Why Sara was eliminated

Originally posted by: Khatarnak

I know most of you are not going to agree with me and usually people think that I am insane (that does not bother me at all, as I like to have fun), but I do have a right for my opinion(s).

Here is my reasoning for her elimination:
Sara - not much support from Pakistan and Indians have so many to chose from and really most of us vote on regional basis
Zaheer - Getting majority of votes from Pakistan and does have some fan base in India as well
Asma - Is she really getting any votes?, I don't think if people from Oman would care to vote mostly she is getting some sympathy votes.
Soumen/Debo - They are splitting votes from Bengal (still enough votes to keep them alive).
Prathiba - Huge fan base in Punjab.
Yashita - Come on folks Bombay is a big city and she is getting majority of her votes from Bombay and the area.
Vaishali - Marathi and lots of sympathy votes.

I am not arguing who is better and who should win, I am simply trying to give you the analysis of the distribution of votes, of course they are also going to get votes on their talent but majority will come from their own region.

Originally posted by: akanna

I agree with you, except for a couple of things. One, Vaishali is not surviving on sympathy votes. She was the winner of SRGMP Marathi, and so a bunch of Mumbai votes would be going to her too, not just Yashita. Even Salman mentioned how his mother watched her on SRGMP Marathi and all that. She is really good regardless of her background - a beautiful lotus in the marshland in terms of music.

The same way, Prathibha would be getting a lot of votes from MP and all, as well as all over India - C'mon she is very good and decent, plus she has a simplicity and charm, and more innocence than Asma.

I agree with you with respect to Sara, Zaheer and Asma. In fact Asma would be getting a bunch of teenagers' votes I think. Else she wouldnt be there now.

Soumen and Debo - whatever it is, both of them together ended in bottom three once - quite shocking!! Soumen is the winner of SRGMP Bengali and so could already have a big fan base in W. Bengal.

It's incidents like these make me wonder whether the vote counts are real?! Else how would Asma be in and Manisha from Calcutta would be out in Brahmastra round? How would Mitika be the first to go?!!

Originally posted by: Khatarnak

I am not sure if you have read it from top to bottom. Thanks

Originally posted by: jo_jo1214

First of all we don't think if you are insane - we also like to have fun like you do and yes usually people do vote on regionalism.

Originally posted by: Summer3

Khatarnak your analysis is quite scientific and logical.

But there is also one other factor to take into account. We call it the X Factor.

Certain singers have plenty of X Factor.

I will ask Kingji's Royal Dept to investigate this.