Criticism and Racism at Saregamapa 2009!

bhagat_singh830 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#1

Why do they get people from all different places when this has to be done.. What does Yapshita sings being cool doesn't been you are a smart and a sincere singer… Sara has always been good so in this way I think someone else should have been out.. This even happened in 2008 as well with Amanat Ali and Raja Hassan, middle of the way they bought the Aneek winner of bengali saregamapa half way of the show and now this year bought that girl and a boy… It's such a place where people from different countries get criticize and racism is always there.. Hate everyone…… What the Hell is debojit doing.. can't even sing properly..

At frist all the Pakistani's boy got eliminated and how come only Indian on the show right now.. why aren't lot of Indian going.. Haan.. I am not from India or from Pakistan but I think things have not been changed yet.. even though they say but still something is their in heart alive today as well..

Hope you all liked my comments and what a SHAME for SAREGAMAPA 2009 ....HUH!!

Created

Last reply

Replies

85

Views

9.4k

Users

31

Likes

1

Frequent Posters

*Woh Ajnabee* thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#2
There's going to be a riot on the forum now. 😆😆


akanna thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: bhagat_singh830

Why do they get people from all different places when this has to be done.. What does Yapshita sings being cool doesn?t been you are a smart and a sincere singer? Sara has always been good so in this way I think someone else should have been out.. This even happened in 2008 as well with Amanat Ali and Raja Hassan, middle of the way they bought the Aneek winner of bengali saregamapa half way of the show and now this year bought that girl and a boy? It?s such a place where people from different countries get criticize and racism is always there.. Hate everyone?? What the Hell is debojit doing.. can?t even sing properly..

At frist all the Pakistani?s boy got eliminated and how come only Indian on the show right now.. why aren?t lot of Indian going.. Haan.. I am not from India or from Pakistan but I think things have not been changed yet.. even though they say but still something is their in heart alive today as well..

Hope you all liked my comments and what a SHAME for SAREGAMAPA 2009 ....HUH!!

I dont understand your comments completely. I assume you are talking about Soumen and Vaishali being brought into the show. In terms of numbers and proportions, the show maintains the same proportion when it comes to Indian contestants versus non-Indian contestants. In fact they do that at the cost of many talented Indian singers all the time and this year is no difference either.
When the show started, there were 16 Indians in four gharanas, and six Pakistani singers and six foreign singers (two from US, two from UK, one from Oman and one from Singapore) were brought in, along with a bunch of independent singers. As it went on, four Pakistani and four foreign singers made it into the four gharanas. In the top 14, there were nine Indians, four Pakistani singers, and one foreigner, which is 9:5 ratio - this meant five foreigners and over a dozen Indian singers were sent home already by this time. After this week's round, it's now five Indians, one Pakistani, and one foreigner - making it 5:2 ratio, and Indian singers will be taking the baits in the coming weeks in order for them to retain the less talented foreigner.
The producers of the show are Indians, and if they had wanted, they could have maintained it as a 100% Indian show. They have opened their doors for others to particiapte and look at the positive side of it. These people are getting such an exposure in the Hindi music industry which none of the Indian contestants can even dream about having outside their home country. Indians never get invited for such a talent show outside India. Then why complain when India is opening her venues for non-Indians?! I dont even understand why someone is so annoyed about it when they dont even belong to either nations??!!
338121 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#4
Judging by past records i wouldn't be surprised if Soumen wins the competition even if he is a mediocre singer and has absolutely no personality
bhagat_singh830 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#5
bhagat_singh830 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: MrsAckles

Judging by past records i wouldn't be surprised if Soumen wins the competition even if he is a mediocre singer and has absolutely no personality

YEA YEA i will wouldn't be even surprised when you shut up...
*Woh Ajnabee* thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: bhagat_singh830

I truly want that to happen bez these people deserve that way.. kehte hai na jab ghee sidhi ungli se na nikle to ungli ko teri karna parrta hai... now it's goign to be fun and if anyone want or wish to say soemthing so think before you do.. cause now the fun starts..

That Yaspita by doing a dance (thumka lagane se kuch nai hota woh to tawaif bhi lagatein hai khote pe) sing to us in a sur and don't sing from next time the disco songs sing a soft love song.
and the other girl what's her name yea... Vaishali (ghar par kia dimag chord kar aie hain, saans ka itna porblem hai) .. sing in a nice voice don't breath too hard...
and Adesh is truly a f***** and so is Himesh and Pritam.. Shankar is littel ok but he himself does not know how to safe his own gharana and kids...



You know if you hadn't made this second set of comments, I was going to put my two cents forward. I was going to say that yes, it is true, foreign singers don't get votes. BUT you can't expect people to vote for people outside their nationality. Simply because they're humans, we all relate to people that have our culture, beliefs, morals, origin, etc. But I will not comment further because you have made such low comments that are in a very bad taste. If you don't like Yashita, that's fine, but that does not give you a right to say such low life comments about her. And using such inappropriate language is totally uncalled for. I have no respect for people who stoop to such levels to get their point across. If you have a true argument, and you would like this forum to discuss/debate in a proper manner, then you should present the argument in a proper fashion. Not by posting insulting and rude comments that might offend others.

It was unfortunate that Amanat and Raja lost last season. I liked both of their singing more than Aneek's. But we can't change the past. What's done is done, look to the future and discuss this season (with dignity).
v12345 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: bhagat_singh830

At frist all the Pakistani's boy got eliminated and how come only Indian on the show right now.. why aren't lot of Indian going.. Haan.. I am not from India or from Pakistan but I think things have not been changed yet.. even though they say but still something is their in heart alive today as well..

Hope you all liked my comments and what a SHAME for SAREGAMAPA 2009 ....HUH!!


If you not from India or Pakistan why have you kept the user name Bhagat Singh. I know you are not from India thats for sure.
Sa re ga ma pa is giving atleast exposure to new talent across the world.

vijaykkk thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#9

This time zaheer got sangeet chakra. If all indians hate pakistan than this would not been possible. Yes sara was a good singer and she reached top 8 but only one can be a winner. Sunidhi chavan was also in a reality show but she never won. So who ever may be the winner may or may not be able to achive his goal. That is the matter of destiny. Also most of the people from east especially West bengal, assam does give lot of votes to their contestent which you can also see from last year indian idol so if debo survives or win just like aneek its not zee tv's fault.

bhagat_singh830 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: v12345


If you not from India or Pakistan why have you kept the user name Bhagat Singh. I know you are not from India thats for sure.
Sa re ga ma pa is giving atleast exposure to new talent across the world.

Don't go withthe name Babes.. alright.... Which exposure is Saregamapa doing we all know that for sure and getting new talents just to show people about how big hearted they are and they loving welcoming people from different countries but what the truth is we all know tht for sure..... It's still there in hearts.. You just can't judge people with their face or sweet talks.. PERSONALITY TALKS.. ALRIGHT.....

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".