What a powerfull performance singing marks 8 ??!!

75073 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#1

It sounds like someone your boos in your office telling ya he/she really impressed on your job performance and next day you got fired....Todays Abhijit this (who is not even closed quality to singing like Sonu Nigam, Shaan, Udit Narayan, Himesh Reshamiya, Kumar Shanu, Shukhbindar shing) he told Aneek what a powerfull performance what a powerfull singing......and then gave 8 marks only which was fully opposite his comments on singing and previous prejected comments that aneek and shayonti ,,,,kushal and shanchita should be in final.

Then What it is???? is this kinda fully planned match setting or scripted drama if its then I am glad that Aneek a winner singer and beautifull taught dancer Shayonti left this silly show...who can understand i am sure they already hating this show and what marks gave by abhijit to kick out aneek. I am sure instead of abhijit if it was bishal and shekar or farah khan then meenal and abhishek would have already eliminated because there are not biased judje. 😡

Created

Last reply

Replies

14

Views

1.3k

Users

8

Frequent Posters

Blossom5 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#2

Well, of course judges will make it look like Aneek performed less than what he did. They have to justify this decission of elimination... :(

But i take this point of view. Those of you who followed esbe closely know how unfairly this singing prodigy was treated and what unprofessional and ridiculous comments were hurled at him all this time. He deserves much more than this lowly show and, God willing, he will be a Bollywood legend one day. At least, with his elimination, he doesn't have to put up with this awfull show anymore.
75073 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: LuckyJade

Well, of course judges will make it look like Aneek performed less than what he did. They have to justify this decission of elimination... :(

But i take this point of view. Those of you who followed esbe closely know how unfairly this singing prodigy was treated and what unprofessional and ridiculous comments were hurled at him all this time. He deserves much more than this lowly show and, God willing, he will be a Bollywood legend one day. At least, with his elimination, he doesn't have to put up with this awfull show anymore.

Thanks for understanding my point its not from my view only it should be from people view also that how Aneek treated for his singing now i see Aneek's platform is like one of the biggest platform Saragamapa I wish Himesh Reshamia was there when abhijit was giving aneek 8 marks...cause Himesh does not care who is senior who is not all he cares the singing quality thats why he gave perfact answer to Asha Boshley because he said he said the truth....if he was in here ...i am sure by his voice Abhijit ka thobra tor deta ..

51559 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#4
Sorry to say but i think its fair...He gave Meenal 7 points which was completely unfair..So obviously Judges ne bhi Aneek k saath waisa hi kiya...
75073 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: Pentaminous

Sorry to say but i think its fair...He gave Meenal 7 points which was completely unfair..So obviously Judges ne bhi Aneek k saath waisa hi kiya...

Meenal deserves 7 even sometimes 6 but Aneek always desrvs 10....not even 8 he is the winner always...how come you say that.......Aneek 1000000000 times better than Meenal i dont even count meenal compare to aneek ..... Aneek can be compare with Amit who is legend unique voice singer...meenal always kicked out because of her deadly performance ...always sleepy performance you should watch saregamapa Aneek's singing than you go tell anything about Aneek

Blossom5 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#6
Ok guys, i hope this doesn't turn in to another argument. :( I think Aneek is one of the singers who has deserved a ten so many times but because of these odd judges he hasn't gotten it. Thank God he has some other project opportunities ahead of him. God bless him always and God bless all the singers in esbe. If we talk about Aneek here, i hope we won't bring in other singers in here...
RAJNISHMJF1 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: simpleguy

It sounds like someone your boos in your office telling ya he/she really impressed on your job performance and next day you got fired....Todays Abhijit this (who is not even closed quality to singing like Sonu Nigam, Shaan, Udit Narayan, Himesh Reshamiya, Kumar Shanu, Shukhbindar shing) he told Aneek what a powerfull performance what a powerfull singing......and then gave 8 marks only which was fully opposite his comments on singing and previous prejected comments that aneek and shayonti ,,,,kushal and shanchita should be in final.'

' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' Then What it is???? is this kinda fully planned match setting or scripted drama if its then I am glad that Aneek a winner singer and beautifull taught dancer Shayonti left this silly show...who can understand i am sure they already hating this show and what marks gave by abhijit to kick out aneek. I am sure instead of abhijit if it was bishal and shekar or farah khan then meenal and abhishek would have already eliminated because there are not biased judje. '😡

so Mr. simple guy now u came to realise that how does it feel when a good singing is given only8 marks...😆😆its tit for tat...in the last episode when meenal sang so gud that everybody praised her than mr. aneek gave her only 7so god gave him the punishment and thats y today despite good singing he got 8...but i think the way he gave meenal only seven marks...even 7 wud have been sufficient...jo jaisa karta hey usko waisa hi result milta hey...now today u are making so much hue and cry...hope u got my point...and dont compare abhijeet with himesh or sukhwinder😆
75073 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#8

Aneek always better but he gave 7 marks as he wanted to and that was 45 sec singing not full song performance....abhijit gave 8 marks based on his full performance and yes....compare to sonu nigam, udit narayan, kumar shanu, shukhbindar, shaan abhijit steel needs to know about lot of singing and also one more thing added judjment without drama...since he has been biased and worst judje now in this planet.

Aneek was right but abhijit now trying to save un do jodi so he kicked out aneek .... there should not be any final decision like shoni ki gher fully unfair there should be only one decision by People like Indian idol, saregamapa, jo jeeta wohi sikander....so that abhijit and ahmed these two biased judjes will not be able to keep some bad singers in this show....now at least Raja in here but i am sure these two judjes will kick Raja and jessi out fom this show thats how the shows going as full on drama show or game show😡😡

Blossom5 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#9
I don't think we should compare what happened with Minal to Aneek's elimination. Here's why:
1 Aneek's points did not make the decision of whether Minal would be in or out while Abhijeet's 8 sent Aneek out of the show. Whether Aneek gave Minal a 7 or a full 10, she would still be in first place. Abhishek and Minal were leading in points that week with 53 points.
2 This is actually the most important reason: Aneek didn't load Minal with praises and then give the 7. He just gave the score and that was it. Abhijeet said so many wonderful things about Aneek. Things like "what a powerful performance" and something like I'll tell the world to watch for this singer. Then, he sent Aneek packing. Rajnish ji I think you know that I've always said that I admire your support for Minal and that she's a sweet gal with a sweet voice. So please no offense but I respectfully disagree, that is not an apt comparison.
Edited by LuckyJade - 17 years ago
holymary thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#10
Abhijeet has lost all credibity on this show. Often times his remarks and points don't tally. How many times he had given ten to Sanchita, but today could come up with only an eight for Aneek after an unparalleled performance.
Aneek is so confident that he improvises on the fly, I have never heard him singing a song in the same way twice - every time he adds something new to it. Other singers try to copy the original but Aneek can take any song and take it to the next level.
I think Abhijeet's career is finished as a judge today - his singing career already being over.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".