Snehandu elimination Fair?

Snehandu Naskar sang better than the other girl, still he was eliminated. Did not seem fair to me. He song was also so much more enjoyable to listen.

Also unfortunately his Mentor was not around then.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rnES3ftk9zs

[YOUTUBE]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rnES3ftk9zs[/YOUTUBE]

Snehandu's earlier performance. He has a good voice

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z4xh2GAv5Aw&feature=relat ed

[YOUTUBE] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z4xh2GAv5Aw&feature=relat ed[/YOUTUBE]

Sudhenshu's voice is not unique....

Rashi has husky and different voice which can be explored for playback singing.... The surs can be corrected with the computer but her voice will sell more than sudhanshu's

Originally posted by: kabhi_21

Sudhenshu's voice is not unique....

Rashi has husky and different voice which can be explored for playback singing.... The surs can be corrected with the computer but her voice will sell more than sudhanshu's

You may be right. But I did not enjoy Rashi's singing as she seemed to be straining ( perhaps nervous). But Sudheshu was very gracious in defeat.👏👏👏

Where was shanker while Sudhenshu's elimination 😕

Originally posted by: Dabulls23

Where was shanker while Sudhenshu's elimination 😕

He had got a hall pass from Ashaji to go to some other event someplace else in town.

Originally posted by: bunbutt_too

He had got a hall pass from Ashaji to go to some other event someplace else in town.

I C 😆 Hall Pass hmmmm 😈

Shankar ji went for recording for another TV programme.

It is always bad to see some one leaving with a heavy heart. His song E ajnabee was a good attempt though he broke down in sur and was strained at places/ What can we say when Asha tai her self is judging, we can't question her.

But if you ask me bairi piya was itself not great , she was breaking words to breathe and ofcourse equally besura. Apparently this girl doesn't have a classical training.

E ajnabee is loosely based on Bhimpalashi and it is dangerous to attempt such song unless you have at least few years of classical training under your belt.

He was very sporting and graceful in defeat, God bless him.

Originally posted by: bunbutt_too

To be honest I had selected Rashi and Sudhenshu for elimination before Ashaji said it. I had no idea that there was a life line of some sort for one of them. But Summer3ji you are right, Sudhenshu was very sporting and dignified in defeat.

What to do, eliminations started early even before they could fully settle down. I enjoyed Sudhenshu's song selections which were more enjoyable to the audience to listen to. But felt sad to see him go. Hope they pay him for his costs and expenses for coming down.😕