Appreciation for Shilpa-Nishant's Crazy Kiya Re

I personally thought it was a fantastic performance and deserved atleast a 24! They truly tried something very innovative and I thought it paid off cuz it was a very good performance!

I don't get what Saroj Khan was harping on about 'basic' lavni steps or whatever....it was a fusion number! Doesn't she get that?? They atleast tried to be innovative! Just because she has her own prejudices and biases against fusion numbers, why does she try to put down and demoralize anyone who tries it??? I felt really bad for Shilpa and her choreographer Nishant for the way SK just totally pulled them down.

I was disappointed by Vaibhavi and Juhi cuz I had expected atleast them to try and applaud some innovation being attempted by a participant in a very good manner I felt! Vaibhavi I guess did like the way they conceptualized it but found Shilpa lacking....but I personally thought Shilpa was still very good....I found this to be a better performance than their first one.

And I don't know what missing 'namkeen' Juhi was talking about, cuz I thought that was all there!

Overall, they deserved much more appreciation and marks for this performance than they got! It was sad to see them being unnecessarily demoralized by the judges.

I agree. While I was watching their performance, I thought they'd get good comments for being creative. Granted, Shilpa is not a trained dancer, but she put a lot of effort into this, and it shows.

Saroj Khan is just very very biased. And she seems to have become a bit moody too. If she's feeling happy during a performance, they get good points. If she's not, they don't.

Inspite of all the comments from judges regd technique ,no mirchi and thadka i felt they deserved more than 18. There attempt for some thing different and steps were also good a 24 should have been better marks.

It was different, it was innovative, but I have to agree with Juhi - it lacked the "spice" factor. I cannot exactly put my finger on what. IMO, it was not bad, but not "wow" either.

At the same time I wasn't sure I liked SK's comments. No offense to SK or anyone else, but her style of dancing is a bit dated, unlike Shaimak Davar or Ganesh Hegde. I truly wish there was a male judge for objectivity - not 3 devis 😕

Their performance was not perfect but it was good.. They tried something different and i liked it a lot..

I infact liked their performance, I can't say that stage phaad diya but it was indeed good and differet. Saroj Khan makes things worst. First of all she has an inflated ego problem just like her own size. She thinks she knows it all and doesn't even listen to what the choreographers has to say. Her face dropped ugly when Shilpa's choreographer tried to explain something. Also she never smiles when Vaibhavi is commenting or saying anything funny. Saroj Khan thinks she is the know all and end all of dancing. And I think by watching these dance shows all choreographers should know that never talk back to Saroj khan immediately because your pints can drop from a 9 to a 6 within the blink of an eye, but if yu praise her like she is the queen of dancing, she will give you a 9 for doing ringa ringa roses also.

What I said, dude. What I said.

The harp on about creativity and originality, but when someone actually tries something new...

Originally posted by: desicrowd

Her face dropped ugly when Shilpa's choreographer tried to explain something.

And I think by watching these dance shows all choreographers should know that never talk back to Saroj khan immediately because your pints can drop from a 9 to a 6 within the blink of an eye, but if yu praise her like she is the queen of dancing, she will give you a 9 for doing ringa ringa roses also.

So much word. Not only the choreographers, I'd say. Even when Karan's wife (very respectfully) said she disagreed with Saroj, it was blatantly obvious that she was pissed. Sad, really.

Originally posted by: nanshr

I agree. While I was watching their performance, I thought they'd get good comments for being creative. Granted, Shilpa is not a trained dancer, but she put a lot of effort into this, and it shows.

Saroj Khan is just very very biased. And she seems to have become a bit moody too. If she's feeling happy during a performance, they get good points. If she's not, they don't.

Anu,

Couldn't agree more. I thought Shilpa and Nishanth did a very gud job with their dance. It was a surprize package coz the last thing one would expect from a dance number like crazy kiya re is a traditional "lavni" ! I would definitely like to applaud them for doing something creative and different, at the same time also dancing quite well.

I think SK has some major issues man ! Her judging is quite silly. She's arrogant, rude and pathetically one dimensioned. I think she expects evryone to just suck up2 her all the time. U try to explain ur point of view and ure so doomed !

Mo

Originally posted by: desicrowd

Saroj Khan thinks she is the know all and end all of dancing. And I think by watching these dance shows all choreographers should know that never talk back to Saroj khan immediately because your pints can drop from a 9 to a 6 within the blink of an eye, but if yu praise her like she is the queen of dancing, she will give you a 9 for doing ringa ringa roses also.

LMAO! This is sooooo trueeee!😆😆😆....As is obvious from the way she gave marks to the other contestants doing a great job of sucking up to her😆😆