All the female singers this year are horrible

Do you agree? I saw the piano round and noticed none of the singers has a unique or outstanding voice quality. Same goes for boys also but a few were okay. I found sa ra ga ma pa contestants far better than these Idol singers.

sorry, i dont agree with u at all .........

female singers this yr are far better than last II.

1st ...don't compare another musical contest in this forum ...we r talking about Indian Idol and let's stick to it's pros and cons .....

2nd...I disagree with u ..I think compred to boys girls r better this year ....but what would happen to their confidence level and who would rise and who would fall after the judges scrutiny and sometimes way out of line comments , is yet another matter ....

this time really girls are far better than last year,bhavaya is too good and one is that married girl I dont know her name.

The married girl's name is Shini and she is really good. I also like Sourabhee.

I also reluctantly agree that this time the girls are much better than the boys as far as singing goes. Behavior wise and manner wise.................... I would not like to comment any further as it might offend some of the members.