Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 38 - Page 49

Few words from a sporadic visiter to the forum

For me the writing of the story matters more than any ship or character. Although, i started with rooting for Mannat and Vikrant, the story and the way it's executed, I really feel they aren't meant to be together. The ghisa pita, soul mates , one love for life despite living years and years apart, maybe if written well works , but this time around nope , doesn't want me to root for them to be together at all

The writing is messed up for th sake of separation, but ultimately what we see on screen is the story of this show, and Vikrant comes off as really really stupid, leave the misunderstanding apart wrt mannat, but unable to find the true vileness of the villains and letting himself be manipulated, self victimization and living as Vikrant saluja after everything, so off puting.

Mannat supporting neetu after everything, stupidest move but atleast she has some dignity and sees people for who they are.

Dhairya is written well, I like him and if mannat and Dk get together i have no issues but so far it's all platonic, and the misplaced blaming of DK is so unwarranted. Vikrant can't even be alone this seven years he needs some girlfriend or the other for what I don't know. Unable to discern the true character of anybody, how is he a businessman.

Eventually Manvik is the endgame, but the journey is gonna be painful with sparring good moments.

https://x.com/estheticsf78170/status/2015529848043692246

Originally posted by: Moor278

The crimes you list down were decisions taken when DK believed Aman needs to be taken back from a murderer family... the decisions he took later (of hiding the truth) were again in Vikrants favour... since he saw Vikku was happy in his make believe family...

I won't list his crimes anymore Moor , because that's a fact he committed all those crimes. Comparing DK's crimes to Malla or ARS or saying he did all those things for Aman doesn't make him a better human being.

Bold - Can I ask who is DK to take decisions on behalf of Vikrant ? Then why did he make such hoophoola when Neetu wanted to tell Vikrant about Dua? Only he has a right to take decisions for others lives?

If he truly believed it was for Vikrant's benefit he did all those crimes, he should have then worked for how many ever years it takes to bring out Vish's truth. He caused this along with RoTu which led to Vikrant getting his partial memories back about the accident traumatizing him further.

It's not Vikrant's problem that DK couldn't save Dadi was it? Why should Vikrant trust anyone but Dadi just like DK himself didn't trust anyone but Dadi? Why do we have different set of rules for different characters?

Originally posted by: Moor278

Bold... Neetuji....😁

This is like expecting the same behaviour Malla did...

Stay with mom/Aish/Vish inspite of knowing she has done crimes and supporting her 😆

Enjoy the stolen/snatched riches and be around his brother who doesnt accept him anyway...

And I know you would point out that DK can expose Vishakha... I want to ask how??? Since the same proofs exist which Mannat brought ahead... if he didnt trust Mannat what makes you think he will trust DK???

Those proofs are not good enough to jail Vish either.

As always Vik needs to see with his own eyes for him to accept that there could be an alternate truth...

You dont get this difference between Malla and DK which people/me are trying to tell you... its the intentions...

The crimes you list down were decisions taken when DK believed Aman needs to be taken back from a murderer family... the decisions he took later (of hiding the truth) were again in Vikrants favour... since he saw Vikku was happy in his make believe family...

Sach gang was really trying to avoid the aftermath of that truth reveal... which is exactly what happened.

DK will still look out for Neetu inspite of the harshest words... which the worthless woman wont ever recognise...

He must have been the only earning member when they were thrown out.... and DK need not have taken their responsibility... but he did... as sort of penance for his brothers mistake.... Sadly very few people see it that way 🤐

Another thing to add is DK did try and he tried on many occasions to discuss with Vikrant, to explain to him but we all saw how Vikrant treated him, with feelings bordering on hatred! He completely rejected DK. And after that closed all avenues of discussion by throwing them all out to stay with criminals, liars and gold diggers.

Originally posted by: Rdigest

I won't list his crimes anymore Moor , because that's a fact he committed all those crimes. Comparing DK's crimes to Malla or ARS or saying he did all those things for Aman doesn't make him a better human being.

Bold - Can I ask who is DK to take decisions on behalf of Vikrant ? Then why did he make such hoophoola when Neetu wanted to tell Vikrant about Dua? Only he has a right to take decisions for others lives?

If he truly believed it was for Vikrant's benefit he did all those crimes, he should have then worked for how many ever years it takes to bring out Vish's truth. He caused this along with RoTu which led to Vikrant getting his partial memories back about the accident traumatizing him further.

It's not Vikrant's problem that DK couldn't save Dadi was it? Why should Vikrant trust anyone but Dadi just like DK himself didn't trust anyone but Dadi? Why do we have different set of rules for different characters?

First of all 😁😁😁😁

Red... he didnt... he was ready to leave remember??? Without telling Vik who he was and his relationship... since he realized RoTu were better than Vish and didnt want to disrupt Viks life but the sad truth that Vish sold him.

Green... how???? Proofs remain the same. What more can he collect? And will Vik believe when he already thinks (fed by Vish) DK has some other motives.

Purple... 😁😁😁

Unless you have forgotten... DK RoTu didnt bring out the memories... that was the whole point isn't it why Neetu was drugging Vik???? The memories were brought back by Vishs manipulated and staged video... existence of which was not known to sach gang... they were as taken aback as Vik was.... what they were doing was to control the aftermath... not enhance it.

Blue... yes DK couldn't save Dadi... thats his fault... he didnt anticipate Aish would kill her did he??? Aish was dead for him and Vish was in SM the whole time this was happening.

DK didnt trust Mannat earlier because its difficult to believe that your mom can do this... just like it is for Vik... DK didnt believe Vish would double cross him when she agreed with him that she wont reveal...

I dont have a different yardstick... you do... to you Vik can believe Vish instantly (plus his memories) when he too knows Vish lied to him and has met her for only few days (also Malla supoorts her) but DK cant believe Vish even though he has lived with her for so many years... for both she is their biological mother.... they are not wrong when they trust her... thats the yardstick...

You also dont believe that DK can operate purely from a non platonic feelings for Mannat since he looks coming across better than Vik in this when nothing of the sort has been shown in the episodes.... so far (until the BTS wala hug plays out) we cant say DK has romantic intentions for Mannat.

But DK haters cant accept that... which is a very sad thought in itself... for the show, audience perception in general and the character... 😢

I think what's happening is pure human psychology. When a person loves someone very much and that person betrays them in some way or the other, we many times pin the blame on someone else, a scapegoat, because it suits us to think that way to minimize our hurt, in this case the fall guy happens to be DK and what makes matters worse is the evolution arch of the character. His arch is so glorious whereas the main protagonist's is a complete downfall. The comparison is stark and that's what is pitting DK against Vikrant and making him even more of a fall guy!

Originally posted by: Padmajaan

I think what's happening is pure human psychology. When a person loves someone very much and that person betrays them in some way or the other, we many times pin the blame on someone else, a scapegoat, because it suits us to think that way to minimize our hurt, in this case the fall guy happens to be DK and what makes matters worse is the evolution arch of the character. His arch is so glorious whereas the main protagonist's is a complete downfall. The comparison is stark and that's what is pitting DK against Vikrant and making him even more of a fall guy!

Ditto... 👍

I have been saying this since many days ... the problem is not DK is a good guy.... the problem is he is looking better than Vik.... and neither does the audience trust Mukta that she will give a good redemption to Vik... ye accept nahi kar paa rahe hai log...

I feel contrary since I feel Vik is always protected.... Vik always has to be better than DK tabhi vo ML bola jayega and so far Mukta has always kept a loophole for Vik to save him later on...

Like the birth certificate will come in force now... Mannat never uttered the words pregnant or baby while talking to Vik on the funeral ground... thats the excuse Vik is going to use now.

Writers are giving enough material for Vik to bounce back....

Mukta also knows Adnan has the capability to pull off the track however crap the writing is... 😉

Mannat ke liye ye problem kabhi nahi aayegi kyunki Malla Y dono hi pathetic hai... Mannat is and always will be better than them even with bare minimum writing for her. Her actions need not justification because the other party is extremely horrible.

I myself was not okay when Mannat kidnapped Aish. 😆

Thats why I dont agree when people say Vik is hated by writers or Mukta.... infact writing for him is more difficult than Mannat.

They need to pitch him against Mannat yet have to save him without downgrading Mannat.

Originally posted by: Moor278

First of all 😁😁😁😁

Red... he didnt... he was ready to leave remember??? Without telling Vik who he was and his relationship... since he realized RoTu were better than Vish and didnt want to disrupt Viks life but the sad truth that Vish sold him.

Green... how???? Proofs remain the same. What more can he collect? And will Vik believe when he already thinks (fed by Vish) DK has some other motives.

Purple... 😁😁😁

Unless you have forgotten... DK RoTu didnt bring out the memories... that was the whole point isn't it why Neetu was drugging Vik???? The memories were brought back by Vishs manipulated and staged video... existence of which was not known to sach gang... they were as taken aback as Vik was.... what they were doing was to control the aftermath... not enhance it.

Blue... yes DK couldn't save Dadi... thats his fault... he didnt anticipate Aish would kill her did he??? Aish was dead for him and Vish was in SM the whole time this was happening.

DK didnt trust Mannat earlier because its difficult to believe that your mom can do this... just like it is for Vik... DK didnt believe Vish would double cross him when she agreed with him that she wont reveal...

I dont have a different yardstick... you do... to you Vik can believe Vish instantly (plus his memories) when he too knows Vish lied to him and has met her for only few days (also Malla supoorts her) but DK cant believe Vish even though he has lived with her for so many years... for both she is their biological mother.... they are not wrong when they trust her... thats the yardstick...

You also dont believe that DK can operate purely from a non platonic feelings for Mannat since he looks coming across better than Vik in this when nothing of the sort has been shown in the episodes.... so far (until the BTS wala hug plays out) we cant say DK has romantic intentions for Mannat.

But DK haters cant accept that... which is a very sad thought in itself... for the show, audience perception in general and the character... 😢

Their name is “Sach Gang”, but in reality, they do nothing but lie, hide secrets, and manipulate the truth whenever it suits them.

Originally posted by: Daman17

Latest update: Bunty and Dua try to handle a serious situation when a speeding vehicle puts Bunty’s life in danger. Dua shows courage and manages to save him. In the process, she exposes Yuvi’s bullying by using his own arrogance against him. Later, Dua even saves him who had earlier tried to harm her. Meanwhile, Neetu’s condition becomes critical, and her life hangs by a thread. Mannat is forced to make a difficult decision and return to Mumbai. Seeing Neetu so unwell, Mannat breaks down emotionally and promises to fight fate and not give up on her.

Neetu ko save karna matlab khud ke liye trouble invite karna

Ufff 🤦‍♂️