Prioritize your criteria for judgement

Hey,

I started this topic just to know how people judge a contestant. Please give your criteria of judgement with percentage.

My criteria for judgment:

Singing: 60%

Performance:15%

Good human being:15%

Look:10%

Singing: 50%
looks: 25%
Performance: 10%
Good Human Being: 15%

singing --75%
performance --20%
looks -- 5%

Hey! Firstly, being a musician myself, I do not take Indian Idol as a singing competition. It's more like searching for a youth icon. For any other show I would have given 100% stress on singing. But yes, because they are concentrating on singing, here are my criteria.

Singing and performance: 80%

Good human being: 10%

Look:10%

Originally posted by: winnie_pooh

singing --75%
performance --20%
looks -- 5%

agreed😊

Originally posted by: aditya_formula1

According 2 me ::

Singing --- 90%
Performance --- 8 %
Personality ---- 5%
AND
ONE MORE IMPORTANT THING !!!.

SYMPATHY --- 0 %

Note : I haven't included the criteria "good human being" bcoz I think that one can easily "act" like a good human being but that may not be the case in reality !!!!

iagree with you 100%.i take back my ealrier po😊st

Originally posted by: ankita31

iagree with you 100%.i take back my ealrier po😊st

One can act like good human being in one or two episode but one can not hide inner thing again and again. Like in FG Rex acted nicely till last 3-4 weeks. Good human being does not include one particular thing, it includes behavior, innocence, arrogance, politics, greed, opportunist etc.

BTW that is just one criteria I included if you do not want to judge on that it means it 0%. I appreciate the comments.

Originally posted by: aditya_formula1

According 2 me :: Singing --- 90% Performance ---8 %Personality ---- 5% AND ONE MORE IMPORTANT THING !!!. SYMPATHY --- 0 %

Note : I haven't included the criteria "good human being" bcoz I think that one can easily "act" like a good human being but that may not be the case in reality !!!!

very well said 👏 👏

Originally posted by: aditya_formula1

According 2 me ::

Singing --- 90%
Performance --- 8 %
Personality ---- 5%
AND
ONE MORE IMPORTANT THING !!!.

SYMPATHY --- 0 %

Note : I haven't included the criteria "good human being" bcoz I think that one can easily "act" like a good human being but that may not be the case in reality !!!!

looks can be called as looks and personality. I do not think sympathy is a criteria. Actually in the end I was thinking to give the final result by taking average of percentage so that way we will know what does people count most.

SINGING: 85%
PERFORMANCE: 10%
LOOKS: 5%

the reason i hv give more to singing thn performance coz if one njoys the song themselves then automatically performance rises n even others enjoy the song!!!!!!

dunno if wht i said made sense!!!!