Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 39 - Page 98

Originally posted by: Moor278

If Mukta is intent on following Ektas template then VY shaadi puri hogi. Third times a charm 🙈

Uske baad truth reveal hoga possibly of Dua.

Y will ask for all Property to be transferred in her name in exchange for divorce to Vik which he will do.

Thode din gareeb Vikku milega till they realise Vik never sent or signed the divorce papers to Mannat which will make VY marriage invalid.

And Mannat will help Vik get back all the property... probably then he will stop calling her GD 🤦‍♀️

Wow why did you write this? Any news? Also I saw a clip where he is wall pinning mannat. 😕. Is it a dream or something from preleap ? If it is real it is proved that he is not into the engagement and moving on process but just said yes to jellofy mannat who he thinks is happily married with his brother. Are the writers tripping on his character?

Isse accha toh Y se shadi kar leta and sabak seekhta

Coolmeg, loved your DCP in the first 5 minute. Stopped Vik and calmly rejected the offer and as he predicted Vishaka started her drama. He almost addressed her as maa then corrected himself and addressed her with name instead. Stood up for Mannat and gave back to Vishaka without explaining himself. Felt a bit bad for him, the woman who gave birth and raised him was spewing nonsense about him.

Saw Anirudh after so long in the fb, is he dead? Today they gave apt bgm when Mannat saw ARS. One side was scared and the other shocked. ARS started her drama while Malla smartly tried to get her out of SM. Didnt know they had wheelchair in SM.

Yashika is observing everything, but its not time for her to know more yet. Just praised Yuvi yesterday and he is back to his ziddi self stopping a lady from her 'washroom break'.

Mannat attack on ARS was whistle worthy. Ek naari sab pe bhari. Dragged ARS out of the wheelchair onto the floor. Dhairya was holding her arm trying to get things done with words, still she tried to attack again. The brothers want Mannat to get tasalli, both with opposite intention but ARS know sab shock ho jayenge.

Post leap ARS somehow looks a bit human. Getting scared of Mannat and getting panic attack thinking she will send her back to jail.

Vishaka in her overconfidence made things worse for ARS. First trying to aag lagao, figuratively, as Dhairya was leaving and ARS enters literally on fire. Then threatening with calling Commissioner with a fugitive by her side. One thing she did good today was recognising the saree Yashika mom wore.

Originally posted by: Rdigest

Moor, I didn't mean to push you, apologizes if my post came across unruly ❤️ . We all can stick to our opinions and debate. Just cause I don't believe what you are pointing out and you don't believe what I am pointing out neither one is wrong or not the other is correct from each of our perspectives.

How is it common sense and not gender bias when we treat mistakes and criticize characters based on gender?

"Vikrant was the father unknowingly but did he had to go thru all the trouble pre, during & post pregnancy ? No."

This is the comment I responded to , and here's my comment "We are judging Vikrant not for his actions but because he is a male and he cannot conceive. Would Vikrant CA be any less of a mistake had Vikrant been female character and conceived while they separated?"

Did I say Mannat cannot take decisions for Dua's well-being? In my post I was only referring to making a pact about lying to Dua repeating the same mistake and lying on BC. Infact you can ho back and see my posts, I even pointed out who is Neetu to reveal the truth when she lied to Dua to meet Vikrant.

Where is the well being here , atleast not from my understanding. Infact I was glad atleast for lying Ronnie showed them the mirror. However, we cannot call out Mannat for repeating the same mistakes like pre-leap because this is attributed to safeguarding Dua. If it was safe guarding Dua why didn't she protest and put her foot down with Ronnie?

Now coming back to my post, let's take Vikrant for example, does his CA Mannat be any less of a mistake if he were a female and gone through pregnancy, post pregnancy, had a baby ? No, it will not is the point I am trying to make. So Mannat should be critized when she doesn't learn from her mistakes, Mannat should be held responsible for what happened pre-leap just like Vikrant made mistakes pre and post leap.

Mona, my whole post was about gender bias and how audience is reacting to similar situations so ofcourse I brought up the topic.

Did you see any of my posts defending Vikrant's CA, his scenes with Y , him agreeing to marry Y ? Please point me to my posts so I can rectify my mistake.

And regarding DK, yes you will see my posts for this character, because Y is portrayed as a GD and for what she is, DK he committed crimes, used his position for his benefit, dumped his brother knowing what Vish did to him, supported Vish about taking Saluja wealth , so yes I dislike his character and call him out since makers are not calling him out. I constantly pointed out if he is intended to be a good character, why didn't he try and meet up Vikrant again and explain things , this is the same brother he apparently loved for years. Remember what he told Neetu, he has nothing to do with Vikrant, would a brother knowing he is stuck with his vicious mother act this way ?

You are circling back to this same discussion you had with Kidult Shazia few days back

Has the show ended? Are all the truths out?

Bold... you are holding Mannat accountable on that one statement she has said few months back.

People change according to situations. Mannat has also changed. She did not want to come to Mumbai yet she has and is now living in SM for Neetu's sake. Similarly, as of today Mannat believes Vik rejected the child and thinks its DKs. She doesnt know Vik is innocent in this matter.

Who knows she herself might reveal it to Vik after she finds out he was lied to!!!!

Why are you making a presumption based on a future scenario which hasnt happened yet?

Isnt that your bias against Mannat????

Let the truths reveal and if she still doesnt reveal then crucify her.

We dont know how she will react... why make assumptions and criticize her for something that has not happened.

Pink... The well being is based on current state of conditions.... as of today Vik has done nothing that warrants he should be told... pre leap MUs and post leap behaviour which guarantees that he might accept Dua and keep her safe. He lives with 2 witches who are against Mannat. Till yesterday's episode Vik was married in Mannats eyes...

So what was Mannat going to tell Dua???Just tell me this....

That you father disowned me on mandap and threw me out??? Doesn't want to have any association for you.

Isn't it better than Dua has no knowledge of Viks kaands. Why do you want Mannat to spoil Viks image in Duas mind???

Can Mannat guess how Vik would have reacted then???? Or now? Can she make a life changing decision for a child based on a hypothetical scenario????

Even now... what is it that you want Mannat to tell Dua??? And how is it going to be beneficial for her?

Purple... just like you repeatedly say that Vik cant have realization without knowing some truths same goes for Mannat... what has she seen post leap that might make her think she was wrong???? Does any of those truths which have hurt her tremendously come out???

Who is biased here now, you or me??? Why dont you extend the same courtesy to Mannat which you expect for Vikrant???

I doubt there is even one person in the audience who wants Vik to not know that Dua is his daughter. Thats all we have been hoping waiting and manifesting for... so that he calms down a little bit. And starts seeing the true colours of the vamps... but that has not happened yet... doesnt mean it will never happen...

If you expect others to give leeway to Vik because he is still stuck... so is Mannat. She hasnt healed either. And her trauma is equally valid. She hides it well unlike Vik who wears his emotions on his sleeve.

If there is anything DK has not been able to provide is healing from that trauma. Because thats Vikrants job. Only he can heal Mannat. Let it happen atleast before judging her actions.

I.liked today's episode..Mannu turns tables and how....Ash knows Mannu has an agenda behind this act. All believe Mannu has accepted she is Arzoo but not Aishwarya....this maa beti knows eo very well....

Guess that fire incident wala thing will come true since it's going to be Mallas kaand in harming Dua....its this probably where Dua will be stuck and both Manvik will save her. Vanku ki yaad aa jayegi agar aisa hua toh.. dekhte hai

Originally posted by: sadiltl

Wow why did you write this? Any news? Also I saw a clip where he is wall pinning mannat. 😕. Is it a dream or something from preleap ? If it is real it is proved that he is not into the engagement and moving on process but just said yes to jellofy mannat who he thinks is happily married with his brother. Are the writers tripping on his character?

Isse accha toh Y se shadi kar leta and sabak seekhta

This is a hypothetical scenario which I have written... based on one of EKs show...

Since she loves Ekta universe.. might as well pick it up.

Vikrant needs to see who is real GD and should be gareeb for some days atleast 😝... just to give him a taste of what its like 😂

Originally posted by: nutmeg7

Vikrant ki nazar mei yeh apne bade bhai Dhairya ki wife hai naa...

Toh yeh apne "bhabhi" ke piche kyu pada hai

https://x.com/santoshi1905/status/2025847554198622567

Now you are thinking like me finally!

Originally posted by: Moor278

You are circling back to this same discussion you had with Kidult Shazia few days back

Has the show ended? Are all the truths out?

Bold... you are holding Mannat accountable on that one statement she has said few months back.

People change according to situations. Mannat has also changed. She did not want to come to Mumbai yet she has and is now living in SM for Neetu's sake. Similarly, as of today Mannat believes Vik rejected the child and thinks its DKs. She doesnt know Vik is innocent in this matter.

Who knows she herself might reveal it to Vik after she finds out he was lied to!!!!

Why are you making a presumption based on a future scenario which hasnt happened yet?

Isnt that your bias against Mannat????

Let the truths reveal and if she still doesnt reveal then crucify her.

We dont know how she will react... why make assumptions and criticize her for something that has not happened.

Pink... The well being is based on current state of conditions.... as of today Vik has done nothing that warrants he should be told... pre leap MUs and post leap behaviour which guarantees that he might accept Dua and keep her safe. He lives with 2 witches who are against Mannat. Till yesterday's episode Vik was married in Mannats eyes...

So what was Mannat going to tell Dua???Just tell me this....

That you father disowned me on mandap and threw me out??? Doesn't want to have any association for you.

Isn't it better than Dua has no knowledge of Viks kaands. Why do you want Mannat to spoil Viks image in Duas mind???

Can Mannat guess how Vik would have reacted then???? Or now? Can she make a life changing decision for a child based on a hypothetical scenario????

Even now... what is it that you want Mannat to tell Dua??? And how is it going to be beneficial for her?

Purple... just like you repeatedly say that Vik cant have realization without knowing some truths same goes for Mannat... what has she seen post leap that might make her think she was wrong???? Does any of those truths which have hurt her tremendously come out???

Who is biased here now, you or me??? Why dont you extend the same courtesy to Mannat which you expect for Vikrant???

I doubt there is even one person in the audience who wants Vik to not know that Dua is his daughter. Thats all we have been hoping waiting and manifesting for... so that he calms down a little bit. And starts seeing the true colours of the vamps... but that has not happened yet... doesnt mean it will never happen...

If you expect others to give leeway to Vik because he is still stuck... so is Mannat. She hasnt healed either. And her trauma is equally valid. She hides it well unlike Vik who wears his emotions on his sleeve.

If there is anything DK has not been able to provide is healing from that trauma. Because thats Vikrants job. Only he can heal Mannat. Let it happen atleast before judging her actions.

Bold:

We all want the villains exposed, the snakes in chains, strait jackets & in dark bottomless pits, and the permanent volcano Vikrant to stop flaring his angry nostrils & start observing. BUT, i don’t see this set of makers and writers ever doing that. Show will end,but loops will never be closed nor justice served.

Originally posted by: Resham

I.liked today's episode..Mannu turns tables and how....Ash knows Mannu has an agenda behind this act. All believe Mannu has accepted she is Arzoo but not Aishwarya....this maa beti knows eo very well....

Guess that fire incident wala thing will come true since it's going to be Mallas kaand in harming Dua....its this probably where Dua will be stuck and both Manvik will save her. Vanku ki yaad aa jayegi agar aisa hua toh.. dekhte hai

https://x.com/i/status/2026115030086033914

Just observed one thing today, vikrant despite his issues, anger on mannat..he immediately started addressing mannat's concerns , he hardly cared about dk-mannat in there, all he cared was at that moment mannat needs assurance, she was panicking and he saw ,understands the trauma she feels looking at ars and was addressing her concerns and stood up by her even when they are on opposite sides of truth.... We might call out vik for his trust issues and rightfully so but have to give credit where it is due, he does stand up by mannat when she needs him more even when they are on opposite sides of truth..

this is what matters the most because complete blind trust on anyone is too unrealistic..because no matter how much we love and trust someone at the end of the day our loved ones are humans too who would make mistakes by emotions, misunderstanding,haste,negligence..so not believing in our close ones at times thinking that they are misunderstanding because of emotions, haste we might sometimes end up on opposite sides of truth with our loved ones but despite being on opposite sides of truth we need to stand up by them when they need us more,we might still fight for our own versions of truth but still manage to be on our loved ones sides by giving them emotional support and understanding when they need it more... this is where mannat falters a bit..

Vik falls on wrong side by not able to trust mannat at times but he proves his love by standing by mannat even when they are on opposite side when he sees she needs him more, where as mannat proves her love by trusting Vik but falters to stand by Vik when they are on opposite side not realising when he needs her more...

Vik being the one majorily faulty in the way things turned out to be, he is the one who needs to realise his mistakes and apologize big time and has to take initiative to seek forgiveness but if and when mannat forgives Vik.. from my pov mannat too should realise her little mistake🤏... and then decide if she wants to go back to him or just forgive and move on from him.

Originally posted by: ChaoticTangles

Just observed one thing today, vikrant despite his issues, anger on mannat..he immediately started addressing mannat's concerns , he hardly cared about dk-mannat in there, all he cared was at that moment mannat needs assurance, she was panicking and he saw ,understands the trauma she feels looking at ars and was addressing her concerns and stood up by her even when they are on opposite sides of truth.... We might call out vik for his trust issues and rightfully so but have to give credit where it is due, he does stand up by mannat when she needs him more even when they are on opposite sides of truth..

this is what matters the most because complete blind trust on anyone is too unrealistic..because no matter how much we love and trust someone at the end of the day our loved ones are humans too who would make mistakes by emotions, misunderstanding,haste,negligence....thus sometimes because of this we might end up on opposite sides of truth with our loved ones but despite being on opposite sides of truth we need to stand up by them when they need us more... this is where mannat flatters a bit..

Vik falls on wrong side by not able to trust mannat at times but he proves his love by standing by mannat even when they are on opposite side when he sees she needs him more, where as mannat proves her love by trusting Vik but flatters to stand by Vik when they are on opposite side not realising when he needs her more...

Vik being the one majorily faulty in the way things turned out to be, he is the one who needs to realise his mistakes and apologize big time and has to take initiative to seek forgiveness but if and when mannat forgives Vik.. from my pov mannat too should realise her little mistake🤏... and then decide if she wants to go back to him or just forgive and move on from him.

Absolutely you're right..

Despite standing on opposite sides, he stood by her. I feel he understood her agenda of exposing ARS in accepting the deal,too. He was not fooled by her, but accepted her reasons...