To all those who say Charit should be there - Page 3

i farmly think tht charit shud b there...if thy could choose 4 so..why not 5!!!!!

I don't think either of them are that good as singers..there are just here as eye candy.

Originally posted by: Surkilla

Are you still in the petition business? How much money do you make out of it? 😃

tones.😆

Originally posted by: tinytina

The judges themselves have said number of times, that the performance of each day counts and the contestants are judged on their singing of that particular day, then Mohit shouldn't have been selected at all. Actually, I had read an interview in the Mid-day in which Mohit's father had quoted that Mohit has performed with the top singers of the country which includes Kailash Kher too!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Besides II4 is not a game of cricket and Mohit can in no way be compared with Sachin Tendulkar....Who is MOHIT?? Do we know him????NO!!!!!!!!!! He has yet to prove himself and the judges decision is totally biased. When only three were to be chosen how could they bend the rules and accomodate Mohit.....Possibly some connection like how his father stated!!!!!!! Very bad!!!!!!😲

😆Well i agree wit dis post in a way..but yes Mohit shudnt b compared to SACHIN!!! plzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz how cn u compare a singer wit an cricketer they both hv different professions all together..
i agree Mohit shud have been in for galas as he is a gud singer..but i think on de basis of tat day's performance all 5 shud hv been chosen.. it was really sad to see just charit leaving..

Originally posted by: Dabulls23

Neither Charit nor Mohit should be in TOP 14 along with some already who were there.....Bhavya is another questionable for me...

Originally posted by: Aisha_86

I don't care if Mohit is better or not.. Mohit just wasn't THAT good that they changed the rules just for his sake... Was he that good that they chose to make a top 14 instead of the top 13? And if he got that chance, so should Charit... If they have to chose 1 winner out of 10 perfect singers, they are not going to change the rules and make 10 idols winner will they? So why do it now just for a singer like Mohit?

There were supposed to be three selected, and three obvious good singers could easily be selected... Mohits singing was just average so it doesnt make any sence to choose 4 instead of 3..!

It just didn't make any sense to choose 4 out of 5....