Kyunki Saas Bhi Kabhi Bahu Thi-EDT #18 - Page 32

Originally posted by: RamonaG

Achcha aadmi was in which show it sounds so familiar 🤔

Originally posted by: SaHi_Fan

Everyone hating on Tulsi for no reason. She doesnt have to be mahaan, just like Nandini is not being the bigger person in the situation. Why should Tulsi have to pick and side with Nandini's view all the time.

I get Nandini's trauma, but again I think more of her blame should be on Karan than Tulsi. Tulsi cannot differentiate between Karan and uska beta vs. Ansh and uska beta.

Also, Karan shouldn't have been easily white washed and forgiven he spend 20 years hiding the fact that he is pretend playing family with another woman and child.

KN are not an ideal couple at all, neither were they in season 1 or now. Nandini wasn't forced to marry Ansh she did it because she looked up to Tulsi and the Virani's took care of her. Karan sacrificed because of his history and his love for Tulsi, but they could have stood up for their love.

If Tulsi shouldn't agree with Nandini's view then why does she expect Nandini's,why expect her to happily accept Niyati and Reyansh when he openly blamed her defended his rapist dad, why shouldn't be she upset, in current scenario definitely Nandini is way bigger person than Tulsi as she trying to accommodate with Niyati and Reyansh who are kept and illegitimate son of her rapist bit what does she get insult from Reyansh and she shouldn't even complain, any wife would get hurt to see other woman getting close to her husband in her own house, yes Karan did started it but it was for Tulsi's sake! He didn't bring them to SN with which Nandini agreed just for Tulsi's happiness, despite all the trauma she faced she controlled herself and didn't reveal her marriage to Niyati or Reyansh not being Karan's son, Niyati herself saw the pic and overheard the conversation which was started by Tulsi not Nandini, still Nandini asked about her health update and what did Tulsi do! Blame Nandini for Niyati's accident and ask her to leave not only SN but Karan as well, how dare she say that to Nandini which Tulsi's own son also pointed out to be wrong, but yes Tulsi is right! Tulsi is not only the one who has sacrificed and accepted! Karan and Nandini did too for her happiness but they don't rant of doing favor which Tulsi does every now and then!

Originally posted by: Ajab.Pehchan

Oh yes thanks I remember him now

Originally posted by: bjsh82

If Tulsi shouldn't agree with Nandini's view then why does she expect Nandini's,why expect her to happily accept Niyati and Reyansh when he openly blamed her defended his rapist dad, why shouldn't be she upset, in current scenario definitely Nandini is way bigger person than Tulsi as she trying to accommodate with Niyati and Reyansh who are kept and illegitimate son of her rapist bit what does she get insult from Reyansh and she shouldn't even complain, any wife would get hurt to see other woman getting close to her husband in her own house, yes Karan did started it but it was for Tulsi's sake! He didn't bring them to SN with which Nandini agreed just for Tulsi's happiness, despite all the trauma she faced she controlled herself and didn't reveal her marriage to Niyati or Reyansh not being Karan's son, Niyati herself saw the pic and overheard the conversation which was started by Tulsi not Nandini, still Nandini asked about her health update and what did Tulsi do! Blame Nandini for Niyati's accident and ask her to leave not only SN but Karan as well, how dare she say that to Nandini which Tulsi's own son also pointed out to be wrong, but yes Tulsi is right! Tulsi is not only the one who has sacrificed and accepted! Karan and Nandini did too for her happiness but they don't rant of doing favor which Tulsi does every now and then!

Sorry what did Karan and Nandini accepted? No one asked Karan to take care of Niyati and Rio to be frank he should have told Tulsi or Mihir right away about this and let them handle it when he first found them. He didnt know Rio was going to look like Ansh when he grows up.

Again Nandini can leave if she doesnt want to be around Niyati and Rio. They lived in the US for years, her husband is buying properties in India she has many options.

Originally posted by: SaHi_Fan

Sorry what did Karan and Nandini accepted? No one asked Karan to take care of Niyati and Rio to be frank he should have told Tulsi or Mihir right away about this and let them handle it when he first found them. He didnt know Rio was going to look like Ansh when he grows up.

Again Nandini can leave if she doesnt want to be around Niyati and Rio. They lived in the US for years, her husband is buying properties in India she has many options.

i just want to understand what right does Niyati have to stay in that house??

And why isn't Reyansh being told to accept that his father was a monster..

Why can't Niyati and Rio be expected to compromise a bit?

Yes Nandani has options to go and she should go and Karan did create this mess. No justification for that, but is it needed to further enhance that mess?

Originally posted by: SaHi_Fan

Sorry what did Karan and Nandini accepted? No one asked Karan to take care of Niyati and Rio to be frank he should have told Tulsi or Mihir right away about this and let them handle it when he first found them. He didnt know Rio was going to look like Ansh when he grows up.

Again Nandini can leave if she doesnt want to be around Niyati and Rio. They lived in the US for years, her husband is buying properties in India she has many options.

Tulsi rants of accepting Mandira's son but conveniently forgets that Mandira's son sacrificed his love for her son which she never mentions ,Karan accepted Reyansh and gave his name and took care of Niyati when Tulsi's own son abandoned them, of Karan had option do the same none would knew they even exist, but does he ever rants that he has sacrificed his love, gone against his own mother, gave name to her grand child which own criminal son has failed to do so, who never considered himself as Virani and never changed! Nandini accepted to support Karan's decision to take care of her rapist family for Tulsi's sake but that's not really important only what Tulsi does is important and bye why should Nandini leave SN it's their family house , it existed even before Tulsi existed! SN isn't Mihir - Tulsi private property like Malabar hill is Karan's personal property!Nandini can live wherever she wants to, she has right to live anywhere, she was even leaving SN but stayed for children sake and also Karan wasn't present.

BTW you said it right Karan should have let Tulsi handle her son's affair and child as he isn't worth of Karan's love and upbringing which he have proved by defending his criminal father's deed, blaming Nandini of not adjusting in marriage but doesn't find any wrong in his mother being pregnant out of wedlock and not to forget planning rape allegation on himself to gain Tulsi's trust to take revenge! Tulsi deserved criminal Ansh now Reyansh following the same footstep! Only when Reyansh will take revenge and ruin everything thing she will realize Nandini was right and Mandira's son Karan is far better than her own son and grandson! Don't worry that time will come soon and we shall see who will have to live where!

Originally posted by: FlauntPessimism

i just want to understand what right does Niyati have to stay in that house??

And why isn't Reyansh being told to accept that his father was a monster..

Why can't Niyati and Rio be expected to compromise a bit?

Yes Nandani has options to go and she should go and Karan did create this mess. No justification for that, but is it needed to further enhance that mess?

I mean honestly anyone can stay at SN, Niyati doesnt have a direct right but she can stay through Rio as long as the house owners dont have a problem.

ReAnsh was told that his father is a monster, he hasn't really questioned that other than in front of Khusboo and Nandini.

Playing Devil's advocate here. Rio comes to know that his whole life has been a lie, his father is his uncle and his father was killed by his Dadi for assaulting a woman that was married to him who is now married to uncle. From someone who hasn't really experienced Ansh first hand he cant really just be like everyone is telling my father is a monster so he must be. Most people will question and want to do their research. He cant just take people's word for it especially from the people he just met.

As much as I do not support Rio and his views of assault whether you are married or not. His warriness of Nandini makes sense because she was married to his father and now is married to his half brother like that sounds like an affair to someone looking from outside in.

Rio is a villain all in all no doubts that he needs to fall. But my problem is Nandini is just questioning Tulsi and wanting her to do what she wants, while her husband has done all kinds of stupid things.

Nandini'd anger is misdirected.

Originally posted by: SaHi_Fan

I mean honestly anyone can stay at SN, Niyati doesnt have a direct right but she can stay through Rio as long as the house owners dont have a problem.

ReAnsh was told that his father is a monster, he hasn't really questioned that other than in front of Khusboo and Nandini.

Playing Devil's advocate here. Rio comes to know that his whole life has been a lie, his father is his uncle and his father was killed by his Dadi for assaulting a woman that was married to him who is now married to uncle. From someone who hasn't really experienced Ansh first hand he cant really just be like everyone is telling my father is a monster so he must be. Most people will question and want to do their research. He cant just take people's word for it especially from the people he just met.

As much as I do not support Rio and his views of assault whether you are married or not. His warriness of Nandini makes sense because she was married to his father and now is married to his half brother like that sounds like an affair to someone looking from outside in.

Rio is a villain all in all no doubts that he needs to fall. But my problem is Nandini is just questioning Tulsi and wanting her to do what she wants, while her husband has done all kinds of stupid things.

Nandini'd anger is misdirected.

I am not discussing whether Reyansh is good or bad or if he is justified or not, but he did badmouth Nandani in front of everyone, he was told Ansh was a monster but never convinced with evidence. Not even the complete truth was told on how he was abducting Nandani

Reyansh can have multiple reasons to become evil and I am not someone who can comment on it, my problem is with response of family members.

But your very point about as an outsider Reyansh was bound to think that KN had affair and that's why they got Ansh out of line is the reason why he should have been given complete details and picture about what happened back then

Nandani is very much a part of the household and she has problem with Niyati. So you point that anyone can stay there till owner has no problem doesn't hold here. As we already discussed SN is a family house and not individual property of Mihir Tulsi.

Nandani's anger is misdirected because Hiten isn't shooting, else obviously she would have been angry at both Tulsi and Karan..

Originally posted by: FlauntPessimism

I am not discussing whether Reyansh is good or bad or if he is justified or not, but he did badmouth Nandani in front of everyone, he was told Ansh was a monster but never convinced with evidence. Not even the complete truth was told on how he was abducting Nandani

Reyansh can have multiple reasons to become evil and I am not someone who can comment on it, my problem is with response of family members.

But your very point about as an outsider Reyansh was bound to think that KN had affair and that's why they got Ansh out of line is the reason why he should have been given complete details and picture about what happened back then

Nandani is very much a part of the household and she has problem with Niyati. So you point that anyone can stay there till owner has no problem doesn't hold here. As we already discussed SN is a family house and not individual property of Mihir Tulsi.

Nandani's anger is misdirected because Hiten isn't shooting, else obviously she would have been angry at both Tulsi and Karan..

I dont think SN is a family house, I do think it belongs to Mihir and Tulsi, unless everyone's name is on the deed. Everyone else has seemed to move out and come and go as they please.

Originally posted by: SaHi_Fan

I dont think SN is a family house, I do think it belongs to Mihir and Tulsi, unless everyone's name is on the deed. Everyone else has seemed to move out and come and go as they please.

that's their choice. many people leave their family homes and move out for their career.

SN was built by Govardhan even before Mihir was born. And it's clear except for Himmat 's family, none of them have had the property distributed (Tulsi clearly said that)