This is coming from a huge Aishwarya and Sonam fan. I was an Aishwarya fan, before Devdas, before HDDCS so I think I know the history of her career.
1. Aishwarya was Miss World and a very successful model. Apart from Aishwarya Rai, Priyanka Chopra, and maybe two or three others, how many other Miss Worlds can you name? Do you really think outside of India, being a Miss World is a HUGE deal? It's not. As for being a successful model, no doubt she was but she wasn't an international supermodel. She was only popular in India among those who followed fashion. She wasn't Laxami. Many people didn't know her name even when they saw her in ads until MIss World. So please don't say she was extremely popular even before she entered movies. She wasn't. And she wasn't well known at all until Devdas went to Cannes in 2002 and it was than she got international attention. Devdas was in 2002, 7 years after she entered Bollywood. She became the face of L'Oreal, end of 2003/early 2004...8 years after she entered Bollywood. The fact that Sonam is the face of L'Oreal in just two years after entering Bollywood is a big deal out of itself. L'Oreal is an INTERNATIONAL company, it's not an Indian company, so there's no way Sonam can be a face of L'Oreal only locally. Being part of Dream Team doesn't mean you have to be the face of L'Oreal all over the world. Eva Longeria, Gong Li and some others are proof of that.
2. Aishwarya's first few movies were flops. Iruvar, Aur Pyar Ho Gaya, Aa Aab Laute Chale, and even Jeans didn't do well. It wasn't until HDDCS that people thought she could act. I still remember the days when people called her a "cold fish". Even Aishwarya herself commented on that and mentioned how hurtful that was. People thought she was just another pretty face model who can't act. She worked HARD, and proved them wrong. Sonam is TWO movies old. Yes both her movies flopped but her acting skills have been appreciated. Is she good of an actor as Aishwarya? Of course not. Aishwarya has been around since 97, that's 12 years. So she's way ahead of Sonam. There is no comparison. But please, apart from Abhishek Bachchan (who is a good actor I might add), whose dad likes to remind everyone that Abhi is his son, what other star kid is known for just belonging to a filmi family?? Kareena?? Hrithik? Aamir? Salman? They all started off being known as starkids but they all made a name for themselves because of their hardwork and I think with time, Sonam would make a name for herself too. Please stop with the "she's a star kid"....if all the starkids get out of Bollywood, more than half of Bollywood would be gone.
3. Sonam has a big mouth, Aishwarya is reserved? Aishwarya has been around for a much longer time, please dont forget all the controversies she got into herself. She made stupid decisions before too. And I would expect Aishwarya to be more reserved, more mature as she has more experience. Sonam is still new but I don't think she's rude at all. I think its just how you look at it. She's just sharing what she thinks. There's a line between being honest and rude, and I don't think Sonam has crossed it yet. And can we not forget, L'Oreal's statement? Sonam's words were MISQUOTED. So she didn't actually say those words and we all saw the video.
4. I am extremely disappointed if Aishwarya actually did do this but I guess they all know better.