Come on Tanya..!

SWAROSKI thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#1
I fail to understand Tanyas Character potrayal in this serial.
Firstly, she is got such an understanding and loving sisters whom she could easily open up & confide esp at the incept when goon like Khanaiya started stalking her....c'mon anyone on earth would report this to their family!?
Secondly, when Khanaiya has done wrong to her even then she is not disclosing it to any of her sisters and let the criminal and crime go un-punished!?
I hope sisters like Tanya do not do the same mistake in reality ...GOD forbid and do all possible to protect themselves from such exploitation.
I wish the director conveys a message for girls like Tanya to be brave and inspire them to stand up and fight against such odds.

Created

Last reply

Replies

17

Views

1.8k

Users

13

Frequent Posters

Prachi_Shah thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#2
Indeed you may be right! But also if you were in Tanya's place than what would you have done? I know Tanya should speak up but right she is scared to death... So its not her fault but also her sisters' fault... because they claim to know each other than if they know how both Trisha and Tanya are than why aren't they trying to understand Tanya too....

Maybe its me or something but if something like that would have happened to me I would also loose faith in myself but at the same time I would have my sisters' support because I don't have to explain the anything in-fact they know me pretty well that they understand me too.


zainabay thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#3
no it makes me nad, she actually made khanaiya come close to her, when ever he called she answered, whenever he made her come somewhere she did, like that nite, she decided to go herself, he didnt force her, she couldve told someone, so its all ehr fault, and it make me mad, she shouldve told trishna atleast because now shese married to yovraj, i kinda makes me mad because she noes that, u can tell the police, and u can take action, but she didnt
xxangelxx thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#4
no it makes me nad, she actually made khanaiya come close to her, when ever he called she answered, whenever he made her come somewhere she did, like that nite, she decided to go herself, he didnt force her, she couldve told someone, so its all ehr fault, and it make me mad, she shouldve told trishna atleast because now shese married to yovraj, i kinda makes me mad because she noes that, u can tell the police, and u can take action, but she didnt


i tottaly agree...its all tanyas fault...i mean gimee a break!!

sharry20 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#5
I TOO AGREE WITH YOU GUYS COZ TANYA IS THE ONE WHO HAS TO BE BLAMED .....WHY THE HELL SHE WENT THAT NIGHT TO MEET KANHIYA....SHE KNOWS HIM WELL RIGHT.....I GUESS ITS HIGH TIME SHE TELL EVERYONE ABT IT....
nidmister110 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#6
^Come on guys............I think she went over there to protact her family. He's crazy, he can do anything to her family if she didn't go.. But yes I agree that Yuvraj and Tanya should everyone what happened so everyone can understand and help them. Yuvraj is so nice and everyone hates him because of Tanya and Trishna......😭.
zainabay thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#7
^ but he didnt want to harm her family
he wanted her
Mitu1228 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#8
When stuff was happening 2 Sujata, her marriage part, he did that 2 her friend n said he will do it 2 any person she tells, sorry.
sonikudi1 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#9

I believe that the only fault she has commited was that she went to Kanhaiya everytime he called her. But then again I don't blame her because she was scared and afraid of what might happen. I think, though, she should confide in her sisters considering how close they were. Its not like they're gonna go out and yell it or something!

sonu4ever thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#10
Ok guyz many different views here.
I agree with all but to some extent 😆
@ Swaroski : I dont think Tnay was shown up like a brave girl in the beginning. On teh contrary, Me Kohli and Manshaa made the remark at the beginning that Tanya is quite living in a cocon. She isnt that opened up. I agree she's an understanding person, but she couldnt disclose her tragedy withs omeone else, because of that understanding, as she felt that it'll ruined her other sisters life.
But u are right, she should have at least shared it with her sisters and so punish Kahnaya.
I fully agree on that, Directors should use Tanya's character to convey messages, because the message which we are getting is of a sis who can on teh one hand do anything for her sisters, but on teh other hand, someone who is really fragile and cant fight for the truth. 😕
@ Prachi_Shah : Well said in a way her sisters are at stake, because they couldnt understand her and her pain. Tanya didnt needed to diclose teh Truth, HER sisters should have known that something was going wrong.
@ zainabay : I dont think so, she went whenever he called her because she was scared. She didnt have the guts to tell him no, neither to tell it to anyone. But i agree that now she can at least tell it to police, but yet again she fears that it can affect her sister's image and honour
@ xxangelxx : same, i dont think it's Tanya's fault.
@ nidmister110 : Well said sweety, she did this for her family 👏 and yes they both should have told it to all, but no one is ready to listen to them. 😕
@ Sonia : U are right, well said, it wasnt Tanya's fault and she could have confide it to hers is, but her sis could have understood her too. So i guess its not her fault. 😉
Sorry if u guyz dont agree with me 😳
Humera.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".