I know i am disagreeing but having seen the episodes i saw karishma giving judging a fair goo not being to nice but not mean giving good and bad points i like that.
As for attitude i have never seen her come across as with attitude she has some warmth about her people with attitude tend to come across what i have seen cold. I remeber when she hugged the contestent whos birthday it was i was like it seems sweet.
Yes i did expect abit more from karishma maybe its way she comes across in her movies but its first week and evne if shes not like other judges so what.
You cannot judge a person by looks seriously i mean i know a person whos the nicest person in the world and first looks i thought omg she looks like she will eat you alive.