting a particular contestant? I have seen 'n' number of members sending unparliamentary comments about judges and Sony whenever Qazi or other contestants in FG were sent to the danger zone by saying that Sony and FG judges are backing so and so contestant and till recently similar comments on Neha (now don't interpret this as saying something against Qazi or FG, for God's sake). How sure do you think they are when they wrote all that? Someone here suggested me to learn music. FYI, I'm a trained singer.

As far as Amey's singing abilities are concerned I stick to my point. I don't think or feel he's great shakes compared to Anuj or other contestants from his group and I'm entitled to my choice. If you feel he's great that doesn't mean that everyone else here should feel the same about Amey. I have respect for Amey as a singer. He is a learned singer and I respect his talent. To others he is someone great but sorry to say he hasn't impressed me and there are others who might feel the same. You cannot impose your favouritism on others.

What culture were you mentioning about? Have I anywhere mentioned anything about anybody's culture here? What do you know about my religion or region? And what do you know on what basis I'm voting? What else can this be except a product of an obsessed mind! I didn't get this place from you for you to decide where my place is in this forum. If you read the last lines of my message you will understand what I intended to convey. I clearly mentioned "viewers must not get influenced by factors like region or religion". You seem to be having some problem in understanding simple English? Stop moral policing and we've had enough of people like you everywhere. It is people like you who contaminate the minds of others by giving your own misinterpretations. I think more than me it was you who spoilt the process of discussion and the fun involved.

I wouldn't be surprised if even this reply is misinterpreted.

i agree w/ u, i dont like amey date much either, he reli didnt impress me (THIS IS JUST MY OPINION!!)

Lovlina you are saying that Amey did not sing well that day. Do u really mean it?????? 😕
If yes then I am sorry to say......you are not a TRAINED singer, but u are local TRAIN singer who knows nothing about Sur Taal... 😆
What say guyz????
no personal offence meant.

gamezone,

Thank you for atleast calling me a local train singer. You should understand that they are all good singers and that's why they are here in II2 and no one is truly a bad singer. As far as Amey is concerned, I already acknowledged that he's a trained singer and respect his training. We form opinions based on their performance on that particular day (in this case piano round). Honestly, I found Anuj's performance better than Amey's. I will not form my opinion blindly based on how judges react (standing and clapping or saying wah! wah!) b'coz I know they have their own 'majboori' and they are paid for it. My judgement is based on whatever training and understanding I've gained about music in my life. Sorry to say that Amey might have impressed others but not me.

Originally posted by: gamezone

Lovlina you are saying that Amey did not sing well that day. Do u really mean it?????? 😕
If yes then I am sorry to say......you are not a TRAINED singer, but u are local TRAIN singer who knows nothing about Sur Taal... 😆
What say guyz????
no personal offence meant.

well said!!! agreed!

Folks, why is everyone up in arms against people who dont agree with their choices?
Lovlina is simply stating that she didnt much care for Amey's performance and thats it. Give her a break. Everyone has a right to an opinion. Please stop passing comments to insult someone. Its childish.

And btw, she is right on about the judges faking wah wah. If anyone saw group 4 they will understand. No girl sang anything great and they were showering praises on Meenal, Sandipa, Antara and Jyotsna without being objective.