Seher Hone ko Hai: Episode Discussion thread 1 - Page 32

Originally posted by: jhalak7

In one episode Sultana was shown in OT, doing surgery ( most probably Kawsar's while she was giving birth to Amal)and confessed Fareed that she knows Kawsar is Amal's mother. What does that mean? She stole Amal from OT or ifound her in the parking lot? Parvez mentioned about a dead son( might be Amal. He knows he had a dead son instead of Amal) in one episode and cursed Kawsar. Sultana also told Fareed that if Parvez knew Amal is his daughter he would do the same as he is doing to Seher. Means Parvez never knew Amal's existence. I missed 1/2 initial episodes.So not sure.

It was the initial promo of this serial where Kawsar is with Seher one side and on other side/other screen Maheed( more like anti).

Originally posted by: Darkxmatter

The plot, writer wanted this. Otherwise if seher simply said to mehid or his grandpa I want to be doctor. The marriage would had been canceled.

As for sultana I guess she did not know those are human traffickers.

On the other hand kauthar was just in tite spot. She was bitten, tortured , put captive by her own husband. And mehid shown her his other side. So she does not consider him a good husband. Nor her daughter accepted this marriage.

The only mistake kauthar did is obeying sultana . Someone she barely knew.

As how mehid will find her is simple. Many people saw her face before. And know about there marriage. So one of them will see her snd her to him. Like how the driver returned her to her hone unconscious last time.

Originally posted by: pyar-ishk

I couldn't agree with you more. It's even cause of Kausar, that nikah was rushed. To be honest didn't expect after the nikah Seher mother will still want to runaway instead confronting Parvez in front of everyone how she didn't want the wedding and Seher is underage but nope. Now they're out of the lion den and now in the line fire with human trafficking

The dishonor her and her daughter will receive from it will be too much.

And the husband had the plain tickets. He could reveal them to everyone and say she is a cheater and tried to run away with the help of the doctor. Which is major sin in there religion.

The real fix would had been when the doctor came to the house with the police. But she didn't accept his help that time because of fearing she will be separated from her daughter. She would be free from him. But...

Originally posted by: Aurelia07

Honestly, Kausar is adapting herself to wrong means over here. I am aware of her situation but she should not make her daughter run away after her wedding, if we look at it from a different perspective, it is extremely disgraceful and egregious. And not to mention, Mahid was despondent and blamed himself for trusting a woman and letting her (Seher) in his world. Dada Huzoor also collapsed.. 😞 The fact is true that Sultana did not know about the human trafickers. We will see how Mahid saves both of them next week.

From kauthar prespective mehid is insane and not husband material.

And her daughter is too young to get married.

---

But it is clear the writer or the PH of this serial message to the viewers is for young women to focus about making a career. Instead of early marriages. To be more progressive instead of being house wifes and tying themselves to there religion rules. And for mothers to support there daughters in this endeavor instead of accepting there husbands decisions and commands.

---

I think the TRP are down because of:

- the major of tv audience are in disapprove of the community represented in serial 'muslims'

- or the target audience 'muslims' disapprove of the serial content. Which I mentioned ubove.

Let's see how much this serial will still be in air with the trp.

I stopped watching this show but I still keep looking for updates. Its kinda unfortunate to see this go down the typical route. I really dont understand the choice of the writers here..Why did Mahid fall in love with Seher so soon? He was supposed to be a man who doesn't have any interest in women and an emotionally caged person. I dont understand how he opened up with Seher so soon about his trauma/mother's suicide and how he became so dependent on her. Imo it should have been gradual may be after they both spend enough time with each other.

Im not sure how the makers are planning to take the story forward from here. Now since Seher ran away, a plausible route they can take is a leap so that Seher becomes an adult. But I dont think thats the case here, since Mahi(Kausar) is also not available..Most probably Mahid would save Seher from the human trafficking and in the process gets to know about Seher being underage. Something might happen to Kausar and Mahid might bring Seher home probably to protect her. Which brings me back to the question- if makers always wanted to show Mahid and Seher together (without leap) then they could've taken the og route where both the leads didnt want to get married and could've built their relationship from that point.

Originally posted by: Darkxmatter

The dishonor her and her daughter will receive from it will be too much.

And the husband had the plain tickets. He could reveal them to everyone and say she is a cheater and tried to run away with the help of the doctor. Which is major sin in there religion.

The real fix would had been when the doctor came to the house with the police. But she didn't accept his help that time because of fearing she will be separated from her daughter. She would be free from him. But...

Lol I don't get Kausar at all. She has missed a golden opportunity when Farid brought the cops to their house. She could've filed a domestic violence complaint. How is running away a better option than going to the cops? When she was all alone, I understand she might've hesitated to take that step. But she literally had Dr Farid supporting her. Forget about Dr Farid, she has her own SIL who works in an NGO, who is progressive and supports Seher and Kausar. She could've taken her help too. But no! She just falls in one trap after another. How did she even think of going ahead with Sultana's idea *Major Facepalm*

I also dont understand why she never tried to take divorce from Parvez. I dont think she was financially dependent on Parvez, she is capable of earning her living and she could've obtained Seher's custody. Parvez was anyways interested in his second wife and his son. Kausar too doesnt seem like a person who is submissive enough to stay in an abusive marriage.

One of the major problems with this show- writer has spent all the energy in writing ML's character. The rest of the characters seem like hollow caricatures and one dimensional. The negative characters are too many and are just pure evil for the heck of it. Kausar who is supposed to be the hero of Seher's life (as suggested by promos) is too dumb to be of any help to Seher. And this is very unfortunate

Originally posted by: Darkxmatter

From kauthar prespective mehid is insane and not husband material.

And her daughter is too young to get married.

---

But it is clear the writer or the PH of this serial message to the viewers is for young women to focus about making a career. Instead of early marriages. To be more progressive instead of being house wifes and tying themselves to there religion rules. And for mothers to support there daughters in this endeavor instead of accepting there husbands decisions and commands.

---

I think the TRP are down because of:

- the major of tv audience are in disapprove of the community represented in serial 'muslims'

- or the target audience 'muslims' disapprove of the serial content. Which I mentioned ubove.

Let's see how much this serial will still be in air with the trp.

Originally posted by: Darkxmatter

The dishonor her and her daughter will receive from it will be too much.

And the husband had the plain tickets. He could reveal them to everyone and say she is a cheater and tried to run away with the help of the doctor. Which is major sin in there religion.

The real fix would had been when the doctor came to the house with the police. But she didn't accept his help that time because of fearing she will be separated from her daughter. She would be free from him. But...

Like when Dr Fareed brought police it was such a good opportunity to expose Parvez and more easily help to fulfill Seher’s dream. But I still don't understand why she refused that time! Apart from that whatever she did for Seher in the initial episodes was alright, even when she got upset seeing Seher and Mahid holding hands in the picnic I thought her being upset was actually justified. She didn't want Seher to be distracted, since she didn't know Seher was actually consoling Mahid when he shared the reason behind his trauma.

But then after the airport episode her character was handled kinda strangely. I don't understand why she chose to go back to Parvez when Seher was sent to Delhi, she could have stayed at Fareed’s or Parvez’s sister place and then meet Seher later when she can!

There is a rumour Mahi Vijj might quit Seher for the 50 show, if it's true is this why the focus shifted from Kausar-Seher to Mahid-Seher?!

Not sure what’s going to happen with Sultana next. She clearly lied to Fareed about them not reaching the place and made them run away, but at the same time it feels like Fareed already had some plan in mind. This track is getting interesting and confusing at the same time.

What I’m really waiting for is Mahid finding out the truth — about the entire wedding situation, Sehar’s real age, and how she was tortured by her father. The fact that Parvez and Dada Huzoor already knew about her age and still chose to hide it just to avoid breaking the marriage. Mahid is already so troubled because of his past, and once he realises all this was kept from him by his own family… I feel he’s going to completely shatter 💔

Also, a small doubt — they keep saying Mahid’s father is no more, but did they ever clearly mention what actually happened to him in any episode? I might have missed a few episodes in between.

What do you all think?

Originally posted by: JustRandomGirl

I think Parvez did know that his second child with Kausar was a girl and he wasnt willing to raise another girl, and so he left the baby. Sultana and Fareed then adopted the baby