Well, really difficult to tell and a very odd post. But just to reply hypothetically :
shreya - She would win the contest hands down, if it was only singing which was being looked at and the judges also had a say in the decision
sunidhi - Would come runners up to Shreya but if the show was not SRGMP and was Idol, then she would be the winner and Shreya would be runners up as Sunidhi is a great singer & performer.
sonu - Would be miles above the contest and if calibre of Shreya was participating then he would be the Judge. I think all singers (no matter who) have great respect for Sonu as a singer so they would not mind being judges by him.
kk - He is besura at times while live singing and is not high on popularity, so would exit mid-way
shaan - He would make the top 3 and would get the maximum votes due to his popularity / nature & looks. If the show was only voting based (like it os now) then he would win.
babul supriyo - Absolute besura when singing live, have seen him on the NDTV show. Would go out in the first few rounds
mohit chauhan - Not heard him live but he has his limitations and excels in particular soulful songs. If HR was the judge (which he should not be) then he would have said ke tum unconventional singer ho and you should stick to your strengths.
amit kumar - At times Besura while singing live and keeps giving his gyaan, thinking that he has all the authority just because he is KK's son. Should be out of the competition in the early rounds. Bahut Pakata hai !
udit - Would exit mid-way. During live singing he is decent but during his concerts I have seen him loosing breath after a few songs.
sanu - Absolute besura while singing live. Will be out soon. Unless he sings songs from Aashiqui / Deewana / Phir teri kahani.. coz then I will flood him with votes as I love those songs ! I am a fan of his RECORDED songs (not live singing)
hard kaur - As per me she cant sing ! Blurting out words in an accent and at a pace which no one can understand ! She would be out in the qualification rounds !
And please members, dont crucify me, these are just comments in zest. Just my opinion, all the above singers are good in their own right (except Hard Kaur) but as they say - you like some and you dont like some.
Edited by ReemAnshu - 16 years ago
