4th round results inside story - deduced

After counting votes of 4th round, the outcome was
1st lowest - Nihira
2nd lowest - Hemachandra
3rd lowest - Rajeev

Logic is - when 40 lakh votes have been polled, probability of a tie is very very less. Zee Tv has never promoted Hem, so they will not try to save him by announing a tied result. So it is Nihira who got less. She does not deserve to be ranked the lowest is another matter. For that matter neither Hem deserves to be treated badly by public.

Next, ZeeTv and Gajender Singh tried to save Nihira by almost announcing Hem out. Logic, Believe's blog on this topic, he said Hem is out first and then said there is a tie. The first announcement was a bit premature. After this, there was probably an argument about it between Gajender and the mentors, ID and AS. ID and AS probably insisted on declaring both the contestants as winners. Remember, ID making strong comments about public's voting before the start of the show. AS also said he was worried about not only Chandu (that is how AS calls Hem) but also about Nihira. I say, AS and ID did a neat job of defending their respective shishyaas, especially ID. He was impartial then and also in the Shahid and Amritha episode, he gave Hem 9 marks out of 10. Dikne me woh sakht hai, lekin ander se, he is a soft person.

They could have declared Rajeev as out, my opinion only. The difference in the number of votes that Hem and Nihira got to what Rajeev got is hardly 200 (Hem and Nihira are supposed to have got 3,62,120 votes and Rajeev 3,62,320 out of the 40 lakh votes). And everybody knows that he is the worst among the lot. In such a case Nihira would not be at the receiving end of backlashes. This is my opinion only, I have not posted this to start off a tangetial discussion.

Now coming to guess_gallery's posting about the almost sure ousting of Hem during the next round - he feels Hem will be eliminated. As the producers did not mind throwing him out the last time, they may do it during 5th round. Guess_gallery works for ZeeTv or somebody who he knows works for ZeeTV, this is for sure. In fact, at first I thought Guess_gallery is plain disappointed like many of us but now I have changed my opinion.

That Hem has come so far facing many adversities is a proof of his abilities.

So much for the public voting!!!!!! Hoping for the best for the next round. Why can't Believe post results soon????

PS: I don't work for ZeeTV. This posting is purely based on facts that I have read on India forums. I work for a MNC in Bangalore, just in case you thought otherwise.

Interesting observation....... i like it... but again i will repeat my sentence tat hemachandra MAY BE out i am 99.99% sure till now but after so much hype abt his elimination Mr G singh is not so Inncent to follow same thing he may plan his exit later so this time MAY BE some other... carry on
hope for the best

i think rajeev or paresh is out this week

Hi Anadeep - I am thinking on similar lines. If you have been seeing the results over the last 2 weeks you will notice that this is the first time they have given the % to the 3rd decimal point. I feel the difference between Hem and Nihira was less than 20 points as a result of which both of them end up with the same percentage to the 3rd decimal point. If it was between 20 and 40 votes you can round it by increasing it to 9.054% I think AS raised a hue and cry and in the 3 yellows two were his shishyas and the 3rd person is Nihira. I think he and ID took a call along with Gajendra Singh to declare it as a tie. I think Hem did have lowest votes so the counting personnel would have revealed the results which was later revoked and declared as a tie.

I understand that it is unfair to declare a tie even if there is a difference of 1 vote but if the measure is % then they are fair to declare it as a tie. Moreover - this was to decide the fate of two exceptionally talented singers and with a difference as slim as that...it is really unfortunate if one had to go.

I am not saying this since I love to hear both of them but would do the same if it was anyone else.

i think it is a publicity stunt by zee tv so people vote and watch the show! and sharib was a victim of that.....i could be wrong

Thanks, that was very thorough and insightful.