Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 42- Page 138

Episode Discussions

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.3k

Views

84.3k

Users

37

Likes

4.3k

Frequent Posters

Moor278 thumbnail
Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 5 hours ago

Originally posted by: Mona_HappyLife

Mannat deceived Vikrant for DK/Rotu 🤣🤣🤣 Biggest joke..

There was no support for Mannat either from this forum when everytime it was told that why she did not herself told the Aman truth. It wasn't her truth to be told. This particular point has been explained 1000 times. She wasn't even born when Aman incident happened & hence kept on begging continously from RoTu to tell. She never had any evidence to back claims so why would Vik believe her ? Jab proof tha tab bhi nai Kia, iss case mei tha hi nai then why would he believe. Is this point so difficult to understand. And that guy DK literally wanted to tell the truth during rasams, why would any girl ruin her Rasams when for a day it can wait & parallelly when she was also convincing RoTu to tell ?

Mannat's past experiences wasn't something pleasant when she told truth without proper proofs but yeah she can be called selfish, deceiving etc but Vikrant's impulsive nature leading to chain reaction & not believing Mannat even once cannot be called out. All of a sudden he becomes the only victim & she is the perpetrator.

Some people here don't want to under this pov but they want others to understand Vikrant's pov. By the way most people here justified Vikrant's anger because he was wronged so your statement is partially wrong. Mostly people were furious with how he left her at Mandap. Then believed all the CA with DK. 1 person here supported this through & through & few people were silent then.

People are still so pissed that Mannat walked out. Its the people here who made it Vik vs RoTu/Dk & completely ww off Vikrant as he never had any part to play. You hate your parents for the truth, Fine. How can you leave your partner for this who wasnt even born at the time of incident ? Post him cooling down while talking to Mannat did he for once tried listening to her ?

People are quick to point out that Mannat chose this, chose that but conveniently forgetting Vik also has done exactly the same thing multiple times even after Mannat gave proofs -chose his family over Mannat. But Mannat for the 1st time chose herself, het sanity & her respect & walked out & it became a problem.

The biggest irony here is some people want Mannat to do everything from A to Z but others when expect the same from Vikrant even the basic then it becomes a huge issue. The bare minimum she expected from Vikrant was trust which she never got. This has been going for ages. Not some 1 time incident.

If people go after FL since the start, give a free pass to ML everytime & expect her to fix all the mess created by ML, then obviously other people will go after ML. Everything can't be overlooked & brushed under the carpet in the name of Vikrant toh aise hi hai....

Snarky comments were started by someone here. Online Neetu words are for X people not this forum. If few here are hurt by those veiled statements then they shouldn't have even started in the first place.

Also, Rdigest since you had mentioned this multiple times before that Mannat should have stood by Vikrant because they are partners. The support & trust should have been from both sides. When for every other incident Mannat has to literally scale Mt Everest to convince him or make him belief her then the minimum expection of trust, faith & understanding is also needed from his end when he never gave.

Also , since Vik & others here have the habit of putting all the A to Z blame on her, what's the guarantee that if Mannat had chosen him during Aman truth then years later he wouldn't have blamed her for separating him from his parents. Bcz bhai sahab ko truth khud pta nai lagana hai, thats also Mannat's job. People here at forum & at X would have declared her as a Home Wrecker.

Bold... brilliantly said ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️


The reason Aish chose to reveal the truth during wedding was because she knew Vik would ask for proofs and neither Mannat nor Neetu would be able to provide it.

Aish played on his weakness very well... had he listened to Mannat and Neetu calmly or Mannat begging to complete the wedding it would have been a different picture altogether... phir DK bhi kuch nahi kar paata 🤪🤪🤪

Agar Mannat ne use blackmail karke shaadi kiya hota to bhi vo kuch nahi kar paata. It was her integrity that she never brought up he slept with her.


For that matter, DK was never on Vishs side even post leap... agar sach main use Mannat chahiye hoti pre leap se to vo Vish ke side hota na Mannat RoTu ke side 😆

But yeah... choose to ignore this for obvious reasons 😁

Mona_HappyLife thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 5

Team ManVik

Posted: 5 hours ago

Originally posted by: Moor278

Bold... brilliantly said ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️


The reason Aish chose to reveal the truth during wedding was because she knew Vik would ask for proofs and neither Mannat nor Neetu would be able to provide it.

Aish played on his weakness very well... had he listened to Mannat and Neetu calmly or Mannat begging to complete the wedding it would have been a different picture altogether... phir DK bhi kuch nahi kar paata 🤪🤪🤪

Agar Mannat ne use blackmail karke shaadi kiya hota to bhi vo kuch nahi kar paata. It was her integrity that she never brought up he slept with her.


For that matter, DK was never on Vishs side even post leap... agar sach main use Mannat chahiye hoti pre leap se to vo Vish ke side hota na Mannat RoTu ke side 😆

But yeah... choose to ignore this for obvious reasons 😁

Vishakha really played smart.

Dono beto ke weaknesses ko kured kured ke khaa gyi.

Jaate Jaate she injected poison into DK that Dua will always choose Vik which automatically meant Mannat also choosing Vikrant & that was the start of him being the villain bhale hi previously he was grey shade.

Pre leap same thing she did with Vikrant.

Jyotsna09 thumbnail
Republic Rhythms Aazadi Quest Volunteer Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4

Team Vikrant

Posted: 5 hours ago

Originally posted by: Rdigest

Why is Viks reaction based on his own memories is justified and a completely different reaction by Abhi is also justified????

Did Vikrant do anything when he got those flashes and no clear images until the wedding day 8 years ago? Nope he didn't, he asked his family around him and believed their lies until Vish brought out the truth and him getting clear flashes. It's the same here, he has been getting flashes but no clear images until he ended up in the hospital. He asked Ankit and he lied by EB him, Vikrant even asked for proof from Ankit.

Vik as a person would not entertain or encourage physical harm, body shaming or mistreatment to anyone.

Exactly, with no memories and nothing to rely on he could only show his displeasure, apologize, make them feel better which he did with the teacher and Vibha. He is not the confident Vikrant whose 1 roar can shut down the whole SM. He was someone with no memories, relying on them, indebted to them and being EB every second if he went against them and reminded of their favors. To put into perspective, think of how DK EM & physically abused Mannat into putting down Vikrant int he court and how he abused Vikrant for no reason infront of Mannat multiple times. Did Mannat speak up for Vikrant or did she even stand up for herself against the abuse? No, She stood there even when DK said DuMan were objects and he will do whatever he wants. She infact defended DK when Vikrant tried to interfere.

We all supported Vik when he threw out Mannat RoTu (pre leap) because he had memory recall and realisee Mannat hid Aman truth from him. Rest of it is a domino effect which we have discussed to shreds.

I don't believe anyone from the forum supported Vikrant and called out Mannat for deceiving Vikrant for DK/RoTu. Infact, forum even expected Vikrant to immediately accept the apology for such deception and complete the wedding when all Vikrant requested Mannat was to never hide anything from him. When he questioned Mannat why she was supporting DK so much when he should have been her priority, forum declared he CA her.

Some of us did support Vikrant and we went silent because of the snarky remarks by calling opinions which didn't align with them as childish and offscreen Neetu's. I for one find such snarky comments very funny and have a good laughsmiley36. I even had a good laugh when I read posts supporting DK abusing Mannat on the forum, such love and dedication for DKsmiley37.

I don't understand this desperate need to gloss over Abhimanyus poor writing just because he is played by Adnan.

I have no issue with Abhi character writint though I didn't care for the leap. I personally don't route for actors , only support or not support characters. So, not sure who this is intended forsmiley36. I have called out Vikrant in multiple tracks prior to DK's entry , even with the Y wedding drama I called him out. But, when I call out Mannat & how she was ruined since DK entry, I am suddenly Adnan supportersmiley36.

Anyways Chao, kitchen duties and dinner calling before I go watch DK drugging Mannat smiley36

Right On Yes GIF by Christopher Pindling by christopherpindling
Moor278 thumbnail
Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 4 hours ago

Originally posted by: Mona_HappyLife

Vishakha really played smart.

Dono beto ke weaknesses ko kured kured ke khaa gyi.

Jaate Jaate she injected poison into DK that Dua will always choose Vik which automatically meant Mannat also choosing Vikrant & that was the start of him being the villain bhale hi previously he was grey shade.

Pre leap same thing she did with Vikrant.

And i am very glad she isnt whitewashed.... YET 🙄

Moor278 thumbnail
Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 4 hours ago

Originally posted by: Mona_HappyLife

During Baisakhi episodes, not even once Neetu said sorry to Vikrant for the gravest mistakes she did.

Yehi agar Mannat nai sorry bolti toh log another round of bashing start karte.

Also Vik said sorry to her only bcz Dua truth came out even though he accepted that Aman truth was hidden from him to save him from his breakdown & what they did at that time wasn't wrong so he could have atleast said sorry to her as well.

This is for the statement that Mannat deceived Vikrant for DK/ RoTu

Bold...

Yahi to baat mujhe samajh nahi aati....

The character agrees that hiding the truth from him was for his own betterment... and whatever Mannat did was to save him from that exact same situation which he faced for 7 years...

Kitna kuch alag hota if he had not reacted the way he did. DK ka pura ka pura existence worthless hota if that had happened.


Phir bhi log Mannat ko hi kose jaa rahe hai... kis baat ka rona hai I will never get.

If you love Vikrant so much, agree to him na atleast... uska baddappan maan ke hi sahi .... ye kya apna alag narrative banake rakha hua hai 🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️


I love how they are showing Vikrant post memory recall... a rapid growth brought in due to unfortunate events... but growth indeed.

Edited by Moor278 - 4 hours ago
Mona_HappyLife thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 5

Team ManVik

Posted: 4 hours ago

Originally posted by: Moor278

Bold...

Yahi to baat mujhe samajh nahi aati....

The character agrees that hiding the truth from him was for his own betterment... and whatever Mannat did was to save him from that exact same situation which he faced for 7 years...

Kitna kuch alag hota if he had not reacted the way he did. DK ka pura ka pura existence worthless hota if that had happened.


Phir bhi log Mannat ko hi kose jaa rahe hai... kis baat ka rona hai I will never get.

If you love Vikrant so much, agree to him na atleast... uska baddappan maan ke hi sahi .... ye kya apna alag narrative banake rakha hua hai 🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️


I love how they are showing Vikrant post memory recall... a rapid growth brought in due to unfortunate events... but growth indeed.

I just feel the underlying point which pissed off people is Mannat walking out choosing her own sanity & respect. People won't accept this though.

Majority are so habituated to see the setup where Mannat is running pillar to post for Vikrant's acceptance for what she is even trying to say or share with him so the minute the setup gets changed she gets branded Selfish, Deceiver.

Honestly, what Vikrant is doing now, should have been done long ago. This was the support & trust Mannat was expecting from Day 1.

Also now you can see how Mannat is sharing each & every small details with him & he is listening calmly, no impulsive reaction . This is again for those who till today keep on complaining why Mannat never shared anything with him in the past conveniently forgetting that she did both - without proof & with proof only to be bashed, humiliated left & right because of the very impulsive nature of Vik.

Aaj woh sun raha hai shaanti se tabhi woh sab share kar rahi hai.

When a person keeps on pushing you away not try to listen to you then why the other person will continue with the efforts to share anything. This is basic. Mannat still did till the end but then there is again limit to everything. The limit got breached & she walked out.

Edited by Mona_HappyLife - 3 hours ago
Mona_HappyLife thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 5

Team ManVik

Posted: 4 hours ago

Originally posted by: Moor278

And i am very glad she isnt whitewashed.... YET 🙄

Lol woh bhi ho hi jaayegi 🤣🤣

shiro_shinchan thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3

Team Aishwarya

Posted: 4 hours ago

Originally posted by: Moor278

Bold...

Yahi to baat mujhe samajh nahi aati....

The character agrees that hiding the truth from him was for his own betterment... and whatever Mannat did was to save him from that exact same situation which he faced for 7 years...

Kitna kuch alag hota if he had not reacted the way he did. DK ka pura ka pura existence worthless hota if that had happened.


Phir bhi log Mannat ko hi kose jaa rahe hai... kis baat ka rona hai I will never get.

If you love Vikrant so much, agree to him na atleast... uska baddappan maan ke hi sahi .... ye kya apna alag narrative banake rakha hua hai 🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️


I love how they are showing Vikrant post memory recall... a rapid growth brought in due to unfortunate events... but growth indeed.

Mera to simple sa funda hai, if Mannat is so problematic then why ship Vikrant with her and hail ManVik? In any case Vikrant has tons of options, Manyata, Yashika or even Mallasmiley37

We'll ship him with Mannat and continue to curse her day and night like a typical saas if she doesn't nanny their Raja beta enough, hence the term Neetu mommies smiley37

He's supposed to be a brilliant entrepreneur, So why does he always need a character to nanny him, whether it's one of the vamps/mommies or the FL herself?

Let him be independent and do something on his own for once, display some accountability. Everyone else is blamed for his actions, if x did so and so hence Vikrant reacted in y manner!

Even DK when he was positive was bashed, no wonder he was flipped overnight to accommodate the sinking ship that was the ML's ckt graph, only to tank it again with bringing that a$$hat abhimanyu as an alter-egoish cktsmiley37

Moor278 thumbnail
Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 3 hours ago

Also there was always a boss employee kind of underlying power dynamics with them. Vik being the boss always got his way with her and she kept behaving like his subordinate. Running after him to concede to his demands.


Duas truth has actually flipped the dynamic and then onwards Vik has really changed. Mannat turned out more loyal and superior to him in that situation by choosing to give birth to Dua and raising her as a symbol of their love. Vik realised what she meant whenever she asked him to trust without proofs.

Whatever calmness and understanding Vik has developed towards Mannats way of working is only after that event. 👍

Moor278 thumbnail
Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 3 hours ago

Originally posted by: Mona_HappyLife

Lol woh bhi ho hi jaayegi 🤣🤣

It was hilarious how Y was giving gyaan to Dua on not trusting people on face value and making faces at MR while she herself had tried to kill Dua once and was working against ManVik.


Sirf Whitewash nahi Pura ka pura bleach ho gaya 🤣🤣🤣🤣

Related Topics

Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7 · 1 years ago

Permission given by Leprechaun

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: purplegirl7 · 1 years ago

Welcome to Chat Corner for Mannat forum We can do gupshup here

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: Shemer · 1 years ago

Welcome to BTS Thread of MHKPK...

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7 · 2 months ago

Hi ya'all! This thread is for reactions on X (formerly Twitter) so that it cheers people if they are having a bad day: Will just post tweets...

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7 · 4 months ago

WRITTEN UPDATES AND DAILY DISCUSSION THREAD NO 41 Welcome to Mannat - Har Khushi Paane Ki EDT Permission given by leprecheun

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".