Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 38 - Page 97

Originally posted by: Daman17

I looked at scene different angle. DK has taken care of Mannat and family for years, and after hearing Vik’s name from Dua, Neetu got her senses back and it has triggered her inner turmoil which she couldn’t express. That moment lightened hope in her that her broken family could be restored. Although she had long sensed how DK and Mannat functioned together, Vik’s name revived a possibility she had mentally held on to. The writers used this moment to show a shift in DK’s emotional arc. Neetu’s repeated pushing led DK to finally acknowledge his feelings in front of her while Mannat remains unaware. To Mannat, DK is still just a dependable friend. Neetu questioning DK’s intentions and labelling their relationship only makes Mannat resent Vik more as she feels his presence is the reason Neetu has turned against DK and forgotten his sacrifices. In the dream sequence, Vik apologising to DK is not about DK being mahaan. It reflects Vik’s guilt over his past actions especially the CA incident, which made him believe he had lost his family forever. From his perspective, the apology comes from regret over hurting Mannat and disrupting multiple lives. Neetu knows that Dua is Vikrant and Mannat’s child. She tried to tell Vikrant, but Mannat stopped her due to past trauma, and DK also intervened for Mannat and stopped Neetu meeting Vik. In that heated moment, Neetu accused DK of deliberately keeping Vikrant away, leading DK to admit his feelings while stating he never crossed boundaries and knows Mannat still loves Vikrant. In Neetu’s dream, DK appears as the son she once accepted who was supportive of ManVik. This is not Neetu seeing DK as mahaan but her subconscious mind trying to resolve an uncontrollable reality. DK’s happiness in the dream reflects Neetu’s wish for peace, not DK’s emotional truth. The dream ultimately reveals Neetu’s inner conflict between her son’s past mistakes, Mannat’s pain, DK’s unspoken emotions, and her desire to reunite her family.

Love this.... this is what I made it out to be

But I refrained from saying it since I am a certified mahaan DK lawyer.... I hope you understand . Did not want more indirects

Bold.... on these lines.... I am still trying to wrap my head around this but I feel now that DK did not realize his feelings till Neetu pointed them out to him... thats why he added a shayad and said pasand not pyar ... also prior to that by the pool side... he did not understand Neetu's allusions till she clearly spelled it out for him.... which means either DK (not Manit ) is a great actor and had been pretending all along or he genuinely had not thought on those lines...

Thats why I said Neetu might have said it in anger... but she did not actually mean it...

Another thing is DKs memories always have more of Dua... Mannat is there by association... till he got to know from her that Vik has moved on that is. He still ended the convo with I see respect for me in Mannats eyes and I am content with it.

My question to you since you can approach this without bias is.... why do you think they added this flip?

If you ask me, a simple solution could have been that DK remains the true supporter but Vik doesnt MU them... meaning he didnt mean those words he said about Mannat and DK pre leap .... the writers could have elevated Vik instantly without dragging DK down... as that is a major point of contention between Mannat and Vik and for the audience who were pissed off with the nature of these allegations.

Now with this flip, it indirectly says Vik was right and Neetus of the world would defend him

I see this only to somehow make it parallel to YV and DM.... that because Vik has a GF (who is surely going to be the manufacturer of cringe in Mumbai) and correlate that with DM.

Originally posted by: truptishree

I thought I am watching Mannat only. Vikrant is the same guy who stood by Mannat against his own family, brought her home against Neetu’s wishes, helped her with Shruti’s treatment , though he was angry at her but stood by her in kids poisoning case , clearly told ARS that he will go to jail instead of her( ya actions speak louder than words or may be I need to check my eyesight because this clearly shows another picture😜)

Wasn’t he the one who pretended to fight with Mannat so they can trap ARS/ Malla when he found out the truth?(silly me again need to check my eyesight😜)

If Vikrant doubted her at least fabricated truth was presented in front of him in form of DK/Mannat’s pictures. As long as I remember Mannat immediately jump to conclusion just by listening to ARS/ Neetu that he slept with Malla. Vikrant at least defended her in front of Vish saying friends do hug each other. We all know his triggered memories and lie was presented to him so he doubted her. I am no way justifying his actions because I know he was wrong.

But how come Mannat doubting him and him doubting her is different? Doubt is a doubt.

For you he is Vamps BDB then it’s okay but for me he is and will always be Mannat’s OG BDB. I respect your POV.

I know I like Vikrant and I can’t say about others but as long as I remember I never defended his wrongdoings. In fact I want him to repent,grovel and redeem himself.

And if you see he is not the only one who is responsible for this mess. All are responsible for it. Even Mannat also. Her share of mistakes may be more or less but yes her mistake is to support a lie and choosing RoTu over Vikrant.

So just like Vikrant I want everyone to realise their share of mistakes and rectify it. Not just Vikrant but they also did wrong with Vikrant.

Like I said I do respect your POV but from your post it’s evident that you don’t care about others POV or even respect it.

At least I have the guts to accept that I am ML fan and even acknowledge his share of mistakes and want him to repent for it but that’s not the case here. So like I said this is public forum and you are entitled for your POV and I respect it.

But I can’t deal with this bias where others are not even ready to acknowledge the mistakes committed by favourites putting their blinkers on and think only in one direction without seeing the other side.

I don’t have energy to deal with this where others can’t respect your POV and don’t have guts to call spade a spade .So don’t bother to reply or even react on my post.

Peace out

Sorry yaar, if I hurt anyone. That was never my intention. I genuinely respect everyone’s opinions—I just poured out what I felt.

I’m still in Team Manvik. What hurts me is that I expected a Kabir Singh–style Vikrant, someone who would stand like a wall to protect Mannat from every villain. Instead, what we’re seeing is the opposite—he expects Mannat to protect him.

That’s what disappoints me the most. The dynamic feels reversed, and it hurts because the potential was so strong.

Originally posted by: Moor278

Purane din yaad aa gaye

Reminded me why team popcorn always had the most fun

Originally posted by: Daman17

I looked at scene different angle. DK has taken care of Mannat and family for years, and after hearing Vik’s name from Dua, Neetu got her senses back and it has triggered her inner turmoil which she couldn’t express. That moment lightened hope in her that her broken family could be restored. Although she had long sensed how DK and Mannat functioned together, Vik’s name revived a possibility she had mentally held on to. The writers used this moment to show a shift in DK’s emotional arc. Neetu’s repeated pushing led DK to finally acknowledge his feelings in front of her while Mannat remains unaware. To Mannat, DK is still just a dependable friend. Neetu questioning DK’s intentions and labelling their relationship only makes Mannat resent Vik more as she feels his presence is the reason Neetu has turned against DK and forgotten his sacrifices. In the dream sequence, Vik apologising to DK is not about DK being mahaan. It reflects Vik’s guilt over his past actions especially the CA incident, which made him believe he had lost his family forever. From his perspective, the apology comes from regret over hurting Mannat and disrupting multiple lives. Neetu knows that Dua is Vikrant and Mannat’s child. She tried to tell Vikrant, but Mannat stopped her due to past trauma, and DK also intervened for Mannat and stopped Neetu meeting Vik. In that heated moment, Neetu accused DK of deliberately keeping Vikrant away, leading DK to admit his feelings while stating he never crossed boundaries and knows Mannat still loves Vikrant. In Neetu’s dream, DK appears as the son she once accepted who was supportive of ManVik. This is not Neetu seeing DK as mahaan but her subconscious mind trying to resolve an uncontrollable reality. DK’s happiness in the dream reflects Neetu’s wish for peace, not DK’s emotional truth. The dream ultimately reveals Neetu’s inner conflict between her son’s past mistakes, Mannat’s pain, DK’s unspoken emotions, and her desire to reunite her family.

Beautiful interpretation of Neetu’s thoughts Daman, I’ve also felt that DK only formed his realisation of affection for Mannat after Neetu’s goaded him into thinking about it, but subconsciously there was a shift in him since Mannat returned from Mumbai and he asked about Vik. Up until then, the Indore set up was ticking along well, but after Mumbai, even if in thought only, Vik greatly upset the balance. This unconscious shift in DK continued as each incident increased, Mannat sharing Vik had ‘moved on’ and finally with Vik’s in person events in Indore and DK’s admission to Neetu.

In Neetu’s dream sequence yesterday, after Vik apologised and hugged Neetu then emotionally embraced Ronnie, DK’s expressions toward Vik were curious. There wasn’t happiness & longing to reunite as there was in RoTu, DK at first was stand-offish, until Vik made the move to ‘apologise’ and they hugged, then DK motioned Vik toward Mannat…….. as it was Neetu’s dream was it her acknowledgment that DK was holding a grudge towards Vik and standing between ManVik but DK knew it was futile so stepped back and brought ManVik together? Then DK and everyone’s happiness.

I absolutely love Bunty so i am very happy.

But the IF hindi video said Kaddu is going to cause a huge problem for Mannat 😔🥺🤬

So she becomes witch number 6(Neetu is back to her Baba Yaga mode)

Originally posted by: moonwearer

I absolutely love Bunty so i am very happy.

But the IF hindi video said Kaddu is going to cause a huge problem for Mannat 😔🥺🤬

So she becomes witch number 6(Neetu is back to her Baba Yaga mode)

I don't know the last time i saw an accurate IF article or video.

In today's bts Guddi spoke about how Dua saved her bunty and Mannat didn't send her to jail and she seemed interest in going along to help.

Maybe she can be a friend to Mannat in due course. With the shift in dynamics with DK who knows.

If they turn her negative then i will be speechless.

Originally posted by: shiro_shinchan

Reminded me why team popcorn always had the most fun

Mujhe aur bhi bahot kuch yaad... blocking, warnings, word censors 😆

vaise iss forum ko chaskameter pe no. 1 banane ko bari aa gai ... Mannat just needs to step foot into Mumbai 😂

Originally posted by: Shazia_h

Beautiful interpretation of Neetu’s thoughts Daman, I’ve also felt that DK only formed his realisation of affection for Mannat after Neetu’s goaded him into thinking about it, but subconsciously there was a shift in him since Mannat returned from Mumbai and he asked about Vik. Up until then, the Indore set up was ticking along well, but after Mumbai, even if in thought only, Vik greatly upset the balance. This unconscious shift in DK continued as each incident increased, Mannat sharing Vik had ‘moved on’ and finally with Vik’s in person events in Indore and DK’s admission to Neetu.

In Neetu’s dream sequence yesterday, after Vik apologised and hugged Neetu then emotionally embraced Ronnie, DK’s expressions toward Vik were curious. There wasn’t happiness & longing to reunite as there was in RoTu, DK at first was stand-offish, until Vik made the move to ‘apologise’ and they hugged, then DK motioned Vik toward Mannat…….. as it was Neetu’s dream was it her acknowledgment that DK was holding a grudge towards Vik and standing between ManVik but DK knew it was futile so stepped back and brought ManVik together? Then DK and everyone’s happiness.

Bold... could be other way around too... that he is genuinely happy for ManVik... but was upset at the allegations and hence it was Vik who should have apologized first 🤔

Originally posted by: Moor278

Bold... could be other way around too... that he is genuinely happy for ManVik... but was upset at the allegations and hence it was Vik who should have apologized first 🤔

Very true !

Originally posted by: Ravisadha

Sorry yaar, if I hurt anyone. That was never my intention. I genuinely respect everyone’s opinions—I just poured out what I felt.

I’m still in Team Manvik. What hurts me is that I expected a Kabir Singh–style Vikrant, someone who would stand like a wall to protect Mannat from every villain. Instead, what we’re seeing is the opposite—he expects Mannat to protect him.

That’s what disappoints me the most. The dynamic feels reversed, and it hurts because the potential was so strong.

It’s okay. I also shouldn’t have lost my cool😜❤️🤗.

Bold-Vikrant don’t want Mannat to protect him . He just wanted her to choose him against those people who did wrong with him. She indeed chose RoTu over him. She supported their lie and even Neetu giving him harmful drugs. If you see he was more hurt by the fact that despite everything she was defending them and chose them over him. And that’s what hurt him the most. He never wanted her to protect him but just be with him when his life took this sudden turn😭

For me Vikrant will always be her BDB and it’s just right now he is fallen angel but he will rise again 🤞🧿. Even I want to see his angry young man persona . Hope very soon we will see that but for that some truth has to come out🤞. Because not just him but Mannat was also manipulated by vamps.

Just like you I also want to see ManVik together. Hope Mukta Mata realises that viewers watch this show for them not for vamps or sidekicks 🤞🤬

❤️🤗