Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 37 - Page 128

Originally posted by: Rdigest

Betty, They are liar pro max gang. And then they continue to lie Dua herself called DK baba, it was destined and all other nonsense

Vikrant should show no mercy on these liars for a change because I know the sympathy like always will go for Mannat and expectations will be on Vikrant to understand.

How can you call them Liar Gang when their lies are far less than the slithering cobras??

Originally posted by: Resham

Ek baat batao..why is everyone saying Dua is 7 years old..she is a 6 year old child. It was been said in one of the episodes, don't recollect which. Ek saal kyun badhate ho bacchi ka

It was mentioned to the ticket officer when they went to the bus stand and they were searching for her.

That's why at some point i thought she was joining a competition she was too young for.

Originally posted by: Rdigest

Aap nye free pass de diya for another lie what is right for the new born

In the previous episode Mannat told Ronnie, Dua herself chose DK as baba, but this proves it was a lie and they presented this lie to Dua.

Writers too may not remember what they wrote in the last episode 😂. I always have this problem with Indian TV shows -- there is no link with what was said in the previous episodes, as the writers and directors keep changing.

Now, if I want to defend that dialog: Dharya was a father (not being like a father figure), and Dua accepted him as her father with no questions asked. She chose him and didn't look around to fill that gap. If he had acted like a father figure with no real emotions invested, she would have shared a formal relationship with him.

A lie is much better when the truth is much more life-altering and dangerous.

I remember arguing with some friends when this leap news and spoiler came out that DK will give his name on baby's birth certificate... and I had said that Mannat should name Vikrant or Aman as biological father...

It led to arguments then as Vikrant was at his worst and my friends thought I was wrong... Vik doesnt deserve to be a father when he is going to reject a child and CA the mother.

There was talk about society and how Shruti raised Mannat alone.. but Shruti had invented a hypothetical father too...

Anyway I rest my case now... 😁

Buddy Vikrant has not been the parent to Yuvi yet... but he has to be for Dua... which is where his growth lies... mere DNA contribution doesnt count.

Though this conversation reminds me of this lovely clip...

https://youtube.com/shorts/YeqafIEVcDo

Originally posted by: Kidult104

People expect right and wrong sense from a 6 year old, side characters, female lead but not much from male lead. It gets brushed off as we know him, he is manipulated, this and that. How long? Not once he was shown worried about Neetu when he saw his family turning up. He only remembers Mannat's bitter words to him, tell me, does he remember he slept with her and still left her at the altar? Does he even understand how damaging this is for a girl? Did they once show him pondering over this?

I'm sure Mannat, DK, Ronnie all 3 will get their karma for their lies. Dua might drag them, court will take actions, Vikrant might destroy them again, valid. Especially Mannat will suffer the most as she is the biggest enabler somehow and I trust that she will sustain it all. Unlike gaslighting, she will take it on herself but all she will worry for her child. Anyone here can give gurantee on Vikrant's behalf that he will be able to take care of his own kid? Is he capable enough to do that? I can see Mannat fighting the most during custody given Vikrant has kept some pathetic people around him. Each one of them have attacked Mannat, so her fighting back will be truly justified for her child's safety.

The major flaw of Vikrant is, lack of introspection. He is saying mere paas kuch bhi nahi hai. "Kyu?" Why you dont have it? Why he never thinks that way? According to him, he cut off all the wrong people and surrounded himself with the people who are good to him, then why he still whines? This is where he should introspect like any normal human being, but instead of that, he chooses to gaslight others. There is no point of owning your flaws repeatedly if you dont work upon it.

That's the whole point isn't Vikrant is not Dhood kaa dhula , he is extremely volatile and needs to go down the path of redemption and this can happen only if he starts seeing the truth. Here he believes he is the victim and left with nothing which is not wrong from his perspective. How is this wrong if he as a character says so with the information he has on hand?

We are asking Vikrant didn't find out about RoTu did RoTu reach out to Vikrant to see how he was doing all these years?

Bold this is partially true Mannat does gas light , though subtlety not like Vikrant and in your face and both may not even be realizing they are doing this to each other.

Originally posted by: Moor278

did you forget 2 saal ka MBBS degree which also qualifies you for surgery????

Kya Resham tum bhi

Are haan...kaise bhul sakti hun main yeh....

Originally posted by: Daman17

I feel the reason DK and Ronnie stand with Mannat goes back to the pre leap events from the house exit to Shruti’s death, they witnessed how these events completely destroyed Mannat’s life, Shruti’s traumatic death, child denied and then the divorce. All of this led them to form a strong protective wall around her, ensuring she feels safe and supported. Although Rotu and DK are connected to Vik than to Mannat but they chose to stand by her, knowing how difficult is for mannat to survive alone without mother and love of his life so they became her emotional backbone. In the Baby Dua BTS, I felt Mannat seemed lost and behaved a bit differently almost hesitant and unsettled. This makes me feel that she was still dealing with deep trauma up until Dua’s birth. To protect her and shield her from further pain, both Ronnie and DK may have decided not to mention Vik at all considering the immense loss and suffering she had already endured. Let’s see how this unfolds in the upcoming episodes😉

I agree.

If Aman's truth destroyed Vikrant's picture perfect family and made him lash out and disoriented, his reaction, especially him accusing her of affair with his elder brother on their wedding day, and Shruti's death -- her biggest supporter and mother -- altered something in Mannat. Both are no longer the same people who were introduced in episode 1.

And as Kidult said, they are going for hatred to love trope.

Originally posted by: Moor278

I remember arguing with some friends when this leap news and spoiler came out that DK will give his name on baby's birth certificate... and I had said that Mannat should name Vikrant or Aman as biological father...

It led to arguments then as Vikrant was at his worst and my friends thought I was wrong... Vik doesnt deserve to be a father when he is going to reject a child and CA the mother.

There was talk about society and how Shruti raised Mannat alone.. but Shruti had invented a hypothetical father too...

Anyway I rest my case now... 😁

Buddy Vikrant has not been the parent to Yuvi yet... but he has to be for Dua... which is where his growth lies... mere DNA contribution doesnt count.

Though this conversation reminds me of this lovely clip...

https://youtube.com/shorts/YeqafIEVcDo

Moor how can he be a father to a kid who he doesn't know exists so I am with you on this one.

He doesn't even act as a father to poisonous UV

Originally posted by: Daman17

I feel the reason DK and Ronnie stand with Mannat goes back to the pre leap events from the house exit to Shruti’s death, they witnessed how these events completely destroyed Mannat’s life, Shruti’s traumatic death, child denied and then the divorce. All of this led them to form a strong protective wall around her, ensuring she feels safe and supported. Although Rotu and DK are connected to Vik than to Mannat but they chose to stand by her, knowing how difficult is for mannat to survive alone without mother and love of his life so they became her emotional backbone. In the Baby Dua BTS, I felt Mannat seemed lost and behaved a bit differently almost hesitant and unsettled. This makes me feel that she was still dealing with deep trauma up until Dua’s birth. To protect her and shield her from further pain, both Ronnie and DK may have decided not to mention Vik at all considering the immense loss and suffering she had already endured. Let’s see how this unfolds in the upcoming episodes😉

Good that Ronnie is standing with Mannat and she deserves his support and I would be mad if he switcha to Vikrant.

I didn't understand DK though, what is your take on his lack of loyalty to the brother he was searching for years and was trapped by his mother now because of his doings ?