Moon-Sparkle thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#1
I am wondering how come Noni is IN top 16? not being rude or anythin...but i think Shubu was more deserving to stay back. and again Kiran was much better too. but not sure..cuz Noni does her dance same way. I was glad to see her in top 18 cuz i thought wow she dances very good. but now comparing to others..i think it wasnt fair to shubu😒

Created

Last reply

Replies

22

Views

2.2k

Users

16

Frequent Posters

brainychild92 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#2
i no..i wanted shubu in but:(but he was compared to the boys not the gurls.. and as for kiran, from the comments, i knew she was going.....
blueblue3 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#3
overall i'd definitely say kiran's a better dancer than noni but like the judges said her solo performance did lack 'dance'. I think she could have done way better if she chose some other song.
Dabulls23 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#4
Noni is OK...Nothing to write home about...I give her credit for her energy and determination to dance...But Kiran was waaaaaaaaaaaay better then Noni or Rakhee..Kiran's elimination is total discrimination by 2 judges and mahaguru...👎🏼
Subho was the weakest amongst the 3 boys...so he had to go..sorry...His elimination is justified...
366774 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: Dabulls23

Noni is OK...Nothing to write home about...I give her credit for her energy and determination to dance...But Kiran was waaaaaaaaaaaay better then Noni or Rakhee..Kiran's elimination is total discrimination by 2 judges and mahaguru...👎🏼

Subho was the weakest amongst the 3 boys...so he had to go..sorry...His elimination is justified...

lol!
yes i never liked this subho🤢
andysah thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#6

I agree that Noni and Rakhee is the weakest of the lot. They also mentioned two dancers will be out and not 1 from each sex. But then the elimination was like 1 from boys and 1 from girls. The last nine boys were correctly chosen and if it is 1 from boys, then Shubho's elimination is justified. But the last nine girls seemed biased. Even from the initial stages, Tanvi (? from Ghouse group) was a much better dancer than Noni and rakhee. And Kiran is definitely much better than Noni and Rakhee. Maybe she needs to dance inside a fat suit and wiggle her flesh around to be appreciated.

Also the judging left me confused. Is this going to be the format from now on? No voting and anything!! That is so uncharacteristic behavior by Zee. One way this is good that they are out of the money mindedness. But the judging would cause a furore later. Terrence had 2 of the best and original choreographed dances. But because he does not have that footing in the film industry, 2 of his best dancers are out. How is Mithunda judging? Is it by points in different transparent criteria? Or whoever manages to irritate his slumber gets kicked out.

Dabulls23 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: andysah

I agree that Noni and Rakhee is the weakest of the lot. They also mentioned two dancers will be out and not 1 from each sex. But then the elimination was like 1 from boys and 1 from girls. The last nine boys were correctly chosen and if it is 1 from boys, then Shubho's elimination is justified. But the last nine girls seemed biased. Even from the initial stages, Tanvi (? from Ghouse group) was a much better dancer than Noni and rakhee. And Kiran is definitely much better than Noni and Rakhee. Maybe she needs to dance inside a fat suit and wiggle her flesh around to be appreciated.

I am totally with you on ^^^^....Hey where is Tanvi???? I kept looking for her in 18...I thought she was chosen and made it to 18..
Also the judging left me confused. Is this going to be the format from now on? No voting and anything!! That is so uncharacteristic behavior by Zee. One way this is good that they are out of the money mindedness. But the judging would cause a furore later. Terrence had 2 of the best and original choreographed dances. But because he does not have that footing in the film industry, 2 of his best dancers are out. How is Mithunda judging? Is it by points in different transparent criteria? Or whoever manages to irritate his slumber gets kicked out.

Weakest mentor is Geeta...Remo and Geeta along with Mithun kind a ganged up against Terence...Terence should have really supported and backed up Kiran...He did not even console her...He spent rest of the time consoling Shubo....Tutor-mentor needs to be fair to his pupil...and give equal time to both...I was bit disappointed in Terence as guru...I like him very much...
Aamir's Fan thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: Dabulls23

Weakest mentor is Geeta...Remo and Geeta along with Mithun kind a ganged up against Terence...Terence should have really supported and backed up Kiran...He did not even console her...He spent rest of the time consoling Shubo....Tutor-mentor needs to be fair to his pupil...and give equal time to both...I was bit disappointed in Terence as guru...I like him very much...

Even though Terrence is my favorite judge I was also kind of disappointed that he did not console Kiran at all. All his attention was focused on Shubho. I felt really bad for Kiran. Just because she is older than Shoubo does not mean that she does not need some attention from her mentor. It was really disheartening to see Kiran only being consoled by a few girls.😕😲
bwoodlover01 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: hira**

lol!
yes i never liked this subho🤢

i agree i think noni should've gone and i never liked shubo in the first place. glad he's gone!
andysah thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#10
>Even though Terrence is my favorite judge I was also kind of disappointed that he did not console Kiran at all.
I think this is more of a case of squeaky wheel getting the grease. Shubho can throw hysterics that can match up with the best of the girls. Also he is very young whereas Kiran is a veteran of reality shows and knows that it is not all over till the fat lady (Geeta? Noni?) sings. She is rumored to be back by a wild card entry. She along with her husband has won 1 reality show and her marriage was sponsored by the show (?). There are 2 more contestants from Dance who previously appeared in other reality shows (Jai and another). Where Terrence erred is in his comments that 50% of the choreography was done by her and threw her under the wheel. There was nothing wrong with her song choice and her dancing. That's a lovely song from yesteryears. While I think hip hop, western dance is spectacular and eye pleasing you cannot completely abandon Indian dances or dances from Hindi films. Anyway Kiran doing Indian dance is better than Rakhi/Noni doing hip hop.
No comments on judging yet. I do not know how are they going to judge the boys who are very good and evenly matched unless someone blunders in future. Or are they going for gender (in)equality here also?
Is bar taqdir ki topi ek ladkiko hi milegi!!!!!!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".