Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai - Episode Discussion Thread #1 - Page 142

Originally posted by: A_Star39

there is zero communication for armaan and abhira

Bhai he was nonstop barking tum maira ki maa nahi ho blah blah and did he even think where is abhira for two weeks.He saw abhira was injured and limping around and he didnt even think once what if something happens to abhira?

Armaan ran away with maira 7 years ago and still abhira accepted him and didnt marry anshuman and snatched armaan's rights

wouldnt armaan talk to abhira once and ask his silly girl what happened?It is really clear that vidya and armaan did lot of mehnat to make sure abhira stays away from maira

Kaveri went to mussorie to search for abhira and armaan became so heartless?

Maira's trauma is somewhat similar to what kairav suffered in gen 2.Kartik instead of shooing away naira shifted to mumbai with naira,kairav and akshu and lived with kairav alone in one apartment and naira and akshu lived in another apartment

kairav was recieving therapy and kartik was trying to ease kairav's trauma

Armaan's real POV of Abhira and Maira's relationship is that abhira is not maira's mom since she didnt give birth to her.he tries to be green flag and convince himself that he is wrong but at any point his real POV comes out

Armaan is narrow minded and is narcissist

Armaan is a 50 year man for godsake.Men are not this DUMB.He knows what he was doing.I cannot believe we are blaming writers ,loopholes ,inconsistencies for his behaviour

His mindset towards motherhood is narrowminded

also i feel maira and abhira are a fitting example of armaan and shivani

Vidya is kaveri and armaan is vidya

@bold - Obviously writers only will be questioned for writing fictional characters, unfortunately Armaan or any other fictional character doesn’t write their own script as most of them believe here

Originally posted by: chabalas

@bold - Obviously writers only will be questioned for writing fictional characters, unfortunately Armaan or any other fictional character doesn’t write their own script as most of them believe here

Its their story

They want armaan to be like this

If this was the first case of armaan questioning abhira's motherhood we could say yup writers are doing injustice to him.Poor baby

Its the second time this scumbag is doing this

Its his character and mindset

He is a manchild and this is evident from start of gen itself

Itni besharmi nahi hai mujhme

I cannot sympathise with a scum questioning a lady's fertility every time

There is a limit and it has been crossed now

He never loved abhira

Its very much evident.

For him it was first

Kaveri-Vidya-Abhira

Then Shivani-Abhira

And Now Maira-Vidya-Abhira.

Writers want him to be pathetic

Originally posted by: A_Star39

Why are you even blaming the writers for armaan

Its their story

They want armaan to be like this

If this was the first case of armaan questioning abhira's motherhood we could say yup writers are doing injustice to him.Poor baby

Its the second time this scumbag is doing this

Its his character and mindset

He is a manchild and this is evident from start of gen itself

Itni besharmi nahi hai mujhme

I cannot sympathise with a scum questioning a lady's fertility every time

There is a limit and it has been crossed now

He never loved abhira

Its very much evident.

For him it was first

Kaveri-Vidya-Abhira

Then Shivani-Abhira

And Now Maira-Vidya-Abhira.

Writers want him to be pathetic

He is the most pathetic guy in ITV.

Even viraj dobriyal is impressed by this guy's nautanki

Originally posted by: A_Star39

Why are you even blaming the writers for armaan

Its their story

They want armaan to be like this

If this was the first case of armaan questioning abhira's motherhood we could say yup writers are doing injustice to him.Poor baby

Its the second time this scumbag is doing this

Its his character and mindset

He is a manchild and this is evident from start of gen itself

Itni besharmi nahi hai mujhme

I cannot sympathise with a scum questioning a lady's fertility every time

There is a limit and it has been crossed now

He never loved abhira

Its very much evident.

For him it was first

Kaveri-Vidya-Abhira

Then Shivani-Abhira

And Now Maira-Vidya-Abhira.

Writers want him to be pathetic

I want to know, when did Armaan question Abhira's fertility? He questioned her love for Maira when he says that she didn't birth Maira that's why she doesn't feel the connect with her. That's what he questioned. Fertility is a whole other story & he cannot question that because Abhira was pregnant & delivered BSP, even if he died after.

Armaan questioning her motherhood is wrong, because he took did not birth Maira. And that's what he apologized for last time & I won't be surprised if he does that again & Abhira forgives him as well.

As for questioning her fertility, Kaveri & Vidya questioned it multiple times, taunted her for it, saying woh kabhi maa nahi ban sakti hai & can never give the family a "waris". Yet despite saying all that, Abhira formed a Tigdi with both of them and happily lived with them for 4 years. Kaveri & Vidya have been the most narrow minded people who questioned the entire surrogacy process and were against it from the start, yet they're okay, but Armaan is wrong.

Baaki no matter what I say, I know none of us can ever change your mind about Armaan. But it will be super funny if even after all this, Abhira goes back to Armaan, Maira, Vidya & Pfam, saying she forgives them for everything

Originally posted by: Apsvenky

I want to know, when did Armaan question Abhira's fertility? He questioned her love for Maira when he says that she didn't birth Maira that's why she doesn't feel the connect with her. That's what he questioned. Fertility is a whole other story & he cannot question that because Abhira was pregnant & delivered BSP, even if he died after.

Armaan questioning her motherhood is wrong, because he took did not birth Maira. And that's what he apologized for last time & I won't be surprised if he does that again & Abhira forgives him as well.

As for questioning her fertility, Kaveri & Vidya questioned it multiple times, taunted her for it, saying woh kabhi maa nahi ban sakti hai & can never give the family a "waris". Yet despite saying all that, Abhira formed a Tigdi with both of them and happily lived with them for 4 years. Kaveri & Vidya have been the most narrow minded people who questioned the entire surrogacy process and were against it from the start, yet they're okay, but Armaan is wrong.

Baaki no matter what I say, I know none of us can ever change your mind about Armaan. But it will be super funny if even after all this, Abhira goes back to Armaan, Maira, Vidya & Pfam, saying she forgives them for everything

@Bold in normal language, that's the taunt only that you couldn't give birth Maira and hence you aren't connected. I think that's exactly what writers also meant to say.

It's unfortunate that Miss Doormat Jogan keeps forgiving him but trp audience is giving it right back with 0 interest in Armoron and his Jogan. Their lusty scenes are core reason for show's downfall and nothing can change that.

And it's not going to be funny that she goes back to them, but another straw on her character that's gonna finally either close this show or lead to generation leap before closing.

AbhiMoron are REJECTED by audience and they are only bunch of losers who keep uniting to have only one thing - SEX! That's it. Their love is a lie and fake.. All they need is to fulfill their hawas, which doesn't get this show trp.

Originally posted by: A_Star39

Why are you even blaming the writers for armaan

Its their story

They want armaan to be like this

If this was the first case of armaan questioning abhira's motherhood we could say yup writers are doing injustice to him.Poor baby

Its the second time this scumbag is doing this

Its his character and mindset

He is a manchild and this is evident from start of gen itself

Itni besharmi nahi hai mujhme

I cannot sympathise with a scum questioning a lady's fertility every time

There is a limit and it has been crossed now

He never loved abhira

Its very much evident.

For him it was first

Kaveri-Vidya-Abhira

Then Shivani-Abhira

And Now Maira-Vidya-Abhira.

Writers want him to be pathetic

Then whom to blame ? Armaan, the fictional character ? It's their story which they are only writing, it's their mindset to portary a man like this so they only should be questioned? Why do they want him to be like that ? Why show such regressive content in 2026 mocking real societal issues every time? Real people who are writing characters have to be questioned for their thought process and showing their lead in that way because they are only responsible for it, not the imaginary character?

Originally posted by: shahsb_26

@Bold in normal language, that's the taunt only that you couldn't give birth Maira and hence you aren't connected. I think that's exactly what writers also meant to say.

It's unfortunate that Miss Doormat Jogan keeps forgiving him but trp audience is giving it right back with 0 interest in Armoron and his Jogan. Their lusty scenes are core reason for show's downfall and nothing can change that.

And it's not going to be funny that she goes back to them, but another straw on her character that's gonna finally either close this show or lead to generation leap before closing.

AbhiMoron are REJECTED by audience and they are only bunch of losers who keep uniting to have only one thing - SEX! That's it. Their love is a lie and fake.. All they need is to fulfill their hawas, which doesn't get this show trp.

Abhimaan ka pyaar Sacha hai.They love each other's soul

Not bodies1

Don't you know abhimaan were welcomed like ramji and sitaji on Diwali?

/s

Originally posted by: chabalas

Then whom to blame ? Armaan, the fictional character ? It's their story which they are only writing, it's their mindset to portary a man like this so they only should be questioned? Why do they want him to be like that ? Why show such regressive content in 2026 mocking real societal issues every time? Real people who are writing characters have to be questioned for their thought process and showing their lead in that way because they are only responsible for it, not the imaginary character?

Its their choice of writing armaan like this.We have the option to watch and not watch lol.Coz writers won't listen to us.

I prefer to troll the clownery and nonsense writers are serving

I just hate the toxic behaviour and misogynistic mindset armaan has.

Abhira would obviously go back to silly boy and

I am out of words

Originally posted by: Apsvenky

I want to know, when did Armaan question Abhira's fertility? He questioned her love for Maira when he says that she didn't birth Maira that's why she doesn't feel the connect with her. That's what he questioned. Fertility is a whole other story & he cannot question that because Abhira was pregnant & delivered BSP, even if he died after.

Armaan questioning her motherhood is wrong, because he took did not birth Maira. And that's what he apologized for last time & I won't be surprised if he does that again & Abhira forgives him as well.

As for questioning her fertility, Kaveri & Vidya questioned it multiple times, taunted her for it, saying woh kabhi maa nahi ban sakti hai & can never give the family a "waris". Yet despite saying all that, Abhira formed a Tigdi with both of them and happily lived with them for 4 years. Kaveri & Vidya have been the most narrow minded people who questioned the entire surrogacy process and were against it from the start, yet they're okay, but Armaan is wrong.

Baaki no matter what I say, I know none of us can ever change your mind about Armaan. But it will be super funny if even after all this, Abhira goes back to Armaan, Maira, Vidya & Pfam, saying she forgives them for everything

A baby born through surrogacy, adoption, or IVF may arrive by different procedures, but a child is always connected to their mother. No one is entitled to question that bond—not even the father. Imagine someone asking him, “Why do you feel connected to Maira? After all, you didn’t give birth to her.” That would be callous and insensitive.

@red: There are some mistakes that do not deserve forgiveness; this is one of them. If a person keeps forgiving someone who has never cared about or respected them, what does that say about their self-respect? It’s nothing short of character assassination. If she doesn’t value her own respect, no one else will.

The worst part is that she has never questioned or confronted him about his actions. Whether anyone else does or not, she should have. I don’t mean for token effect. And yes, what Vidya and Kaveri have done doesn’t deserve forgiveness either.

Armaan’s actions are more damaging and toxic because he, as her partner, promised to love, respect and cherish her. They haven’t. Their callous actions might have hurt her but it doesn’t have the power to break her. Also they didn’t run away with the kid, separating her from her own daughter.

Abhira has always had to bear the brunt of his actions. So why does she keep forgiving him? This is not love. Is it Stockholm syndrome—loving someone who has no qualms about abusing her? It may not be physical, but his actions have left scars. Is it a desperate need for family? All I know is that this is not normal.

Originally posted by: A_Star39

then the actor playing should take a stand for the constant degradation of his character and how his character is so toxic

Its their choice of writing armaan like this.We have the option to watch and not watch lol.Coz writers won't listen to us.

I prefer to troll the clownery and nonsense writers are serving

I just hate the toxic behaviour and misogynistic mindset armaan has.

Abhira would obviously go back to silly boy and

I am out of words