Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 38 - Page 51

Episode Discussions

Created

Last reply

Replies

807

Views

28k

Users

25

Likes

3.7k

Frequent Posters

Moor278 thumbnail
Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 9
Posted: a day ago

At the risk of sounding extremely negative for Vikrant and being called a hater...

all these repeated assertions maybe for Viks easy forgiveness from the hands of Indore gang... he will get a very easy and very quick clean chit simply because he was fooled and did not mean anything he said to them...

Vik will get acceptance without having move a molehill forget a mountain. smiley44.... one clean swoop 🙄


And I hope I am grossly grossly grossly wrong in this...

If there is anything I am excited to see is how Vik wins back his girls.... smiley27 (i dont mean neetu 😜)

ChaoticTangles thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: a day ago

Originally posted by: Moor278

At the risk of sounding extremely negative for Vikrant and being called a hater...

all these repeated assertions maybe for Viks easy forgiveness from the hands of Indore gang... he will get a very easy and very quick clean chit simply because he was fooled and did not mean anything he said to them...

Vik will get acceptance without having move a molehill forget a mountain. smiley44.... one clean swoop 🙄


And I hope I am grossly grossly grossly wrong in this...

If there is anything I am excited to see is how Vik wins back his girls.... smiley27 (i dont mean neetu 😜)

Pink: Lolsmiley37smiley37

Bold: This is the issue with mannat makers, they only can go two sides of extremes... Either villainize vik or completely absolve him of his mistakes by making mannat forgive him easily.... without proper redemption..

I too want vik's proper redemption.. Not a quick one.. But at same time I don't want makers to crucify vik like this with single sided narrative..

If they don't plan for manvik end game then it's fine, it's their choice but if at all they want manvik as endgame they need to work on vik's side story too.. warna people have already started going increasingly wary about vik.. and soon they wouldn't want manvik reunion and if there is no manvik reunion then nobody will be interested in vamps exposal of their lies, because vamps exposal will lead to manvik reunion, if people are not interested in manvik reunion then why will they be interested in vamps truth revelations... Then writers entire work to build post leap story line by introducing so many vamps will go in vain...

I hope we see a change in style of narration to a bit more balanced one.. 🤞

Bettyscar thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: a day ago

Originally posted by: Daman17

Latest update: Bunty and Dua try to handle a serious situation when a speeding vehicle puts Bunty’s life in danger. Dua shows courage and manages to save him. In the process, she exposes Yuvi’s bullying by using his own arrogance against him. Later, Dua even saves him who had earlier tried to harm her. Meanwhile, Neetu’s condition becomes critical, and her life hangs by a thread. Mannat is forced to make a difficult decision and return to Mumbai. Seeing Neetu so unwell, Mannat breaks down emotionally and promises to fight fate and not give up on her.

What episode are we now on with this return to mumbai smiley36 We got excited a while back and these 3 episodes don't seem to be coming to an end. From the update does it sound like only Mannat (and possibly Dua) are going to Mumbai and the rest will remain in Indore?

Edited by Bettyscar - a day ago
scarlett22 thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: a day ago

Originally posted by: Bettyscar

What episode are we now on with this return to mumbai smiley36 We got excited a while back and these 3 episodes don't seem to be coming to an end. From the update does it sound like only Mannat (and possibly Dua) are going to Mumbai and the rest will remain in Indore?

The entire Mumbai gang has to see Mannat and Dua now. Unke liye specially this competition is going to happen smiley36



Daman17 thumbnail
Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail

Team Mannat

Posted: a day ago

Dat review, good read

https://x.com/dat_creativez/status/2015724863277994191

Edited by Daman17 - a day ago
nutmeg7 thumbnail
Posted: a day ago

Gonna just enjoy the paida karnewala vs palnewala fight

truptishree thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3

Team Vikrant

Posted: a day ago

Originally posted by: Moor278

Yaar ek hi baat kitni baar likhu main 🤦‍♀️

It was the intentions....

bold... sach gang didnt want Vik to go through what Mannat has gone through... to be told that your mom sold you for money. You are right when you say they could have told the truth with Dadi as witness... but they didnt... when they were the ones on the right side... why???? Because the truth was much much harsher than the lie. Which they wanted to avoid for Vik.

We can rightfully debate on whether he had the right to know... that doesnt what they did was wrong either.

And as audience we dont know for sure how Vik would have reacted.... he might have left all of them and gone to Vish....


Red is the yardstick wala point i mentione to RD .. if Vik can believe Vish who he knows has lied and has met a few days ago... why cant DK... vo unki bio mom hai... extend the same yardstick for both brothers of trusting the mom 🙄


Blue... this doesn't have a logical explanation at all... Ronnie was ready to hand over the property which he did... Malla is a certified liar and criminal... extend the same courtesy to DK trusting Vish which you extend for Vik here when you say he believes her because she claims to have reformed.

Did Vik ever wonder how will RoTu steal a grown up man like himself from his biological mother using money power???? A child was helpless ... a man who is capable of earning his own money cant protect his mother????

Kaise bakwas logic hai ye???

And if thats the case why did RoTu and Mannat sign off everything to never claim it back????


At this point in the story... it wasnt identity issue but became a money issue... why has Vik not accepted the Aman Kumar identity when he was so hurt by Salujas???? Up until Ronnie reminded him of that...


The point I have been making past so many days is plainly this.... not every action of Vik can be justified.... and just like you dont expect any growth from Vik until he finds some truth... same goes for the other side.... they know half truths too... DK wont realise how he was played by Aish till he finds out she is alive....

He didnt anticipate that Malla and Vish were capable of pulling that stunt and they aren't even now... it was Aish all together... who is dead for all characters. Malla and Vish were present in SM throughout... so them pulling off a killing is also unbelievable.


Just because Vik cant be justified doesnt mean other side should be pulled down. You cant deny the fact that Vik was influenced more by the fact that Mannat betrayed him with DK and that made him look at everything with a twisted logic... that was his insecurity which was exploited.


When you lot repeat on extending courtesy and understanding for Vik because he doesnt know full truths ... I am asking the same thing for other side.... how is that difficult to understand?????

The yardstick where I differentiate between DK and Vik is Vik and Vik alone should have a growth in his character and not DK. DK is a sidey not ML.

You know Moor this is an ongoing debate and like last time I said that I do respect your POV but I will stick to mine. I officially hate this character from bottom of my heart and that’s it.

I definitely had a problem with the way they treated this whole Aman fiasco. Just to WW RoTu they turned victim into Villain who abandoned his wife and threw his parents out.

Like you said give BOD to both . Why? If we are doing this then why you say DK’s mistakes are unintentional. Then we can say same about Vikrant. He was manipulated when he was at lowest point in his life. He was hurt by his own people so he also committed mistakes.

DK ,Just because he stood by RoTu and Mannat?

Let us remember that it was him who put onus on Mannat of this truth. He was on his high horse till Dadi landed straight in his arms, the proof he needed . Till then he was doing Vish jaap only 😡.

You know today we felicitated cops who did their duty honestly and with dedication. Vikrant rightly pointed out “disgrace “ DK is in fact a disgrace for being a cop who can’t even do his duty with honesty. He let go of Vish when all the proofs were pointing towards her for torturing Dadi and was trying to kill her.

Chalo at least can give him BOD for ARS. He don’t know that she is alive but what about Vish? Neetu for doing same crime against his bro?

You know I never defended Vikrant for his wrongdoings. If I can’t forgive Neetu for those meds then it’s same for Vikrant. He in fact did wrong by throwing his parents out who love him and gave nice upbringing. If he forgives Neetu and RoTu forgive him then it’s different point all together.

About Mannat it’s upto her. Like I said last time ,If she wants to forgive or not. Wants to stay with him or not. It should be her decision and just because she loves him not for Dua she should decide that for herself not for someone else. But like I said Vikrant deserves to be a part of Dua’s life considering he didn’t know about her and he never rejected her.

About Malla. If Vikrant believe her then Mannat also believed her when she got those divorce papers without thinking that she might be telling a lie. Considering she was going through trauma so was Vikrant. His whole life turned upside down with that truth.

Bold- I am not convinced with that. If Mannat can handle the worst truth of her life then Vikrant also. They all should’ve been there for him as a family. See Mannat had Shruti. Here Vikrant had support of so many people. Like i said last time i wanted to see boat parallel here. His words gave her courage at that time. Her words and support could’ve done the same for him❤️

TBH I am really getting tired of this debate. So you stick to your POV and I will stick to mine😜

So peace out.

❤️🤗

Rdigest thumbnail
Hogwarts Championship 2025 Thumbnail Fashion Feud Participant Thumbnail + 9
Posted: a day ago

I am fed up of the reviews which Mukta shares also now smiley37 promos , reviews are all about ManVik like a dangling carrot, episodes are about unlimited Mahaanta of someone with a small dose of Mumbai gang and their crimessmiley29

truptishree thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3

Team Vikrant

Posted: a day ago

Originally posted by: truptishree

You know Moor this is an ongoing debate and like last time I said that I do respect your POV but I will stick to mine. I officially hate this character from bottom of my heart and that’s it.

I definitely had a problem with the way they treated this whole Aman fiasco. Just to WW RoTu they turned victim into Villain who abandoned his wife and threw his parents out.

Like you said give BOD to both . Why? If we are doing this then why you say DK’s mistakes are unintentional. Then we can say same about Vikrant. He was manipulated when he was at lowest point in his life. He was hurt by his own people so he also committed mistakes.

DK ,Just because he stood by RoTu and Mannat?

Let us remember that it was him who put onus on Mannat of this truth. He was on his high horse till Dadi landed straight in his arms, the proof he needed . Till then he was doing Vish jaap only 😡.

You know today we felicitated cops who did their duty honestly and with dedication. Vikrant rightly pointed out “disgrace “ DK is in fact a disgrace for being a cop who can’t even do his duty with honesty. He let go of Vish when all the proofs were pointing towards her for torturing Dadi and was trying to kill her.

Chalo at least can give him BOD for ARS. He don’t know that she is alive but what about Vish? Neetu for doing same crime against his bro?

You know I never defended Vikrant for his wrongdoings. If I can’t forgive Neetu for those meds then it’s same for Vikrant. He in fact did wrong by throwing his parents out who love him and gave nice upbringing. If he forgives Neetu and RoTu forgive him then it’s different point all together.

About Mannat it’s upto her. Like I said last time ,If she wants to forgive or not. Wants to stay with him or not. It should be her decision and just because she loves him not for Dua she should decide that for herself not for someone else. But like I said Vikrant deserves to be a part of Dua’s life considering he didn’t know about her and he never rejected her.

About Malla. If Vikrant believe her then Mannat also believed her when she got those divorce papers without thinking that she might be telling a lie. Considering she was going through trauma so was Vikrant. His whole life turned upside down with that truth.

Bold- I am not convinced with that. If Mannat can handle the worst truth of her life then Vikrant also. They all should’ve been there for him as a family. See Mannat had Shruti. Here Vikrant had support of so many people. Like i said last time i wanted to see boat parallel here. His words gave her courage at that time. Her words and support could’ve done the same for him❤️

TBH I am really getting tired of this debate. So you stick to your POV and I will stick to mine😜

So peace out.

❤️🤗

Forgot to tag you. Feel free to butt in 🤪smiley2

❤🤗

scarlett22 thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: a day ago

To be very honest guys, I’m getting very bored with whatever they are showing. No matter whose fault it was pre leap, we can go ballistic arguing but truth is the episodes are boring for me, even if Mannat and Adnan are in it.

an elderly woman is sitting in a chair and saying wow this is boring

Related Topics

Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7 ¡ 21 days ago

WRITTEN UPDATES AND DAILY DISCUSSION THREAD NO 37 Welcome to Mannat - Har Khushi Paane Ki EDT

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: Shemer ¡ 6 months ago

Welcome to BTS Thread of MHKPK...

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: purplegirl7 ¡ 1 years ago

Welcome to Chat Corner for Mannat forum We can do gupshup here

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7 ¡ 1 years ago

Permission given by Leprechaun

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7 ¡ 1 months ago

WRITTEN UPDATES AND DAILY DISCUSSION THREAD NO 36 Welcome to Mannat - Har Khushi Paane Ki EDT

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".